Tell me why I don't want a 1928 Thompson

Status
Not open for further replies.
Pretty cool if you can afford a real Thompson. I have a dummy Thompson which is pictured in my avatar, which has a phony receiver but other parts are real. I have never seen areal one for sale but broke down and bought a Kahr M1 semiauto version.
Both are heavy and, IMHO, rather clunky guns. But fun and iconic.

Good luck!
 
If you can afford it go for it.
IMHO, guns, cars etc should never be looked at as an investment. Sure you might make some money. But that’s not the fun or the point into owning a classic car or a classic gun. The fun and point is to shoot them and drive them.

If I want to make money, with investments, I buy real estate, precious metals, or buy stocks, bonds and mutual funds.

guns and cars are for enjoying!

so if you can afford it! Go for it!

btw... I’d be happy to buy your sten gun if you need more cash for your to,my gun.
 
I have a dummy Thompson which is pictured in my avatar, which has a phony receiver but other parts are real.
Dummy Thompson receivers come in wildly differing flavors. Some are just solid aluminum blocks that are good only for a display, and that's all they ever will be. Others, such as those from Bob Bower (Philadelphia Ordnance) and Doug Richardson, are made of steel and could theoretically be made into working guns with some additional machining. But they are not cheap. A Richardson "Ultimax" receiver, with all the options (such as markings), will set you back nearly $2,000. Add a parts kit and you could easily spend $4,000 for a dummy gun. But you would be in good shape if and when the Hughes Amendment is ever repealed.
 
As Alexander alluded to.
A 28A1 will be over 20 and a 28 commercial is a big step up from there.
You mentioned a movie gun but not what it is or what they're asking.

20 will definitely put you into a West Hurley, but that buy absolutely will require a visitation (no matter the seller's rep.) and (IMO) a 2-300 round test fire.
I could probably arrange for you to have a drum to test in a West Hurley if need be.

That said, I shoot my 28 more than any other auto. It is a tad heavy but if Johnny Depp can swing one, so can you!
In my experience, the drums are not finicky at all. I did have to do quite a bit of sanding and polishing to get my 100 rd. running reliably,
but my 4 - 50s have worked from day one.

If you do get a 28 with drums, you can contact me for use of a drum grease fitting.
Keeping them properly lubed is a big step in reliability and longevity.

Get what you want and enjoy it.
Good luck with your decisions and have fun shopping, JT
 
Dummy Thompson receivers come in wildly differing flavors. Some are just solid aluminum blocks that are good only for a display, and that's all they ever will be. Others, such as those from Bob Bower (Philadelphia Ordnance) and Doug Richardson, are made of steel and could theoretically be made into working guns with some additional machining. But they are not cheap. A Richardson "Ultimax" receiver, with all the options (such as markings), will set you back nearly $2,000. Add a parts kit and you could easily spend $4,000 for a dummy gun. But you would be in good shape if and when the Hughes Amendment is ever repealed.


I'm afraid mine is just a block of aluminum that was cnced to resemble a Thompson receiver. I never expected or wanted anything more than a wallhanger. Should I get a Philadelphia Ordinance receiver and a good machine shop I might be okay if that Hughes Amendment is ever repealed; the lower has all the internal parts.
 
20 will definitely put you into a West Hurley,
A West Hurley once went through my hands (when I was an SOT dealer, back in the day), and it was definitely not comparable to my wartime-production gun. By now, though, most Westies have been redone so that they work. (One problem, on some of them, was that the Blish lock ramps were machined at the wrong angle. Fixing that involved welding and re-machining.)

There's a two-tier market in Westies: those that have been fixed (by re-machining, if necessary, and also by substituting parts from Russian parts kits), and those that have not been fixed. It's all-important to know which one you are dealing with.
A 28A1 will be over 20 and a 28 commercial is a big step up from there.
And don't forget that an original Colt-manufactured 21 will be even more. They have achieved cult status.
I'm afraid mine is just a block of aluminum that was cnced to resemble a Thompson receiver.
The aluminum dummy receivers can be convincing, from a distance. I was quite impressed when I first saw one, at a military vehicle convention. But then I looked at it more closely. It wasn't threaded for the barrel, which was just a push fit. So I did some research, and found the Phil Ord and Richardson products. Of those two, the Richardson product is head and shoulders above the Phil Ord. (Don't get me wrong; Bob and Doug are friends.) Doug Richardson is up there in age, and is nearly blind, so it's a question how much longer his products will be available. He's trying to shut down his business and/or find a buyer to carry on.
 
No way I would spend $20k on a gun. And I do think Tommy Guns are really cool.

I have a family to support. With $20K, I could buy a few guns on the want list plus a bunch of ammo. Then share the wealth with my fam. College funds and such. But, that’s my situation.

I’m not sure what your financial situation is, but feeding that thing would be quite pricey. I find feeding my 1911s expensive.
 
Everyone is worried about how expensive it is to feed that thing...
Well, maybe at first. I think you'd find that most owners of collectible MGs don't shoot them much. It's a function of the age of the collectors, and the age of the guns. This applies doubly to Thompsons.
 
Hey! Keep it gun related!


- just kidding, I'm jealous so I've gotta vent.

I had an old Harley for a while, now I have kids. My wife never liked me riding a motorcycle because she works at a hospital and has seen some accident victims.so needless to say, she can be a bit over dramatic about the whole thing.

Mine probably isn't a fan, especially after I got hit by the drunk while riding one. Still recovering from it, but I'd be lying if I said I didn't kick over the 67 while there was an external fixater holding my right foot together. Thought about riding it (right hand shift), but realized my left toes would be exposed.

Exactly! My guess is the OP doesn’t have kids or they’re grown and out of the house.

Quite the opposite - 4 and 6 y/os. This spare money is from my injury settlement.
 
The insurance money should be saved in case of medical complications and not toys.

I say this as an acute care therapist who deals with people's lives going sideways after various accidents.

Especially since you said you're still fighting a bone infection.

At least wait a few years.

But that's just me....
 
There are people in this world who will **** all over your hopes and dreams they do this for one reason only. That reason is fear, they are lesser men who would have you live in fear of what if's. As has been discussed in the previous post of supporting one's family and future medical expenses, all that can be said is your family is alive and making it with out the money being spent so it stands to reason they will continue to live the same quality of life if the money is spent. Medical debt is a joke of poor taste that $20,000 will not fix most of the time, my fathers terminal stroke of 7 days in hospital was $500,000 screw big pharmi and their racket. If this is your dream do not crave the approval of lesser men who would have you live in fear, instead seize the opportunity and buy the best Thompson possible. Only proceed if this is what YOU want to do and no one else.
 
With a 67 Triumph Bonneville, 72 BMW R75/5, 04 Triumph Bonneville, 05 Triumph Thruxton, and 18 BMW K1600 GTL, my wife would probably believe I don't need more guns or motorcycles. I disagree. I need the Commando and I probably should get a BMW R90S.

Nice collection there. My 69 Bonneville is still in the boxes I bought it in. One day it will be on the road again. In the mean time I get by riding the 2015 T-100 or the 2014 Tiger 800XC.

received_553622395124035.jpeg

The 2012 SE and 2014 Tiger 800 are the wife's.

Oh and to keep this on topic: Buy the Thompson.
 
My brother’s wife divorced him because he refused to buy her diamond earrings using funds from an accident insurance settlement.

He used the funds for follow-on medical care later in life.
 
With all this Thompson talk reminded me of a Training photo (God I hope they were just training) of the Red Chinese army. If this was live fire it could get real ugly... fast.

b4304aaa4e66b8eaba3afec9a8151f6d.jpg
 
Of the machineguns and sub-machineguns I've shot, the Thompson was honestly the most underwhelming. Maybe I was expecting too much but it struck me as heavy/bulky, yet unexpectedly heavy recoiling and jumpy given the relatively low power chambering. I honestly much preferred the S&W M76 and MP 40 I shot at the same time, not to mention the M16s and ARs. Maybe rent a few before you settle on one to buy.
 
You don't want one because it's just a heavy, unwieldy chunk of .45 ACP. Nothing a pile of mags and a 1911 can't do better. And mags, those drum mags can be a real pain.

Ah, who am I kidding, everybody wants a Tommy gun.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top