- Joined
- Jan 28, 2003
- Messages
- 13,329
I don't claim to be the sage on this subject. But I have had the opportunity to shoot some pretty heavy duty hunting rifles and I've developed some fairly strong opinions on the subject.
Lets start by defining what "I" consider a heavy rifle. For the purpose of this conversation lets include all rifles that are dangerous game legal in the majority of the African hunting countries.
With that in mind I'll call the minimum for a heavy rifle a .375H&H. The .45-70 does not qualify in a lever gun because it can not meet the minimum Ftlb energy requirements in most African countries. It can however be pushed into legal DG territory in a Ruger #1. But just barely so we will include it. The minimums for DG in most places is a min of .375 diameter with a min of about 4000Ftlbs energy at the muzzle.
I've been able to spend time behind a few of the grand old DG calibers which include the .375H&H,.376 Styer,.450/400NE, .416 Rem, .458 Win, .458Lott, .450Rigby, .470NE, .460 Weatherby, .500NE,and the .500Jeffery. I've also had the opportunity to shoot an 8 bore falling block cartridge rifle.
I group these rifle in relative recoil groups, The .375 class rifles include all of the various .375's and the lighter .40's like the .404 Jeff and the .450-400 (which are basically the same round one being rimmed the other rimless).
Any and all of these rifles are very manageable and controllable to shoot. With a decent recoil pad and some practice any shooter including the smallest light framed women can handle a rifle in this class with ease and shoot it from any position without a problem. I recently watched a video of a 96 lb girl shooting a buffalo cow in Zimbabwe with a pre 64 M-70 in .375H&H. She had no difficulties except that the muzzle rise was a bit much for her and follow up shots were not as fast as they could have been.
I have spent many hours behind a .375H&H, my M-70 has thousands of rounds through it. I have become so comfortable with a .375 class rifle that I don't even really notice that it recoils at all anymore it is a very pleasant rifle to shoot. The same goes for the .404/.450-400 they are very easy to master and shoot well you can "finesse" shoot this class of rifle with out too much practice.
This class of rifle is the minimum for thick skinned DG and should be considered perfectly adequate as a hunting rifle but less than good as a stopping rifle in close quarters especially where elephant are concerned.
Next category of recoil are the various .416's. These rifles are also not to difficult master but they do take a bit more practice. I haven't spent to much time with the .416's but in my opinion they are the heaviest rifle that should wear a scope they are capable of delivering a stunning blow to the heaviest of animals but are still not to considered as top notch stoppers.
Next we move into the .458 class rifles which include the .458 win the Lott and the various Nitro Express rounds from .450NE up to but not including the .500NE.
I have extensive experience with the .458Lott and the .470NE which for all intensive purposes are equals in every way including stopping power and recoil. These rifles are starting to get into what I consider serious yet manageable recoil levels. The key to shooting rifles in this category and higher is to be able to roll back with the recoil. Trying to shoot this class of rifle from a bench or prone is going to abuse you after a few rounds.
The most comfortable way to shoot these is from a standing position allowing the shoulder to roll back with the recoil. It is also imperative that the shooter has a firm grasp on the fore end to keep muzzle rise to a minimum and keep the rifle from slipping from your grasp. Any rifle in this class can be mastered but it takes time and dedication. Once the shooter becomes comfortable with this class of rifle will be capable of surprising accuracy.
This category of rifle is the minimum that can be considered a stopping rifle. they deliver s stunning blow to any animal encountered. However improper shot placement will not be overcome by horsepower with any rifle, these rounds do provide an increased area of probability for stopping hits. Any of the old time and modern elephant hunters do not consider this class of rifle as a stopper on elephant. They recommend the various .500's for an increased comfort level on elephants.
Moving up to the .500 class rifles and up. I've only had the opportunity to shoot two of these "ultra heavies" the .500NE and the 500 Jeffery. The .500 NE is a noticeable step up from the .470NE in both recoil and performance on big game. However if one is accustomed to shooting the .458 class rifles it not an unmanageable step it just takes more practice. the .500 Jeffery which launches a .510 diameter 540 bullet at just over 2400 FPS also an incredible stopping rifle if you have the fortitude to truly master it. To the unprepared shooter it can be a life changing event.
The buffalo I've seen shot with a .500 Jeffery were truly smashed by the round. It is has an incredible effect on game including elephant as does the .500 NE. But even with these amazing power houses if you don't put the bullet in the goods you are going to have trouble!
With the .500 class rifle I develop a headache after about 6 to ten rounds of range fire. Thus limiting my fun factor. As with all rifles when shooting at game you will not feel the recoil.
Any and all of these rifles can be mastered by any shooter given the desire. Connie Brooks of Barnes bullets shoots a .500NE in Africa and she can't be over 120 lbs.
All of the various gun counter stories we hear about rifles flying from a mans hands, Shooters being bowled over, spun around, broken shoulders, and other gobly gook should be taken for what they are and you should consider the source before banking any of that "information" as reliable.
Last and least I'll briefly mention the .45-70. the .45-70 is a a very minimal DG cartridge in fact in all but the most over boosted loads it does not even make the Ft Lb requirements to be DG legal none of which are safe to fire from a lever gun. I find the .45-70 in a light weight easy to carry rifle to be more punishing to shoot with these hyper ballistic loads than are most of the above mentioned properly stocked balanced and weighted heavy rifles. I own several .45-70's and I love them but they are what they are. And that is a fabulous short range North American game thumper up to and including big bears.
I am not slamming the .45-70 but no matter which way you stretch it you simply cannot make a pony into a horse even if it is a strong fast running pony.
Lets start by defining what "I" consider a heavy rifle. For the purpose of this conversation lets include all rifles that are dangerous game legal in the majority of the African hunting countries.
With that in mind I'll call the minimum for a heavy rifle a .375H&H. The .45-70 does not qualify in a lever gun because it can not meet the minimum Ftlb energy requirements in most African countries. It can however be pushed into legal DG territory in a Ruger #1. But just barely so we will include it. The minimums for DG in most places is a min of .375 diameter with a min of about 4000Ftlbs energy at the muzzle.
I've been able to spend time behind a few of the grand old DG calibers which include the .375H&H,.376 Styer,.450/400NE, .416 Rem, .458 Win, .458Lott, .450Rigby, .470NE, .460 Weatherby, .500NE,and the .500Jeffery. I've also had the opportunity to shoot an 8 bore falling block cartridge rifle.
I group these rifle in relative recoil groups, The .375 class rifles include all of the various .375's and the lighter .40's like the .404 Jeff and the .450-400 (which are basically the same round one being rimmed the other rimless).
Any and all of these rifles are very manageable and controllable to shoot. With a decent recoil pad and some practice any shooter including the smallest light framed women can handle a rifle in this class with ease and shoot it from any position without a problem. I recently watched a video of a 96 lb girl shooting a buffalo cow in Zimbabwe with a pre 64 M-70 in .375H&H. She had no difficulties except that the muzzle rise was a bit much for her and follow up shots were not as fast as they could have been.
I have spent many hours behind a .375H&H, my M-70 has thousands of rounds through it. I have become so comfortable with a .375 class rifle that I don't even really notice that it recoils at all anymore it is a very pleasant rifle to shoot. The same goes for the .404/.450-400 they are very easy to master and shoot well you can "finesse" shoot this class of rifle with out too much practice.
This class of rifle is the minimum for thick skinned DG and should be considered perfectly adequate as a hunting rifle but less than good as a stopping rifle in close quarters especially where elephant are concerned.
Next category of recoil are the various .416's. These rifles are also not to difficult master but they do take a bit more practice. I haven't spent to much time with the .416's but in my opinion they are the heaviest rifle that should wear a scope they are capable of delivering a stunning blow to the heaviest of animals but are still not to considered as top notch stoppers.
Next we move into the .458 class rifles which include the .458 win the Lott and the various Nitro Express rounds from .450NE up to but not including the .500NE.
I have extensive experience with the .458Lott and the .470NE which for all intensive purposes are equals in every way including stopping power and recoil. These rifles are starting to get into what I consider serious yet manageable recoil levels. The key to shooting rifles in this category and higher is to be able to roll back with the recoil. Trying to shoot this class of rifle from a bench or prone is going to abuse you after a few rounds.
The most comfortable way to shoot these is from a standing position allowing the shoulder to roll back with the recoil. It is also imperative that the shooter has a firm grasp on the fore end to keep muzzle rise to a minimum and keep the rifle from slipping from your grasp. Any rifle in this class can be mastered but it takes time and dedication. Once the shooter becomes comfortable with this class of rifle will be capable of surprising accuracy.
This category of rifle is the minimum that can be considered a stopping rifle. they deliver s stunning blow to any animal encountered. However improper shot placement will not be overcome by horsepower with any rifle, these rounds do provide an increased area of probability for stopping hits. Any of the old time and modern elephant hunters do not consider this class of rifle as a stopper on elephant. They recommend the various .500's for an increased comfort level on elephants.
Moving up to the .500 class rifles and up. I've only had the opportunity to shoot two of these "ultra heavies" the .500NE and the 500 Jeffery. The .500 NE is a noticeable step up from the .470NE in both recoil and performance on big game. However if one is accustomed to shooting the .458 class rifles it not an unmanageable step it just takes more practice. the .500 Jeffery which launches a .510 diameter 540 bullet at just over 2400 FPS also an incredible stopping rifle if you have the fortitude to truly master it. To the unprepared shooter it can be a life changing event.
The buffalo I've seen shot with a .500 Jeffery were truly smashed by the round. It is has an incredible effect on game including elephant as does the .500 NE. But even with these amazing power houses if you don't put the bullet in the goods you are going to have trouble!
With the .500 class rifle I develop a headache after about 6 to ten rounds of range fire. Thus limiting my fun factor. As with all rifles when shooting at game you will not feel the recoil.
Any and all of these rifles can be mastered by any shooter given the desire. Connie Brooks of Barnes bullets shoots a .500NE in Africa and she can't be over 120 lbs.
All of the various gun counter stories we hear about rifles flying from a mans hands, Shooters being bowled over, spun around, broken shoulders, and other gobly gook should be taken for what they are and you should consider the source before banking any of that "information" as reliable.
Last and least I'll briefly mention the .45-70. the .45-70 is a a very minimal DG cartridge in fact in all but the most over boosted loads it does not even make the Ft Lb requirements to be DG legal none of which are safe to fire from a lever gun. I find the .45-70 in a light weight easy to carry rifle to be more punishing to shoot with these hyper ballistic loads than are most of the above mentioned properly stocked balanced and weighted heavy rifles. I own several .45-70's and I love them but they are what they are. And that is a fabulous short range North American game thumper up to and including big bears.
I am not slamming the .45-70 but no matter which way you stretch it you simply cannot make a pony into a horse even if it is a strong fast running pony.