Does anyone keep a side-strike chisel for a GP cutting tool?

Status
Not open for further replies.

C0untZer0

Member
Joined
Dec 7, 2010
Messages
5,431
Location
Illinois
These are sometimes called "Construction Knives, Wrecking Knives, Chisel Knives, or Carpentry Chisel."

Dewalt is not the only one who makes one, but this is the one I was looking at. I have a 3.5" folder in my glove compartment but It seems like this chisel can do all of the cutting tasks that I would probably have for a regular knife.





dewalt side strike.jpg
 
The really high profile single-bevel blades don't handle like a typical double-bevel knife blade, or even like a more conservative profile single-bevel blade.

Assuming it comes with some kind of a sheath it might be workable for a general purpose knife.

I'd be interested to see what you think of it after using it a bit.
 
I've done this before.

I dropped my utility knife into a pit and this was the tool at hand.

You can open boxes, pop off zip ties and some other stuff but for the most part you wind up hacking away at everything it got me through the day but I spent all my free time sitting beside the pit with a magnet on a string "fishing"
 
It seems like this chisel can do all of the cutting tasks that I would probably have for a regular knife.

If your normal cutting tasks don't actually require you to cut...maybe. That bevel is very steep for any fine cutting tasks.
 
I picked one up at Home Depot.

I was thinking "What if my nightmare scenario actually happens?" My biggest fear is that I'll be driving down the highway when suddenly I'll want to make a bacon, lettuce and tomato sandwich.

What would I do?

WHAT

WOULD

I

Do ?


SO the fist thing I did was try to make tomato slices with this chisel.

I can tell you that this tool is a lot heavier than any knife of the same size. Its pretty heavy and I can't see carrying this thing around, not even in a cargo pocket. I am going to put it in my car and probably only use it instead of a knife in a situation where using a regular knife could break or chip the blade.

It is meant to be held in the left hand and struck with a mallet or a hammer with the right hand. I found that if I wanted to use it to slice down on something - like a tomato, I had to use it left-handed. If you're going to cut something, the flat side has to face toward the middle of whatever you're cutting and the bevel has to face toward the outside. If you didn't do it this way the bevel would force your blade away from whatever you're cutting and you'd only be able to carve out semi-circle slices.

But anyway, I was able to create tomato slices.

tomato 1.jpg
 
With a lot of grinding, you could rework the profile and edge geometry into a fairly decent knife, albeit with a somewhat unusual blade and handle design.

I took at look at them earlier in the week when I had to run an errand at the local Lowes. What stopped me from buying one, just as an experiment, was that they come in a pack of 3. If I could have gotten just one for maybe $5-$7 I would have probably done it just for fun.

Any idea what the edge hardness is on these? I'm guessing that they are fairly soft given that the back is made to be hammered on, and I doubt that they are differentially heat-treated given the cost. Another point not really in their favor for GP knife use.

By the way, Mora (who else?) makes a "chisel knife" that has a roughly similar profile with a more conventional handle and a blade thickness that is more "knife-like". If this general blade style appeals to you, it might be something that interests you.
 
The steel on those Dewalts leaves a lot to be desired. As a chisel, it chips easily and as a knife it seems to not hold an edge and just seems brittle all around.

The ones sold by woodworking supply houses are probably much much better.
 
The only information on the steel is "tempered carbon chrome steel" that doesn't tell you much. The Dewalt is one of the cheaper ones, but it does have a lifetime warranty with it. Since I'd be using this at times when I wouldn't want to break or chip a knife blade, I probably wouldn't limit my use of it to chiseling wood, so if I did chip it, I probably would be voiding the warranty with the way I'd be using it.

There are cheaper side-stike chisels out there. There is a company called Work Pro that claims that their side-strike chisel is "Drop forged chrome-vanadium steel blade HRC 54-58" but its a Chinese company and I don't believe what Chinese companies say about their products.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top