Pedersoli has a uniformly good reputation as to quality, but is uniformly more expensive (by hundreds of dollars) than Chiappa (Armi Sport). Chiappa can be hit or miss on quality and/or authenticity. The Chiappa M1861 Springfield is heavier and clunkier than an original, but the Chiappa M1842 is spot on, and is almost indistinguishable from an original.
The Pedersoli M1861 Springfield is made on tooling formerly used to make the Euroarms version. This Pedersoli/Euroarms M1861 is/was closer to an original than the Chiappa is, but is not as close as the (long-discontinued) Japanese Miroku. If you can find a Miroku, buy it. (I have the Pedersoli, Euroarms, and Miroku versions. The Pedersoli and Euroarms versions are identical.)
I think Chiappa does a decent job on the M1853 Enfield. I would not pay the differential to get a Pedersoli in this case. Of course, the best Enfield repro was made by Parker Hale years ago.
The Enfield does have a distinctly different feel when brought to the shoulder than does the Springfield. (The stock is shaped somewhat differently.)