Irish hunting poll

Status
Not open for further replies.

Rovi

Member
Joined
Nov 26, 2004
Messages
124
Location
Ireland
Hi all.

Not strictly a shooting/firearms subject, but it's closely related and has implications for the shooting/firearms community over here.

There's an ongoing controversy going on here in Ireland about an outfit known as the Ward Union Hunt, and their trials and tribulations in renewing their hunt licence.
They participate in an activity known as a 'Carted Stag Hunt,' which involves releasing a semi-tame Red Deer stag into the countryside and chasing it down with horses and hounds. The stag is eventually held at bay by the hounds, re-captured, and returned to the herd.
Think of is as like Fox Hunting with hounds, except with a Red stag who doesn't end up dead at the end.

Latest episode here-
http://www.independent.ie/national-news/anger-over-stag-hunt-ban-1250811.html


Anyhow, I don't have any particular interest in chasing stags (or foxes) on horseback, but this sort of thing has brought out the usual suspects who make no secret of their aims of banning all forms of hunting (including with firearms), and most of them fit snugly into the 'Guns bad, m'kay?' camp too.

As such, we shooters and gun owners tend to lend our support to the other field sports enthusiasts, as we're very much on the same sh** lists of the antis too.
United we stand, divided we fall, and all that.


Can I ask anyone interested to hit an on-line poll from one of our daily newspapers, asking "Do you think stag hunting should be banned?"
It's currently at Yes: 69%, No :31%.
The 'No' vote has been slowly creeping upwards over the last few hours.

You'll find the poll about half way down this page-
[noparse]http://www.independent.ie/[/noparse]


I've voted in support of you guy's gun rights on a bunch of U.S. based polls, so I hope I'm not breaking any rules here by asking this.

Thanks.
 
I'll do it, but it will cost you a Half & Half if I ever get over to Ireland.
 
I am sorry but this is not sport or hunting.I have seen this before in Ireland and does not always end up the way you portray it.Some stags have been ripped apart by the hounds and others have died from sheer fear.Wild stags have a fighting chance-semi tame barbaric.
 
Thanks for the support folks, there's another one here-
[noparse]http://www.ireland.com/[/noparse]

macFarlaine: thanks for reading my post and your response. As I said, I don't participate in this, so I'm going on the information I've gotten from the people who do.
Past experience has taught me to be somewhat sceptical of the information provided by the antis, whereas I personally know plenty of people involved in various field sports and would put much more store on what they tell me.
 
Having this link to click might help you to get a few more people over there to vote

http://www.independent.ie/

BTW- If you order a Half & Half in Ireland and they put Bass in it instead of Harp, is it legal to bust the bartender in the chops?
 
Fair enough Rovi.I am no anti,shooting,fox hunting for forty years.I draw the line at hunting semi tame quarry.By the way I also go stalking in the Scottish Highlands.I will refrain from voting either way.
 
I deliberately left the link as plain text so that the poll servers don't log the links as coming from here, a heavily pro firearms/hunting site.
I've seen on U.S. based polls I've participated in, where the anti side start bleating about 'orchestrated campaigns' to skew the results of 'their' poll.

Of course, if 'their' side aren't interested enough to get organised, what does that tell them about their 'cause?' :rolleyes:
 
It's "up" to 67/33 after I cast my vote. Hopefully, the No votes will continue to rise.
 
Sorry, but I won't vote on that one either.

Hunting an animal to help keep a population in check, or because it's good to eat is one thing... Chasing it around just for the fun of it is just plain dumb and wrong.

I've got nothing against hunting at all, but what amounts to nothing more than animal cruelty for the sake of alleviating human boredom should be banned, in my opinion.


J.C.
 
Just to clarify my own position on this: I'm not overly enamoured with the whole concept of a carted stag hunt (or fox hunting with horse and hound either, for that matter), and I wouldn't be campaigning for their introduction here if they didn't already exist; they do exist however, and I'm uneasy with the cries of "Ban!"
Most of the leading protagonists on the 'Ban' side of this issue are the same groups and individuals who would see all forms of field sports banned, including hunting with firearms; and they range from 'vaguely' to 'virulently' anti-firearms in general.

Most people I know in the shooting/firearms community here are lending their support to the Ward Union Hunt not because they particularly support carted stag hunting, but because they know that their sport is only a little further down the anti's list, and if we stay silent while someone else's sport is under the spotlight, we'll be on our own when our turn comes.

Thanks to everyone for the responses.
 
I voted no, but I'm not easy with the idea of a "semi-tame" deer being tracked either. If you're going to have a hunt, have a hunt, and hunt a wild animal that has all it's wilderness smarts.

Springmom
 
Come on Rovi,this is ideal ammunition for the anti's,and for further recruitment.You release a semi tame deer that on occasion has been hand fed,then you let a pack of dogs who have been bred,fed and fitness trained to out run a unfit stag.This does not look good,sound good and is against all the rules of hunting wild prey.
 
Hey Rovi:

I voted to support the sport, but for the love a God, why employ a half tame deer.....make it fair chase and kill the thing if you can!

I am a dog hunter and I maintain and use a pack of Walker hounds to run deer with so I can really sympathize with you fellows wanting to keep the sport alive....but even I gotta question the use of a nearly tame deer in whats patently a "canned" hunt. Then again, I feel the same way about those Texans that hunt behind fences for "exotic" game....about as much challenge as shootin' a damned barnyard rooster...

And for those of you that doubt it, running deer with dogs is an ancient and honorable tradition. Any of you that think otherwise I'd challenge to hunt as I do with me....you kill a LEGAL buck and I'll give you a c note....a racked buck two of 'em....it is really that DIFFICULT. Any that say otherwise simply don't know what they're talking about because they have never done it and have no understanding!


And Rovi.....my Grandpa who raised me, was born in Co. Caven.....makes me eligible to hold Irish citizenship I'm told.....Wonder what you're anti's take would be on me and those hot runnin' Walkers.......much less that auto loading '06 Browning I use.
 
I did my part but it isn't looking good. 66% in favor if banning it. 34% against banning it.
 
Thanks to everyone for responding, and thanks too to those who felt unable to vote in favour of the hunt, I understand and appreciate your reasons.

As far as I know, Ward Union is the last remaining hunt of this type in these islands (Ireland and Great Britain), and I don't doubt that in time it will go the way of bear and bull baiting; what's giving the shooting fraternity here cause for concern is the way and by whom its immediate demise is sought.

Nobody that I know with an interest in shooting would shed a solitary tear if the Ward Union Hunt were to announce tomorrow that they were folding their tents and stealing away into the night, it's just that for the groups most stridently demanding their ban, killing off the last remaining carted stag hunt is only part of their objectives. Further down their list comes hunting with guns, and then guns in general.

For us shooters, there's more than a bit of "my enemy's enemy is my friend" going on here; a 'victory' for the antis on this one only encourages them to further pursue their agenda.
 
For what its worth, my wife is a foxhunter. Her hunt is a "drag" hunt, they only follow the scent that was laid down earlier in the day. Always seemed kind of pointless to me, but I have ridden them twice and it was a heck of a lot of fun.

Other hunts are live (real fox) and many times they never find a fox at all. If they do it's usually a very fair chase and it is also rare for it to get killed by the hounds.



What is going on here is fruitless and I don't consider it sporting. It's dead into the grea area of animal cruelty. If it's not getting hurt, what can you charge them for?
 
it think that it sounds really fun and sporting

as long as the stag, horses and hounds are well cared for i see no reason why people shouldnt be able to do this

in fact i would love to
 
This doesn't sound very sporting, especially with a semi-tame backyard deer.

Now a bull moose during his rut seems like a more daunting challenge.
 
"It sounds fun and really sporting" please,give us a break,what planet are you from? Anyone who endorses this type of hunting should be ashamed of themselves....
 
"It sounds fun and really sporting" please,give us a break,what planet are you from? Anyone who endorses this type of hunting should be ashamed of themselves....

and

He's not from another planet, MacFarlaine, he's just young and doesn't know any better.

Personal attacks are a short route to thread closure here, y'all. Might want to keep that in mind before this goes bye-bye.

Springmom
 
It wasn't a personal attack on my part, S.M., only an observation based on looking at the person's profile.

As for closing the thread... I'm hard pressed to see where that would really be a bad thing, given that it really doesn't have a thing to do with guns.


J.C.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top