Here is .2 cent from very average shooter, that started with Webley 455, and went through most S&W and Ruger revolvers. Didn't have any Colt, but was shooting friend's Python.So, I'm fantasizing about future firearms to add to the collection. I have no immediate plans, but would like to add a .357 at some point. Looking for suggestions.
The only revolver I have is a S&W 10-7, .38 Special - and I like it, but the service grips are a bit small and the trigger guard kind of pounds my hand a bit. I put some aftemarket grips to try, but it lowers the grip, and it made it easier to shoot, but I was not a fan of the added muzzle flip that came with it.
Knowing this - what are some .357 Magnum revolvers I might want to look at.
So, if you just want 357 revolver, anything you like.
For carry, Ruger Security Six in nice condition. Not too heavy, extremely reliable, tough like tank. Newer SP101 is also a good choice.
For shooting, FA M97, if you can afford. Their 353 on M83 frame is overkill IMO. Otherwise, S&W 686-3 or -4 Target Champion. I prefer -3 or -4 because they don't have MIM parts. Some folks think newer revolvers with MIM parts are OK. However, Clements refuses to work on them http://www.clementscustomguns.com/smithwessonrevolvers.html .
As for frequent shooting, DO NOT shoot a lot of full power 357. Especially be careful with 110, 125 grain bullets with double base powders. These loads will eat forcing cone on any revolver. Load your own using 150-160 grain lead bullet, at 38 Special +P or +P+ level, no more required.
If you want to shoot a lot, and like a nice "bang", like 180 grains bullet, or bit more, at 1100-1200 fps, I would skip 357 magnum and go for 41 magnum; S&W M57/657-3 , -4 or -5 (with firing pin on hammer), or one of Ruger revolvers.
Some will notice that I am mentioning S&W -3, -4 and -5. From what I know, with -3 and up, S&W started using CNC machining and some critical parts are made using harder steel. Since CNC machining makes close tolerance parts, in the most case no hand fitting required, so those parts do not to have bit softer as they use to be on "no dash", -1 and -2. Yes, those early ones are very nice revolvers, nicely fitted. However, old dogs from my former club, who were shooting for decades, told me that old, beautifully fitted revolvers are no mach to new ones in durability and reliability.
Last edited: