Sounds like BS to me. I have used #9 for 50 years and never had an issue on any of my guns. Not my blued, or Nickel plated S&W 2232 kit gun, or any of my SS revolvers. Its a great product. You hear a lot of BS by old timers who think they have some inside track. WD40 is one that gets me. I have used WD for 50 years on guns and its only done what it should do. A light lube, and does protect the metal. I took a half a cup of the stuff [I buy it by the gallon and put it in a spray bottle as needed] put it in a dish and let it set for two months. It got thicker about as thick as 3in1 oil but it never "gummed up" as some will tell it will do. I also took a spoon full and put it on a fry pan and on low heat evaporated it till it was gone. Never left a thing behind as far as gum ect. If you listen to 90 percent of the gun people especially the old set in their ways crowd, you will hear a lot of BS. I was told that WD was water based and will rust your guns, that it will turn to gum and not come of very easily. The only thing WD will do is to loosen up the crud you don't clean because of it being in crevasses and other places then drip out to the exposed area and as the WD evaporates it will leave the concentration of old crud it flushed out. I have used it for ever for lub and metal protection. In fact I took out my first gun I ever bought in 1971. A H&R Plainsman 865 to see if I had the curved or straight mag as they make now repops and I wanted to pick one up while still cheap. The gun looks like the day I carried it out of Giantway shopping center in 71. The metal is as perfect as the day I bought it. I used Hoppies 9 on the bore and WD for lube and surface protection.