what should I do

what shoul I do

  • keep 1911 practice more with draw and safety

    Votes: 28 51.9%
  • sell 1911 get M@P

    Votes: 3 5.6%
  • keep 1911 Get M@P

    Votes: 23 42.6%

  • Total voters
    54
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.

jay43

Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2007
Messages
155
I presently own a S@W 1911PD its a nice gun and I carry it regularly and it conceals quite well. One problem I have with it is the the hammer and the hammer cover dig into me pretty good when I sit, especially in my truckBut I have aways had my doubts on a carry gun with a manual safety like one less gross motor skill that will S&*^ the bed when the S&*^ hits the fan. not to mention that it is getting so expensive to shoot with the 45 ammo. I have had my eye on a S@W M@P 40 for quite some time. Feels great in my hand and is light. What should I do in your opinon. should I sell the 1911 get a M@P. keep the 1911 and just practice more with the draw and safety, or keep the 1911 and buy the M@P
 
I voted to practice more with the pistol you have. It sounds as though there are no glaring problems with the pistol itself, you are just not comfortable with it yet. How long have you carried this pistol?

The cost of all ammo is on the rise. Switching calibers is not going to save a whole lot of $$$ in my estimation.

Switching carry weapons is not as easy as you may think, especially if you are already proficient with the 1911. Two years ago I switched over to an HK USP, and I still don't have the ease of operation that I do with a 1911.

Just my 2 cents.
 
Most, if not all, guns will dig in your side while sitting.

The M&P will probably be even worst, seeing how it has a wider frame and slide.

If you like the 1911, I would get a better holster. I'm assuming IWB, so get a holster with a higher sweat band that will protect your body from the hammer and beavertail safety.

What kind of holster are you currently using?

Steve
 
Did you say you have "TruckButt"? I would take care of that first, it sounds painful just by itself.
I, too, used to have issues with my 1911s and their cursed beavertails sticking me in the side, though I typically carry a different handgun, so I didn't press it.
 
Keep the 1911 and practice more. Then get a good holster with a body shield, that will keey the hammer from digging you in the side. All my holsters have a body shields and they work great (I'm 5'9" and weigh 265lbs, much love handles!!!!).

As for the safety, it's just a matter of training and practice. It won't take very long before it becomes second nature to draw, take safety off, and shoot. There's a lot of BS being spread over the internet about the supposed problems with the safety deactivation during a gunfight. Haven't seen anyone post any bonifide evidence to support the claim.

Get a 22 conversion unit for your 45 and shoot 22s, much cheaper. The best feature is you get to shoot with the same frame and trigger pull, great training aid. I just bought a Kimber 22 conversion unit 3 weeks ago and it works great. Much cheaper than shooting 45s all the time. Any 22 conversion unit should work just fine on your 45. :D
 
Last edited:
As much as I like the M&P, the 1911 - if it is reliable, as yours seems to be - is undeniably slimmer and flatter. I also go with the recommendation to try a holster with a body shield, although any gun worn behind the hip will gouge you when you sit.
 
Ditch the beaver tail I won't have one on a 1911 . I want mime as was designed That way I not being stuck every time I sit. Got by with out them for many a year . See no reason for one now.
 
Dance with who brung ya'.

Something drew you to the 1911 or you wouldn't have bought it. Learn to use it and you'll learn to love it.

Holster fit is a very personal thing. It's not like undershorts where you choose tighty-whiteys or boxers. This is why all of us who've carried for a while have a drawer or shoebox full of unused holsters. Buy a holster with a sweatguard and start your own box or drawer.

Now on to the thumb safety issue. There is no need to overthink it, just use a proper draw stroke and it will solve itself. When you grip the pistol in the holster, place your thumb on top of the safety. As you rotate the muzzle toward the target, move your thumb down. Easy, natural and incorporated into your draw so it won't be an issue of "remembering".
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top