.45 ACP ammo blemished

Status
Not open for further replies.

herkyguy

Member
Joined
Jul 31, 2009
Messages
1,409
Humbly submit the following question...

I was given 200 rounds of factory Winchester .45 ACP by a good friend moving to DC. He got it from his uncle.. when I saw that it was in Dillon plastic cases, I asked if he knew any more about it. He did not. So I left it at that. Now I know don’t ever shoot someone else’s reloads (and can’t rule out that these are reloads), but I did. It shot fine, no signs of overpressure or anything abnormal.

my question is this, about half of the cases have the corrosion marks on the photo below. I put them all through my tumbler a bit and that smoothed/polished them out enough that I was comfortable shooting them. Like I said, I know, I know, don’t shoot others ammo.

but I can’t figure out how these things may have been stored so that half of them have the same marks, as if they were stored lengthwise in a humid environment or something? It occurred to me that perhaps the factory box had been wrecked by moisture and whoever owned them originally then put them in a plastic case??

Thoughts?
 

Attachments

  • 21129EB0-0F29-4140-BE5B-E4FCA60D1ED8.jpeg
    21129EB0-0F29-4140-BE5B-E4FCA60D1ED8.jpeg
    86.5 KB · Views: 111
I've never seen factory ammo with a ring from the seating stem on the bullet like those in the pic. That would probably tell me they were reloads. That would bother me more than the little bit of corrosion.
 
You have already taken the big risk and tested them. I dont see a reason to do anything other than shoot them now. If you had any issues then I would say take them appart but none were presented.
 
Forgot to mention the ring on the bullets. I kinda figured they were likely reloads
 
You have already taken the big risk and tested them. I dont see a reason to do anything other than shoot them now. If you had any issues then I would say take them appart but none were presented.

Well, kinda.
It only takes that one.

It’s only 200. For the whack of a hammer it may save that 1911 in the picture.
We already know they were stored improperly. And are not actually factory.
We’re they loaded with the same care?

Is this uncle the Uncle William the High Power Expert, or Uncle Bill that doesn’t get to watch the kids anymore?
 
I would say pull them down, better safe than sorry IMO.
Just because some were ok does not mean the others are, and powder does go bad sooner or later.
Any brass that looked bad and didn't clean up I would probably just toss in the recycle can, not like you have thousands of the cases to try to salvage and .45 brass is cheap. (free if your can scrounge it at the range)
 
Last edited:
Sorry to slightly derail...
Reminded me of this Remington ammo I saw for sale, can't believe this is how it's advertised. Even though Remington is bottom of the barrel junk, at least take a picture of something presentable
Screenshot_20180819-092835_Chrome.jpg
I'd scrap the ammo.
Don't know what it is or where it's from, it's just not worth it. Just my .02.
 
When in doubt - throw it out. One of the first things I was taught about reloading.

That said, I would disassemble them. Weigh and measure the bullets. Inspect the brass. Keep what you are sure of and toss the rest. Throw the powder out on the lawn.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top