HiTek coating failure?

Status
Not open for further replies.
You did not mention the BHN hardness of the coated bullets you were using.
I use some very similar loads that you are using but I use different hardness bullets depending on the loading.

For Example:
1.) I use 240 grain coated lead bullets with 6.6 grains & 7.0 grains of Unique but I use bullets that are 12 BHN hardness and have no problems. If I used 18 BHN hardness bullets, I had leading.

2.) I also use Accurate #9 (19.0 Gr) for hotter magnum loads but use 18 BHN hardness 240 grain bullets with no problem but if I would use 12 BHN hardness 240 grain bullets, I would have problems.

I have never used Accurate #5 powder.
 
You did not mention the BHN hardness of the coated bullets you were using.
I use some very similar loads that you are using but I use different hardness bullets depending on the loading.

For Example:
1.) I use 240 grain coated lead bullets with 6.6 grains & 7.0 grains of Unique but I use bullets that are 12 BHN hardness and have no problems. If I used 18 BHN hardness bullets, I had leading.

2.) I also use Accurate #9 (19.0 Gr) for hotter magnum loads but use 18 BHN hardness 240 grain bullets with no problem but if I would use 12 BHN hardness 240 grain bullets, I would have problems.

I have never used Accurate #5 powder.

These are supposed to be 13BHN according to the maker. It's strange that I have never had these problems, except for this company. I had to send my Alaskan back to the factory today, but rest assured when I get it back, I'll be back to shooting it.

I'd like to figure out what is going on. It's 2 different guns, 2 different people loading them (me and my father), 2 different die sets, 2 or more different powders, both 44 specials and 44 magnums. The easy thing would be to melt em, cast em, and powdercoat em and not have to worry about it. But on the other hand, I'd still like to know what is going on with them.
 
By chance do you load for 44? If so, PM me and I'll send off 100 and I'd love to see what you come up with. This is the second time I've had problems, in 2 different calibers, from this company. I guess I won't be ordering any more from them.
I don't do 44s anymore, @jmorris covered it pretty well. I use the dry powder type hi tek for my cast and also use bullets from mbc, ckb & Brazos - no problems. Typically I use a lot of alliant 2400 & imr4198 but also use my fair share of hodgdons clays , h110, trailboss .

My impression is that the coating is off. I see you're in Illinois , by chance are you in northern IL ? If so definitely check out ckb, he's got a farm out near Harvard and makes great bullets. He's a super friendly guy and if you stopped by for a box of bullets in sure he'll talk to you a while and his bullets are for sure good to go. Reason I know he's doing it all right is that I've sent some of hos 250 grain rnfp .452 bullets out at 1850 fps and had no issue.

My opinion is that of the bullets I've bought , Brazos is the least consistent and a lot of them are wrinkled but they work fine and don't leave residue either .

I'm interested in this thread as I shoot a lot of coated bullets and I'm sure we can get this thing figured out.
 
I don't do 44s anymore, @jmorris covered it pretty well. I use the dry powder type hi tek for my cast and also use bullets from mbc, ckb & Brazos - no problems. Typically I use a lot of alliant 2400 & imr4198 but also use my fair share of hodgdons clays , h110, trailboss .

My impression is that the coating is off. I see you're in Illinois , by chance are you in northern IL ? If so definitely check out ckb, he's got a farm out near Harvard and makes great bullets. He's a super friendly guy and if you stopped by for a box of bullets in sure he'll talk to you a while and his bullets are for sure good to go. Reason I know he's doing it all right is that I've sent some of hos 250 grain rnfp .452 bullets out at 1850 fps and had no issue.

My opinion is that of the bullets I've bought , Brazos is the least consistent and a lot of them are wrinkled but they work fine and don't leave residue either .

I'm interested in this thread as I shoot a lot of coated bullets and I'm sure we can get this thing figured out.


I am in Northern Illinois, but on the western side. I have never heard of ckb bullets. I will be ordering some to try later tonight or tomorrow, so thanks for the suggestion. I don't mind casting, but it's nice to buy some once in a while too.
 
Well here is my unscientific scientific test lol. I aimed a torch between the 2 bullets. Both coatings deformed but the Hi-Tek gave out completely and lead started pouring out the bottom. Not sure why, but it was probably the most entertaining part of my day today lol. Man, I need to get out more...... Screenshot_20220419-203732_Gallery.jpg

And here is a video. Not sure why the quality is so bad, but I'm not a YouTube pro either lol.

 
^ There appears to be a mass disparity between the two bullets, not just coating difference.

Identifying all variables can be helpful in analysis of your observations.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top