WTH is this? S&W 28-2 45 acp...

Status
Not open for further replies.
DOC,

Back in the 1970's, a well known gun writer, Skeeter SKELTON wrote in SHOOTING TIMES magazine about converting several handguns into his favorite calibers.
He did a conversion of a .32ACP COLT Pocket Hammerless 1903 model, into .380ACP. They were the same gun, except for the caliber specific parts. He was much fonder of the .380ACP round.

He also did an article about converting .357 magnums into the no longer in production (at that time) .44 Special caliber. Both were 6 shot .357 magnums and were based on the S&W N-frame which was the original gun made for the .44 Special cartridge.S&W and RUGER both switched to the .44 magnum, in their large frame guns.
The S&W used was a model 28. The model 28, was the service grade version of the more expensive model 27. It had a duller finish and was priced to sell to police departments.
I think that all Skeeter needed were the parts, for the model 24, which he could still get. The 4 inch .44 barrel on the model 28 frame with a .44 Special cylinder, made for the model 24, would fit perfectly. Otherwise, you could bore out a .357 magnum cylinder. He never reported any trouble with either gun.
A .45ACP n-frame would start with a .45ACP barrel, like the model 1950 or the thicker, heavier 1955 barrel, but need a new shorter .45 ACP cylinder, but S&W is still making these.
Skeeter was trying to get a regular price on the .44 Special revolvers which were already becoming collectors items in the 1970's. He liked the .44 Special model 24, because it was lighter than the .44 magnum, model 29, which he found to heavy to carry when on uniform police work.

Some other gunsmiths did a .44 Special conversion on the RUGER Security Six, using a 5 shot cylinder, but Mas AYOOB reported that one blew up during one of his Lethal Force class he was teaching.

Jim
 
DOC,

Back in the 1970's, a well known gun writer, Skeeter SKELTON wrote in SHOOTING TIMES magazine about converting several handguns into his favorite calibers.
He did a conversion of a .32ACP COLT Pocket Hammerless 1903 model, into .380ACP. They were the same gun, except for the caliber specific parts. He was much fonder of the .380ACP round.

He also did an article about converting .357 magnums into the no longer in production (at that time) .44 Special caliber. Both were 6 shot .357 magnums and were based on the S&W N-frame which was the original gun made for the .44 Special cartridge.S&W and RUGER both switched to the .44 magnum, in their large frame guns.
The S&W used was a model 28. The model 28, was the service grade version of the more expensive model 27. It had a duller finish and was priced to sell to police departments.
I think that all Skeeter needed were the parts, for the model 24, which he could still get. The 4 inch .44 barrel on the model 28 frame with a .44 Special cylinder, made for the model 24, would fit perfectly. Otherwise, you could bore out a .357 magnum cylinder. He never reported any trouble with either gun.
A .45ACP n-frame would start with a .45ACP barrel, like the model 1950 or the thicker, heavier 1955 barrel, but need a new shorter .45 ACP cylinder, but S&W is still making these.
Skeeter was trying to get a regular price on the .44 Special revolvers which were already becoming collectors items in the 1970's. He liked the .44 Special model 24, because it was lighter than the .44 magnum, model 29, which he found to heavy to carry when on uniform police work.

Some other gunsmiths did a .44 Special conversion on the RUGER Security Six, using a 5 shot cylinder, but Mas AYOOB reported that one blew up during one of his Lethal Force class he was teaching.

Jim


Jim,


Post 24 shows a 45 ACP I built from a Model 28-2. I used the original barrel just had it bored and rifled. Because of variations in dimensions, not all barrel from the Model 28-x could be used.


Kevin
 
If reboring barrels was an easy option, I'd probably have my 6" model 27-2 converted to .44 Special. Way cheaper than buying a nice 1950 and a better result to boot!
 
Having learned to never say "never" - or, "always" - where gun production is concerned, I'd sure like to see the side of that box.

It may well not apply to that pistol but, just the same, I'd like to see what the box went to.


Todd.
That looks like a modern plastic box; not something that would have come on that gun originally, no matter what it was.
 
There are still revolversmiths around that will do such conversions. Mark Hartshorne did a .41mag conversion on this 28-2 for me a few hears ago. The gun was beat and some bubba-smith had messed with it. I sourced a titanium M357 .41mag cyl from Numrich's and a nice 4" M58 barrel of ebay. Sent the gun and parts to Mark and had him turn it into a useful 3" .41mag that I could carry in the woods and around my farm and not have to worry about roughing it up.
upload_2021-5-6_22-15-49.png



This 28-2 .45acp conversion was done by Marc Krebs around 1987, lots of interesting details on this gun.
upload_2021-5-6_22-18-23.png
 
A mishmash mix master of good parts assembled by an unknown gunsmith. It could be a great gun, or it could be a non working piece of junk. The only way to know is to handle it in person and take it to the range. but I see several people were willing to risk $1100 on it sight unseen.
 
Like the others have stated, using a M-28 as a donor for other calibers was pretty common at one time. I once passed on one that was converted to 44 special and I'm still kicking myself! The workmanship looked really good and I still think about it at times.
 
In the 70s when you could not get a big bore S&W that wasn't a magnum and .44 and .41 mags were twice retail on the used market many 28s were sacrificed for .44s and .45s. I even had one done in .45Colt and a 1955 cylinder fit to it for a convertible...

There is a good chance the buyer has no clue it is a custom. The seller did not say either way and only said it was a 28-2 in .45acp. It wasn't what he said it was what he didn't say..........
 
Last edited:
index.php
Pretty sure you can tell those are not .357 holes behind that Model 28 barrel.

This .44 Special mod was done on a former Georgia Highway Patrol Model 28 in the Atlanta area in the mid 1970's while Model 24s were not available.

In this case the barrel was bored and lined.

I think "Skeeter" would have given it a thumbs up.

I rather imagine a M25 barrel was a lot cheaper in 1975 than they are now and can easily see someone having a barrel swap and either modifiying the M28 cylinder or fitting a M25/ 1917 cylinder to make a "Custom M25"

-kBob
 
Last edited:
I bought 10 of those GSP M-28s from a dealer in Shotgun News in the late 70s. I made several customs and sold some for a small profit.....
index.php
Pretty sure you can tell those are not .357 holes behind that Model 28 barrel.

This .44 Special mod was done on a former Georgia Highway Patrol Model 28 in the Atlanta area in the mid 1970's while Model 24s were not available.

In this case the barrel was bored and lined.

I think "Skeeter" would have given it a thumbs up.

I rather imagine a M25 barrel was a lot cheaper in 1975 than they are now and can easily see someone having a barrel swap and either modifiying the M28 cylinder or fitting a M25/ 1917 cylinder to make a "Custom M25"

-kBob
 
Well, well, well, look what I got.

I had been searching for a Model 25 in 45 ACP but they are all north of $1200 no matter condition. So, I threw in a low bid on this Model 25-15 in 45LC (a cartridge that I also like a lot) and, low and behold, I won.

NOS, looks nice. Will start another thread when I have it to hand.

https://www.gunbroker.com/Item/900502940
 
Congratulations!!!

Granted it is no ACP but it is still a S&W!

I am sure you will enjoy it. This vintage has the corrected throats so reloading should be straight forward.

Kevin
 
Well, well, well, look what I got.

I had been searching for a Model 25 in 45 ACP but they are all north of $1200 no matter condition. So, I threw in a low bid on this Model 25-15 in 45LC (a cartridge that I also like a lot) and, low and behold, I won.

NOS, looks nice. Will start another thread when I have it to hand.

https://www.gunbroker.com/Item/900502940

You should have a lot of fun with that 25-15. I have a couple of 25-9's in .45 Colt, a 4" and a 6". They are great revolvers and I like them very much. I carry the .45 Colt Mountain Gun more often as it is stainless, but I like the others more.
 
StrawHat got a good deal on this one, that needs some work but is all there , an easier starting point and accurate as to correct model for what he wants, a British proofed .455 Triplelock bubbaed to .45Colt
index.php

index.php
 
Thank you Gordon! I appreciate you walking me through the world of electronic payment. Much quicker than the old way.

I will be a good caretaker for it.

Kevin
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top