Hypothetically speaking.... (not shtf)

Status
Not open for further replies.
View attachment 871141
Ruger American Ranch 7.62x39.
I just bought a 20rd mag for it.

Love that set up. A Ruger Ranch is on my next-to-buy list. The 7.62x39 is way up there in the running, but the low recoil and report of the 350 Legend is tempting too, even if it is a brand new round with an unknown lifespan.

I would say that a short barrel bolt gun chambered in a bullet size of over .30 would would suit me fine. A very rugged and simple piece if glass on it, and I would be set.

What I like about the Ruger Ranch is the threaded barrel. Even though I have no plans of jumping through the legal hoops, should there be a tit for tat compromise of an AWB with a hearing protection act should Congress remain split with a democratic president in office, I would be set for quieter plinking yet have something that would handle anything I need to take care of.
 
I, probably like others here, have let political posturing influence my decision making for years. I probably wouldnt own as many AR's if I didnt feel like there was a clock running out on availability. But all semi autos aside, I would probably own a multitude of lever actions, bolt guns, pump shotties and wheel guns.

Seems fairly obvious because that is basically all that's left when you take semi's off the field of play. But as I think about this as I am writing this, I'm through letting these politicians telling me how to spend my gun money. I want to add a few lever guns to my cabinet, wheel guns and bolt guns also....
 
Personally, I'd go for either a lever gun in .357 (or 30-30) or a pump 12 gauge. I can shuck the rounds out of either one in a hurry and I don't know of many critters on earth that can take a 150+ grain bullet or 1.25 ounces of buckshot to the noggin and keep coming to you. Just my opinion...

Mac
 
FN 5.7 Pistol

With non-recoil activated, manually operated slide?


My answer to the scenario is a butter knife, if that's what it takes. The gun is but a tool. The mind is the weapon.

I do own a sword, but I try not to be a nerd about it. My BIL does German HEMA something or other. I always ask if he can parry a .357 yet.:D
 
I never been a rifle guy and it has taken me this long to get an AR so if I had to surrender it I would get the only rifle I’ve ever really wanted to own, a Ruger #1. Probably in 450 Bushmaster.

that plus my SXS and Blackhawk would suit me fine.
 
With non-recoil activated, manually operated slide?




I do own a sword, but I try not to be a nerd about it. My BIL does German HEMA something or other. I always ask if he can parry a .357 yet.:D

Question was semi auto RIFLES

"Don't read much into this, keep it simple. Lets say you live in a state that is going to ban semi auto rifles. (No posturing please.)"
 
Either a lever or a pump in .357 Magnum,,,
Both guns will allow for a decent rate of rapid fire,,,
And the lever guns (for the most part) allow topping off with ammo.

Lever would be my first choice.

Aarond

.
 
Interesting question. I take it you mean a semi-auto ban on “certain” rifle types or how they look. With that said everybody makes a semi-auto in “hunting” configuration…nice wood stock and pretty blue barrel and receiver…take your pick.
 
HBAR. Hillbilly Assault Rifle. - Some form of 30/30 lever gun or possibly a .357 mag version.

Light
Fast handling
Fairly fast cycling
Wide variety of calibers
Scopes/dots are fairly easily mountable on many models
Can be topped off easily.
Short to mid range

A decent lever gun is a perfectly viable defensive/hunting carbine.
 
A bolt gun in a "scout type" set up. I don't adhere to the exact scout rifle concept but like the general idea with some tweaks that I think improve it. I have one each of these, but any compact bolt gun that uses a detachable magazine could work. Either irons or a low powered optic can work.

https://ruger.com/products/americanRifleRanch/specSheets/26965.html with a 2-7X scope on it and the ability to use 10, 20, and 30 round AR magazines

And if a bit more punch is called for I have this

https://ruger.com/products/americanRiflePredator/specSheets/26974.html with a 1-4X scope on it. along with several 3, 5, 6, and 10 round magazines.

Both of these are less expensive and lighter, even with optics, than a lever rifle. They are much faster to reload, more accurate especially at any range beyond 100 yards and hit a lot harder, and are much more rugged and reliable. Ammo, especially 223/5/.56, is much less expensive. And while it is possible to empty the magazine in a random direction faster with a lever action, there is no difference in rate of fire if you throw in the requirement that all of your shots must actually hit the target.

And that is only if you're firing a lever action off hand. From any type of supported position behind cover or prone a bolt gun is FASTER than a lever action for repeat shots. Remember the military had to choose between a bolt and lever action over 100 years ago and the bolt gun won out for all of the above reasons. Lever actions were only a better option in cowboy movies.

I don't see pump rifles as any better. Once again they are only faster if you're not aiming. A bolt gun is just as fast if you have to actually hit the target with each shot. They are still heavier, more expensive, less reliable and slower to operate in any type of supported position or prone. In the real world people don't stand up on their feet in the open and fire at someone who is firing back at them.
Yeah, but you can't go all Chuck Connors with a bolt gun. lol
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top