I’m asking because maybe I’m missing a point or two. Am I missing something?
I think the only purpose or function the case serves when fully supported is to hold the bullet, powder and primer in a nice, neat little package (like 38 special in a revolver). That’s it. No pressure holding, at all, what so ever. It’s the chamber, cylinder and breech face that’s holding the case together.
In instances where the case is not fully supported then the part of the case unsupported has to hold pressure. Examples: a 45 ACP in a 1911, or 22 rimfire on the rim.
I wasn’t sure how much case strength was exceeded when a round is fired, so I crunched some numbers for 38 special. The results I got are that the strength of the case wall are exceeded between 4 and 20 times depending on the temper of the brass. So now I’m thinking that when a round goes off, the case strength is exceed by a BUNCH, unless the case has specific enhancements for prevention (like a 45 ACP case thicker walls on the headstamp / rim end where it is not supported in the chamber of a 1911).
Data and numbers I used for the 38 special example are:
View attachment 945818
View attachment 945819
I think the only purpose or function the case serves when fully supported is to hold the bullet, powder and primer in a nice, neat little package (like 38 special in a revolver). That’s it. No pressure holding, at all, what so ever. It’s the chamber, cylinder and breech face that’s holding the case together.
In instances where the case is not fully supported then the part of the case unsupported has to hold pressure. Examples: a 45 ACP in a 1911, or 22 rimfire on the rim.
I wasn’t sure how much case strength was exceeded when a round is fired, so I crunched some numbers for 38 special. The results I got are that the strength of the case wall are exceeded between 4 and 20 times depending on the temper of the brass. So now I’m thinking that when a round goes off, the case strength is exceed by a BUNCH, unless the case has specific enhancements for prevention (like a 45 ACP case thicker walls on the headstamp / rim end where it is not supported in the chamber of a 1911).
Data and numbers I used for the 38 special example are:
View attachment 945818
View attachment 945819
Last edited: