Pilot's gun discharges on US Airways flight

Status
Not open for further replies.
Correction!:

Heard on the voice recorder:

"I'm the only person in this plane qualified enough to carry a Glock FO-TAY!"
 
I would love to hear that pilot explain himself to the NTSB.

"Well, uh, it's uh... I had uh... Ted Stryker moment. (ahem)"
 
Accidental discharges are about as rare as unicorns. Unless the gun went off all by itself due to mechanical failure, this was a NEGLIGENT DISCHARGE. The good news is that nobody got hurt, the bad news is that the anti's are going to go after the FFDO program using this one minor incident as leverage to cancel or emasculate the entire program.
 
Now the Beardies know our Pilots are packing.
Hmmmm...most of us with beards (and anyone not living in a cave) have known this for years.
What does wearing a beard have to do with it anyway?
Jack
 
H&K had a great deal going on .40 USP Compacts that was only available to pilots, which upset me because when I found out about it I was looking for a USPc and I'm not a pilot.

Frangible bullets eh? Must be EXTREEEEME SHOX AIR FREEDOM DISINTEGRATING TURBO_BULLETS! WITH AWESOME SAUCE!
 
It was an HK USPc .40.

which proves that Glocks are not the only guns that people can fail to follow safety rules with.

Why is that anytime a ND comes up, a whole bunch of people jump on it guessing it was a Glock?

It doesn't matter how many safeties a gun has if you're going to be stupid with it.
 
Vermont Guy, thanks for the article.

What kind of idiot puts a trigger lock on a loaded gun?

The TSA/FCC, that's who.


Edit: I might have to retract my earlier statement.
 

Attachments

  • Holstervault_key_2.jpg
    Holstervault_key_2.jpg
    26.6 KB · Views: 55
Last edited:
Just in case any of you didn't follow the link in Vermont Guy's post - please read this:

The insane procedures required by the TSA demands that our pilots to lock and then un-lock their .40 side arms was and is a solid recipe for disaster. Did the TSA deliberately create this bizarre and unconventional Rube Goldberg firearm retention system hoping for this result? The sordid history of the FAA and TSA’s total resistance to the concept of arming pilots to protect Americans is in itself a scandal.

Putting a gun into a holster and then threading a padlock through the trigger and trigger-guard is required every time the pilots enter or leave the cockpit. This kind of silliness has never been forced on any law enforcement or security officers anywhere in the world until now. Before this holster padlock procedure pilots with guns were forced to carry them around in a cumbersome 22 pound vault. The vault caused problems in the confined space of most cockpits.

FFDO pilots need to carry their side arms in conventional concealed holsters and there is no reason for the unnecessary handling of their firearms in the cockpits.

Vermont Guy: Good job coming up with that info. It seems obvious that threading a padlock through a trigger is likely to cause an accident eventually - and that appears to be what happened. More importantly, trained pilots qualified to carry a firearm are being treated like morons and forced to implement these ridiculous "safety" proceedures that only make the firearm less safe and harder to access in an emergency. Lunacy!
 
Protcol

Thanks for posting again this insane protocol.

This is what happens when folks let emotions rule over common sense and try to appease everyone.

Whiners : "somebody has to do something".
TPTB : "We will do something , but we have to make everyone feel warm and fuzzy".

Quit meddling in how folks protect themselves.

Less is More and applies to rules and regs.
 
Proper training and use of it.. or NOT

...

Every Pilot goes thru extensive training to get the type ticket one holds, be it just a private pilot or ATP rating..

The problem with "Pilot Error" is that when one thinks he has it all clear up in his head, and leaves the check list in its folder, or takes pistol handling and usage courses and fails to lock-in the 4 basic rules that are the foundation of how it will work, correctly, and safely, everytime, goes hand in hand with pilot errors that start with one, 2, and on, of little mistakes that will add-up to a, the, big mistake, and ruin it for all, or many.


Ls
 
The new and improved Rule #3:
Keep your finger off the trigger until ready to fire unless you are ruled by the TSA, then thread a big honkin padlock on through there several times a day. Never mind the fact you're already forced to violate rule #2 on an airplane (since I'm pretty sure there's nothing on the plane you are willing to ventilate).
 
kludge's photo...

I have seen and had this setup in my hands.

If you put the HK in the holster, put the lock through the trigger and then realize the pistol is not fully seated into the holster when you go to snap the thumb break...

You push the pistol down deeper into the holster with the lock in front of the trigger instead of the rear... in turn setting off a round.

This new holster setup is what replaced the heavy lock box.
 
Welcome to The High Road, JeepPunk, and thank you for that detail. It clarifies the picture we're all trying to form in our minds.
 
As Master (post #6) said-spin it right.

It has long been said that a pilot must unholster several time during each flight. Perhaps he was headed to the head and hit the bang switch. They should follow the same rules as the air marshalls-they dont unholster except at the end of the day.
 
Ahem...Since When Do We Believe Everything We Read?

Take it from me: the only time an FFDO who is following proper procedure would have to holster a weapon in an aircraft is if they just drew it on someone.

Or maybe I'm just as much of an expert as the rest of the pundits...guess you'll have to decide that on your own.
 
Dont claim to be an expert...

You dont have to draw your weapon for this to happen with this holster.

Lets say said Captain walks onto the aircraft with the pistol locked in the holster and in his bag. Cockpit door is closed... Captain takes holster out, unlocks, puts on side and gets ready for a 3 hour flight. During flight, said Captain moves around a little due to the seat not being the best for space. Comes time for the FO (First Officer) to land in Charlotte, NC. Said Captain starts to get everything ready to de-plane and is moving again. As far as he is concerned the flight and its risk are over so he takes off his holster, inserts lock, goes to snap down the thumb break and bang... FO is working on landing the aircraft safe knowing a pistol just went off right by him... tense moment.
All the Captain was doing was taking off said holster to have the weapon locked and stored before the cockpit door opened.

Never had it out of the holster but during the flight and all of the movement the Captain did during the flight the weapon shifted just a little.

Now, I dont know what happened, and I do not claim to be said expert or pundit on the incident. But with this setup its easy to do.

To many factors to consider here, and only two people really know what happened.
 
Lots of bad quotes, but some pics

http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20080325/ap_on_re_us/gun_on_plane


Photos show bullet damage to plane

By MITCH WEISS, Associated Press Writer 1 hour, 43 minutes ago

CHARLOTTE, N.C. - The pilot of a US Airways plane may have mishandled a firearm that went off in flight, piercing a hole in the cockpit wall, a federal air marshal said Tuesday.
ADVERTISEMENT

"This is an extremely safe and reliable weapon," said Greg Alter of the Federal Air Marshal Service. "It's not going to discharge on its own, is the bottom line."

The pistol — a .40-caliber semiautomatic H&K USP — discharged shortly before noon Saturday aboard Flight 1536 from Denver to Charlotte, as the plane was at about 8,000 feet and was approaching to land. Photos obtained by The Associated Press show a small entry hole in the lower side of the cockpit wall and a small exit hole on the exterior below the cockpit window.

The AP described the photos and the bullet hole in the Airbus A319 to US Airways spokesman Phil Gee, who said "they sound authentic."

Airline officials have said the accidental discharge Saturday did not endanger the 124 passengers and five crew members on board, although air safety experts said Tuesday the shot could have caused the plane to rapidly depressurize had it hit a window at a higher altitude.

"There are two issues: would they (the crew) have enough oxygen to remain alert," said Earl Dowell, an aeronautical engineering professor at Duke University. "If the crew could no longer control the airplane, that would be a big deal. And the rapid loss of pressure might damage the structure itself."

But both Dowell and Fu-Kuo Chang, a professor of aeronautical engineering at Stanford University, said that airplane design emphasizes safety and that such a blast — even if it knocked out a window in mid-flight, isn't likely to cause the kind of damage that would lead immediately to a crash.

"If not repaired, it may cause a problem. It could get bigger. For a single bullet, it would not be a factor for the safety of the airplane," Chang said. "If it hit the window, it may be a problem for depressurization. I still don't think it would cause a crash."

Dowell pointed to a 1988 Aloha Airlines flight in Hawaii in which the roof of the jet ripped off after an explosive decompression at 24,000 feet. A flight attendant was blown out of the plane, but the passengers — many of whom were injured — remained strapped in their seats, and the pilot safely landed the aircraft.

"If they lost a window, the people near that window would have been substantially uncomfortable," Dowell said. "You probably wouldn't have crashed the airplane. But there could have been some frightened people."

The gunshot marked the first time a pilot's weapon has been fired on a plane since the flight deck officer program was created following the terrorist attacks of Sept. 11, 2001, Alter said. The Transportation Security Administration is investigating how the gun discharged, and Gee says the unidentified pilot has been taken off duty during the probe.

Pilots in the program undergo 50 hours of training at the federal Law Enforcement Training Center in Artesia, N.M. Alter said it appears the pilot of the US Airways flight wasn't following "proper procedures. ... We just don't know exactly what procedure wasn't being followed."

Since April 2003, about 5,000 flight deck officers — captains or first officers — have gone through the training program and received permission to carry weapons in the cockpit, said Capt. Bob Hesselbein, chairman of the Air Line Pilots Association's National Security Committee. The union represents more than 61,000 pilots at 43 airlines.

Gee declined to say how many US Airways pilots have graduated from the program and carry guns while on duty, citing security concerns.

But they all carry the same gun, the high-priced and high-quality H&K USP, which Alter said was specially selected for the program. Gun safety expert Ronald Scott, a ballistics expert who served for 25 years with the Massachusetts State Police, said the gun wouldn't discharge accidentally if dropped or jarred in some way.

"It's a top-of-the-line model," Scott said. "They're accurate and highly reliable. This is not something that you would just walk into a gun store and buy. And it's also not something that goes off by itself. ... Someone would have to squeeze the trigger."

The jet will be grounded at Charlotte-Douglas International Airport for several more days as repairs are made. The Federal Aviation Administration said Tuesday it won't be involved in looking at why the gun went off but will investigate to make sure the plane is safe before it returns to service.

"We want to make sure there was no structural damage and no systems on board were damaged by the bullet," said FAA spokesman Ian Gregor said. "We want to take a look at the aircraft to make sure it's in an air-worthy condition."

___

Associated Press writer Estes Thompson in Raleigh contributed to this report.

My personal favorite quote:

Gun safety expert Ronald Scott, a ballistics expert who served for 25 years with the Massachusetts State Police, said the gun wouldn't discharge accidentally if dropped or jarred in some way.

"It's a top-of-the-line model," Scott said. "They're accurate and highly reliable. This is not something that you would just walk into a gun store and buy. "

Yeah, you wouldn't just walk into a gun store and buy an HK USP. Well, actually, I did, but I ended up trading it in later since I didn't like the way it fit my hand...
 
That holster lock setup has to be THE dumbest thing I've ever seen.Just BEGGING for problems, especially based on the description of what can happen given by Jeeppunk (seems pretty likely and easy to do to me, with this setup).Whats wrong with just a regular handgun trigger lock like what ctypically comes with every, single handgun I've bought since the law changer to require tehy be supplied with them? They seem like they'd work just as good, and eliminate at least 1 potential scenario for an ND, and be a whole lot less bulky.....
Leave it to the government to make something simple, easy and obvious, unnessecarrily complicated, difficult, and plain stupid.
Also, doesnt seem like thier frangible ammo is very frangible if it ripped clear thru the fusilage that esily and cleanly.If the'r fancy, special ammo can do that anyway, why not just give them better performing premium ammo like Gold Dots or something.Cant see how it would increase the risks any based on that pic, and is likely to be a better stopper than any frangible stuff (based on all the tests I've ever seen of them).
 
Black box audio could be priceless. Shows gun to Navigator and Co-Pilot.... "I'm the only one on this flight deck professional enough BOOM!...%^&^&%$!"

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=_91jcFTbLE8

BAAHAHAHAHAHA

How come pilots are allowed to carry outside the airport, and inside the cockpit, yet they become dangerous criminals between the metal detectors and the airplane?

Why can't they carry everywhere?

Heck, why can't we carry everywhere?

i don't get it, everyone here wants anyone to be able to carry onto a plane? what does everyone say when they see the first middle eastern person getting on a plane openly carrying?

these people get acosted and suffer prejudice wtihout ANY weapons... imagine if one of them did....

Now the Beardies know our Pilots are packing. This is good news.
exactly what i was saying above
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top