Should I buy a Winchester Wildcat 22LR?

Status
Not open for further replies.

LiveLife

Member
Joined
Jan 10, 2010
Messages
32,935
Location
Northwest Coast
One of many retirement projects I have pursued now going on a few years is over 40,000 rounds of 22LR testing.

And to better isolate ammunition/firearm specific factors, I bought new 10/22 Collector #3 and T/CR22 then proceeded to capture every 5/10 shot groups to test ammunition accuracy and firearm reliability at 50/100 yards while firearms were broken in over several thousand rounds.

With near 100% reliability of around 25 different brands/weights/lots of ammunition with the exception of Winchester M-22, accurizing of 10/22 and T/CR22 commenced to see how small group sizes could be but after 6500 rounds through 10/22, a surprise ensued.

I didn't expect much from factory 10/22 barrel and anticipated greater accuracy from T/CR22 with KSA bull barrel yet after Vorquartsen trigger upgrade, 10/22 continues to produce around 1/2" groups with CCI SV and Blazer 40 gr and 3/4" groups with Aguila 40 gr ammunition at 50 yards consistently that my work on T/CR22 and KSA bull barrel took a pause.

I recently picked up enough new lots of 22LR to conduct 30+ ammunition comparison testing particularly old/new lot comparison of most popular bulk 22LR out of 10/22 before calling this aspect of retirement project finished.

However, there's more. (I am finding this out with my wife's neverending "Honey do list":D ... Never worked so hard in my life ... grrrrrr ... But after 28 years, what am I to do other than say "Yes, honey"? :p)

A recent trip to the LGS introduced me to Winchester Wildcat. Like T/CR22, Wildcat is 10/22 compatible rifle that comes in 18" and 16.5" barrel lengths. What's interesting is that Wildcat was specifically designed around 10/22 10 round rotatry and various aftermarket magazines - https://www.americanrifleman.org/content/winchester-wildcat-22-sr-a-21st-century-rimfire/

But here is my concern ... Americanrifleman accuracy testing showed smaller 1.2" to 1.8" groups and larger 1.3" to 2.0" groups at 50 yards. I understand that only Winchester ammunition were tested and for me other brands of ammunition produced smaller groups like CCI and Aguila.

I am thinking about getting the shorter 16.5" model for less barrel harmonics but Americanrifleman tested the 16.5" barrel model ... :oops:

So, should I buy the Wildcat? I do have a lot of 10/22 and Butler Creek magazines and that's one of the draw towards the Wildcat. But there are other rifles that are 10/22 magazine compatible.

What has been the accuracy experience of THR members who bought the Wildcat?
 
Last edited:
Only heard through grapevine that they [Wildcats] may be ammo sensitive. Enjoy your retirement activities and data collection!
 
Several 10/22 here however when doing testing similar to your project, picked up a Ruger Precision Rimfire in 22LR. Mag compatible, very adjustable and accurate.
 
Don't actually own one, so you should probably stop reading now :)

I do really like this Winchester's lower assembly design, since my biggest headache with the 10/22 has always been removing and replacing the bolt for thorough receiver cleaning. Dropping the assembly should make cleaning the barrel from the rear a very simple task. Presumably they've done enough destructive testing to prove that the chosen polymer is adequately durable.

My main reservation is that the barrel appears incompatible with the 10/22 and hence the wide aftermarket choices in alternative/replacement barrels.
 
The B22 magazines are different than the ruger mags. 10/22 mags won’t work in it.

I took a look at a wildcat in the store and although it has some neat features, it felt like it was made by the same people as nerf guns and looks like it was styled by them as well.
 
I do really like this Winchester's lower assembly design, since my biggest headache with the 10/22 has always been removing and replacing the bolt for thorough receiver cleaning. Dropping the assembly should make cleaning the barrel from the rear a very simple task. Presumably they've done enough destructive testing to prove that the chosen polymer is adequately durable.
This guy did a long (ish) term test:

This guy shot 1/2 inch groups at 50 yards with one
After some thought, I think I will extend my "retirement 22LR project" a bit more and make it more comprehensive.

So I decided to buy both Winchester Wildcat and Savage B22 Precision to run the Wildcat through paces (For THR members interested in another 10/22 compatible rifle) and use the B22 Precision for comparison of 22LR accuracy.

Thanks for the comments!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top