Question about this "bottle opener"

Status
Not open for further replies.

Rockfarm

Member
Joined
Jan 23, 2013
Messages
14
Location
Palmares, Costa Rica
I ordered this year's ago from Picaroon tools because it looked cool. Solid SS and neat design that can open a bottle or turn a bit. The leather part I made to hold a Philips and flathead with the tool.
My question is, if you held it properly (not jammed up against your knuckles) would the design hurt your hand with a punch? I've never messed with knuckles, not planning on carrying this but I am curious. What do you guys think? IMG_20220808_101513_912.jpg IMG_20220808_101542_398.jpg IMG_20220808_101648_322.jpg
It's definitely not comfortable to hold in a fist! Lol
 
Most people don't know how to punch and just think that throwing bombs is it. They usually break their ring and pinky fingers because of this.

You should hit with your index and middle fingers taking most of the impact.

A decent set of brass knuckles should protect you from breaking any fingers. That and apply the most damage to whomever you happen to hit.
 
It's definitely not comfortable to hold in a fist!
would the design hurt your hand with a punch?

I think you can figure this one out. ;)

If you're still not sure, punch a pillow tied up to a tree and tell us the result.

Or look at the characteristics of these vintage brass knuckles for comparison to your bottle opener.
ef7f14de0484eaef75a5a8b56c09b4cc.jpg
 
Last edited:
I'm sure that's the intention . pretty gruesome stuff though, should never be done unless you plan to kill the person you'd be hitting.
 
Interesting thoughts... but still, call it a "bottle opener" or a "keychain ornament" it's what it can be used for that might cause some indigestion for your lawyer - much less how your hand would fare if you actually used it up close and personal... For anyone wanting to do a bit of experimenting I'd recommend a tree as your striking post - do it at slow speed then gradually step up the pace and the force to find out exactly what your hands can take... I actually worked on the street towards the end of the times when cops carried black jacks or slappers, or "thumpers". I found that my reluctance to go all out with one greatly limited their utility.... About halfway through my career we also learned the hard way that nice heavy flashlights made from machined aluminum bar stock could all too easily be used to kill instead of just subdue (the infamous MacDuffy case down here in south Florida). When years later the California incident that caused so much trouble left us wondering why those officers didn't get the message that we'd been forced to learn over MacDuffy...

Having been on the scene in various altercations (as often as possible before anyone did something foolish...) the weapons in the possession or one or the other individual might actually tip the scales towards an arrest as opposed to "put that away sir before you get yourself a ride downtown..."

I don't miss "street life" even though I waded through it for a career in law enforcement... The urge to go armed (or at least equipped) has gotten more than one individual arrested. Must say I preferred the times when we were able to prevent the dance than the times when we took the loser to the ambulance - and the winner to jail...

If possible I hope to hear just what excuses the lawyer for the drunken idiot that attempted to assault the candidate for governor up in New York will bring forth to mitigate the weapon his client had in hand a few weeks ago. Spin it any way you want to - any ordinary person will know at a glance that it's not a "bottle opener"...

One last thought about this sort of weapon... If I was on the receiving end of it -things would get deadly serious before I got struck down (if at all possible....).
 
Most people don't know how to punch and just think that throwing bombs is it. They usually break their ring and pinky fingers because of this.

You should hit with your index and middle fingers taking most of the impact.

100% correct. Even experienced fighters often break these fingers and/or the hand area immediately behind these knuckles- boxers who have developed their hands for this type of impact. These gizmos (any type of knuckle type weapons) are largely useless if one doesn't understand the fundamentals of throwing strikes, unless he/she is just delivering a blind side sucker punch or similar attack. That thing looks like it is almost certain to cause damage to the wearer, IMO, if anything with any resistance (like a head) were the target.
In addition, in a "fist fight", I don't want anything in my hand(s). I would prefer complete use of my hands and all of the fingers for other things like grappling, grabbing, trapping, poking, etc. The only exception might be for one of those WW1 type trench knives. Of course, the purpose of those things was for a doughboy to be able to stab and smash the enemy into a bloody pulp of a pincushion at very close quarters (like after he dropped into a trench in France) resulting in that enemy's messy death, for which no explanation would be required to anyone. Of course, things like various clubs, e-tools, handguns, etc. would also be in play.
 
That’s why I recommended using a tree as your initial impact training post- and starting out with light, half speed strikes to find out just what your hands can stand… depending on the “tool” you’re considering.

Years ago we had a very prominent dojo owner, sensei, and bouncer (in the “bad old days” of Miami Beach and nearby areas)… in my area that was well known for training his bare handed strikes on a solid concrete wall at full speed / force. The calluses on his knuckles were quite noticeable, understatement…
 
That looks like it was designed to pretend to be kinda sorta brass knuckles. While being an absolutely worthless pair of brass knuckles, with enough sharp edges to insure anyone actually trying to use it as brass knuckles will do it once, and not try again.
 
I suggest using some cloth wrapped around a hanging 2 liter bottle full of liquid or sand. People move when hit hard enough, and a lot of striking an immovable object- even if fronted with a cushion- will damage you.

My art had a high-level practitioner who did a lot of striking against hard targets in his younger years, about a century ago. He developed his hands until they became like talons, able to strip pine bark like an animal claw. He advised his primary student that he didn't need to train his hands like that, since the old master lost a lot of use in his hands as he grew older.

Screenshot_20220814-115947~2.png

Yes, this is an extreme case, but be smart. I have on several occasions had hand pain lasting for months because of hitting a hard, immovable object hard enough to level a person.

John
 
If it dosent feel comfortable in the hand, it will likely hurt. Your fingers just hold it in place & your arm & wrist deliver the blow. If it dosent anchor to the lower part of your thumb it will surely hurt you.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top