Jihad Culture
Furious,
When dealing with a culture (or sub-culture) that prizes death in the line of duty (martyrdom), the usual means of deterrence don't work.
You don't get any traction by threatening to kill someone if he actually wants to die.
The threat of death has long been seen as the most severe threat you can make. When death is welcomed, even sought, a different deterrent is needed.
As with any threat, all you want is for them to stop.
You take the action necessary to stop the threat.
With an individual, you can threaten death. If he doesn't stop, you deliver death.
Now, conventionally, that has acted as a cultural deterrent when used against enemies who just wanted real estate.
When the enemy has a goal of complete domination, including extermination of the opposition, and is willing -- even hoping -- to die in the process, the game changes radically.
When contemplating the force needed to stop a foe, when your own extermination is on the line, you don't have time to get squishy.
If that culture lives in fear of dying in the dark, you do your primary fighting at night. If the phobia is plaid skirts, your men wear kilts with the McGregor tartan.
Geneva never had a provision for the kind of thing we're dealing with now.
Our choices are basically, get a handle that gives real leverage over the enemy, or allow the enemy to have the upper hand and allow them to dictate the terms on which the war will be prosecuted.
If the only thing that penetrates is a cultural horror, then that's the thing you're left with.
If you can't get them to back off, eventually you're going to be forced to do something nuclear.
Deterrence can be achieved through respect or fear. Respect is already gone. Fear is something they experience very differently from us.
Unless we just want to give up, we have to achieve deterrence.
Unfortunately, the usual wavelengths used for civilized discourse among nations are not available to us here.
What we're left with is a very very limited number of things that scare them enough to do the job.
I wish it could be some other way.