I posted my reply. In doing it, I found a great quote some of you might like.
A fear of weapons is a sign of retarded sexual and emotional maturity. -- Sigmund Freud,
I swear. The hell with finding a cure for cancer we need to put more funds into curing DUMB because it has gotten epidemic.
Does anyone have the right to deprive me of a tactical nuclear missile as long as I promise to use it responsibly. Oops, I was a little irresponsible and killed a lot of people. Or better yet, oops, someone stole it from my home and blew up the neighborhood. But don't blame me for having that dangerous weapon at my house. It's my right, dammit.
That is a reductio ad absurdum logical fallacy, a reduction to the absurd.
By using the same type of logical fallacy, I can claim that if blacks and women want rights, then dogs and cats will want rights too, as well as children and illegal immigrants. If gays can get married, whats to stop gays from marrying little boys? Whats to stop people from marrying animals or robots?
The second amendment isn't about duck hunting. It's about protection from tyrannical governments and threats domestic and abroad. Please find me ONE SINGLE ATTRIBUTABLE QUOTE from our founding fathers that claimed that the right to bear arms is a collective militia right.
You will find NONE.
In fact, all our period publications (Federalist, Anti-Federalist papers), newspapers, speeches, quotes, and literature clearly refer to the right of bearing arms as an individual right.
"Remember towns in the old west where you had to give up your gun?
I hope that my use of logic will help uncloud the eyes and judgment of those who let emotion rule their life.
Posted by: gunsRbad
Comment: #355
Mar 02, 02:56 AM
Report Abuse
Reply
guns make people kill. my cousin was an ok guy but when he was
desperate for drugs he would do anything for money, one day he broke into
a house and an old lady killed him for no reason and she even got away with it.
she told the cops she was afraid of being raped! she was like 50 or 60 and nobody would ever
want to rape an old lady like that. he was just going to take a tv or radio and he broke into houses all
the time, if people cuoperated then he wouldn't hurt them, if they got silly he may of slapped
them but he never killed nobody.
he didn't even have no gun and she killed him as he was climbing through a window, how is that right?
if no one could have guns my cousin would be alive today!
Nice not to have to preach to the choir...
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Reply Posted.
I learned a new word. Hopolophpobe (spelling?): the fear of firearms.
There are some very good posts there, and some very high road comments.
I am impressed.