Turkish Shotgun Manufacturers All Making the Same Stuff?

Status
Not open for further replies.

cstarr3

Member
Joined
Jan 15, 2012
Messages
118
Greetings All;

There have been a lot of Turkish shotguns on the market (Stoeger, Hatfield, Dickinson, ATI, Armscor, Charles Daly, CZ, Winchester, and even a few Mossbergs). When doing some research, it seems that there are dozens, if not hundreds of shotgun manufacturers in Turkey. I happened to be looking up many of these manufacturers, and a lot of them have certain products that are eerily similar. For example, the RIA Imports has the VR60 and VR80 shotguns, as well as the VRBP100 (which are made, I believe, by Derya). Most of the shotgun manufacturers I checked out have some flavor of the VR60- or VR80-styled shotgun. Many of them had both, and a few of them had a VRBP100-styled bullpup shotgun. Also noteworthy is that at least three of the companies had a revolver .410 shotgun (and even a revolver lever action .410 shotgun). It just seems odd that so many companies are producing what appears to be the same shotguns. Is there any explanation for this? I have thought of a few, but none are really satisfactory:

1) I know that there are many firearms that have entered the public domain, such as the AR-15 and the Reminton 870. As such, it is easy for small companies to produce a proven design without the cost of R&D. However, I find it hard to believe that something like the VR60, VR80, and a bullpup version of these guns are old enough to be public domain, even in Turkey.
2) I know that some governments procure their weapons through state-owned manufacturers, which are often the largest arms company in the country. If there is some major manufacturer of these guns, they could simply be white-labeling them for all these other companies. Of course, I can't think of a reason a state-owned company would put effort into designing a lever-action revolver .410 shotgun.
3) Maybe there are certain designs that are approved for manufacture, or that aren't covered under patent, or that are collaborative efforts, or there are designs commissioned by a government under the condition of no patent being awarded for them. If that is true, I can see many companies using a royalty-free design.
4) Maybe there are geographic regulations that prevent companies from selling their goods outside of a designated area, so designs have to be licensed by a regional manufacturer for the locals to be able to buy them.

Still, none of these explanations fully satisfy my curiosity. So does anybody know why so many Turkish gun companies produce the same styles of shotgun? Also, in a country with only a third of the population of the United States, there seems to be an inordinately large number of firearms manufacturers, more, it would seem, than Europe and the U.S. combined. Any reason for this?

Thanks for your help!
 
Part of the reason that you see so many different AR style shotguns from Turkey is due to their laws. Turkish firearms laws are less restrictive on pistols and shotguns. Rifles are heavily restricted there. That is why we see a lot of AR style shotguns and upper receiver groups (410 uppers). They like AR's there too but it's way easier to have a shotgun than it is to have a rifle.
 
...Also, in a country with only a third of the population of the United States, there seems to be an inordinately large number of firearms manufacturers, more, it would seem, than Europe and the U.S. combined. Any reason for this?

One reason is: that's the way it should be. Eibar, Spain, for just one example had several dozen arms manufacturers within a 50 mile radius in the 1930s, and most of those survived until the latter half of the last century. Another few dozen spread across Spain as well.

A lot of countries consolidated their arms manufacturing for various reasons. France is a good case, where the government divested itself of many state industries in the last 40 years, allowed GIAT (now Nexter after more mergers) to buy up all the previously-independent state arsenals, and then... shut them down. Many of these arsenals were surrounded by smaller makers who produced parts, and some would make entire firearms. Without the big industrial concern to back them and keep the big supply chains working, most of those disappeared. And now France buys German guns for their soldiers because it's patently impossible to simply create the industry again.

Turkey somehow, I presume, avoided a lot of this. Not all of it, as I gather that TISAS and Sarsilmaz at least are partially mergers, and acquisition types of orgs, and quite large. Some is likely the result of, as indicated above, laws. If easy to own shotguns and airguns (it is there) then lots of those makers prosper. If the country outlawed most guns, then you end up with a situation like the UK with almost no extant arms makers.

And: don't be confused by import brands. The same maker imports under many, many different brands, and those change over time, to add even more to the mix.
 
As you suspect a lot of the Turkish shotguns are actually made by the same company but imported by different US companies. Basically if you order a few thousand shotguns from one of these manufacturers they will make whatever slight mods you want so it will appear to be a different gun. For example the same single shot shotgun is imported by ATI, FedArm, Hatfield, and RIA. They will even go so far as to create a new Turkish company name to make it seem like a different manufacturer.
 
I’m not stating this as fact but I believe most Turkish semi-auto gas shotguns are based on Beretta early 300 series models. If so that could make it seem as though different companies were making the same shotgun. I remember there being conjecture that the Weatherby SA-08 and Mossberg SA-20 were the same shotgun but eventually it came out they are made by different companies with different ownership.
 
True, and from what I’ve seen I’ll take a Turkish shotgun over a Brazilian shotgun any day.

I have a Turkish 410 O/U that is pretty well built. The Brand name on it is Gazelle. I Bought it in 2006. It mostly gets used for occasional dove and quail hunting and a handful of skeet rounds per year. It doesn't compete with a Browning or Beretta O/U as far as quality. For what it cost and the amount of shooting I do, it will serve me well for a long time.
 
"True, and from what I’ve seen I’ll take a Turkish shotgun over a Brazilian shotgun any day."
While they have had numerous issues with their single trigger guns, their double trigger models have established a pretty solid reputation. Very popular in cowboy action, and that is tough on guns.
 
I’d still rather have a Turkish made SxS than a Brazilian one, even with double triggers. It might be psychological, I just would.
 
Ive got a stevens 1200 made by AKDAS, and I put 100 or some rounds thru it last two weekend.
Thing shoots well, and is very smooth. Ive shot a benelli SBE2 that a friend owned, as well as your standard 1100, 1187s, brownings etc. and so far I like this one the best.
Savage dropped the gun after a relatively short run, but its still in production and is being sold by.....I cant remember right now, ill go look.
Anyway, from what Ive read it probably isnt as durable as some of the other options, and IM not going to run any magnum class shells thru it. Other than that, its a very nicely made (and surprisingly light) autoloader.
 
So far my Mossberg SA-20 is working pretty well. Just not impressed with the bolt charging handle, or whatever you call it.
 
Unsure of who/where makes the Savage 301's, but after handling and shooting one of those and a $99 Walmart Turkish special, I'd much rather pay the extra $75 for the Savage.
 
Unsure of who/where makes the Savage 301's, but after handling and shooting one of those and a $99 Walmart Turkish special, I'd much rather pay the extra $75 for the Savage.
The Stevens 301 is made by Sun City Machinery in China and is a solid budget gun. The same company makes the Stevens 320 pump action which is based on the Winchester 1300. The $99 single action from Walmart was a Hatfield which is made in Turkey and is junk.
 
Greetings All;

There have been a lot of Turkish shotguns on the market (Stoeger, Hatfield, Dickinson, ATI, Armscor, Charles Daly, CZ, Winchester, and even a few Mossbergs). When doing some research, it seems that there are dozens, if not hundreds of shotgun manufacturers in Turkey. I happened to be looking up many of these manufacturers, and a lot of them have certain products that are eerily similar. For example, the RIA Imports has the VR60 and VR80 shotguns, as well as the VRBP100 (which are made, I believe, by Derya). Most of the shotgun manufacturers I checked out have some flavor of the VR60- or VR80-styled shotgun. Many of them had both, and a few of them had a VRBP100-styled bullpup shotgun. Also noteworthy is that at least three of the companies had a revolver .410 shotgun (and even a revolver lever action .410 shotgun). It just seems odd that so many companies are producing what appears to be the same shotguns. Is there any explanation for this? I have thought of a few, but none are really satisfactory:

1) I know that there are many firearms that have entered the public domain, such as the AR-15 and the Reminton 870. As such, it is easy for small companies to produce a proven design without the cost of R&D. However, I find it hard to believe that something like the VR60, VR80, and a bullpup version of these guns are old enough to be public domain, even in Turkey.
2) I know that some governments procure their weapons through state-owned manufacturers, which are often the largest arms company in the country. If there is some major manufacturer of these guns, they could simply be white-labeling them for all these other companies. Of course, I can't think of a reason a state-owned company would put effort into designing a lever-action revolver .410 shotgun.
3) Maybe there are certain designs that are approved for manufacture, or that aren't covered under patent, or that are collaborative efforts, or there are designs commissioned by a government under the condition of no patent being awarded for them. If that is true, I can see many companies using a royalty-free design.
4) Maybe there are geographic regulations that prevent companies from selling their goods outside of a designated area, so designs have to be licensed by a regional manufacturer for the locals to be able to buy them.

Still, none of these explanations fully satisfy my curiosity. So does anybody know why so many Turkish gun companies produce the same styles of shotgun? Also, in a country with only a third of the population of the United States, there seems to be an inordinately large number of firearms manufacturers, more, it would seem, than Europe and the U.S. combined. Any reason for this?

Thanks for your help!

Ok, necroposting here, but I believe it may be of interest.
The reason why so many turkish manufacturers make very similar shotguns, with very similar components is due to how their gun industry is structured.
Here in the west we mostly have different manufacturers that design and build their own rifles, every component of them. They may outsource the manufacture of details, or use third parties to make components such as stocks, or accessories, but the gun is mainly built in house.
Turkish gun industry is similar to how production was in Europe as well since medieval times up to the most recent period, say later second half of the XX century: there is a thriving cottage industry of manufacturers that build barrels, other build receivers, others again trigger groups, bolts, stocks, magazine tubes etc. Each gun manufacturer then takes the components and builds his own gun. Some manufacturers may build their own receiver, or their own bolt, but they have to be compatible with outsourced parts. This is how they save on costs while keeping quality reasonably good.
For this reason you can buy an Uzkon, and its stock will fit a Hatsan and a Derya equally well... You can sometimes even exchange handguards, trigger groups or even bolts (even if I don't recommend this!).
 
Tristar G2 shotguns are made by Armsan according the the writing on the barrel. Very similar to a Beretta A400 design. They work well.
 
I had a customer that was one of the US authorized factory repair facilities for Hugulu (largest manufacturer of firearms in Turkey). They made or make OEM guns for anyone that will place a large enough order, their name and special serial number run. When they make a run of guns for XYZ they send a list to their warranty repair facilities as part of the contract for production.

They make a very fine shotgun, especially in the higher grades. My customer started automatically pulling the internal parts and heat treating them, particularly the hammers. They are not defective. Due to ammunition expense in Turkey, the Turks do not shoot very much, compared to Americans. I do believe Hugulu has changed the internals in guns made for export to the US.
You might need to inquire as to weather the gun you might want to buy was bought in Turkey by a GI and brought back. That gun might need the internals reheat treated if you intend to shoot it frequently, as in skeet, trap or sporting clays.
 
Greetings All;

There have been a lot of Turkish shotguns on the market (Stoeger, Hatfield, Dickinson, ATI, Armscor, Charles Daly, CZ, Winchester, and even a few Mossbergs). When doing some research, it seems that there are dozens, if not hundreds of shotgun manufacturers in Turkey. I happened to be looking up many of these manufacturers, and a lot of them have certain products that are eerily similar. For example, the RIA Imports has the VR60 and VR80 shotguns, as well as the VRBP100 (which are made, I believe, by Derya). Most of the shotgun manufacturers I checked out have some flavor of the VR60- or VR80-styled shotgun. Many of them had both, and a few of them had a VRBP100-styled bullpup shotgun. Also noteworthy is that at least three of the companies had a revolver .410 shotgun (and even a revolver lever action .410 shotgun). It just seems odd that so many companies are producing what appears to be the same shotguns. Is there any explanation for this? I have thought of a few, but none are really satisfactory:

1) I know that there are many firearms that have entered the public domain, such as the AR-15 and the Reminton 870. As such, it is easy for small companies to produce a proven design without the cost of R&D. However, I find it hard to believe that something like the VR60, VR80, and a bullpup version of these guns are old enough to be public domain, even in Turkey.
2) I know that some governments procure their weapons through state-owned manufacturers, which are often the largest arms company in the country. If there is some major manufacturer of these guns, they could simply be white-labeling them for all these other companies. Of course, I can't think of a reason a state-owned company would put effort into designing a lever-action revolver .410 shotgun.
3) Maybe there are certain designs that are approved for manufacture, or that aren't covered under patent, or that are collaborative efforts, or there are designs commissioned by a government under the condition of no patent being awarded for them. If that is true, I can see many companies using a royalty-free design.
4) Maybe there are geographic regulations that prevent companies from selling their goods outside of a designated area, so designs have to be licensed by a regional manufacturer for the locals to be able to buy them.

Still, none of these explanations fully satisfy my curiosity. So does anybody know why so many Turkish gun companies produce the same styles of shotgun? Also, in a country with only a third of the population of the United States, there seems to be an inordinately large number of firearms manufacturers, more, it would seem, than Europe and the U.S. combined. Any reason for this?

Thanks for your help!
I have been in a lot of Islamic countries. Most have a robust firearms industry. Some of it is black market. For example in Afghanistan they even make weapons with foot powered lathes. Most can make their own explosives. AK for under $20 and RPGs for $50. The US is not even close to the size of firearms as it is within Islamic nations.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top