Soul.....

Status
Not open for further replies.

Dave McCracken

Moderator In Memoriam
Joined
Dec 20, 2002
Messages
13,936
Location
MD.
I was poking around on another shotgun board, one devoted to "Wingshooting and Fine Guns"....

Much of the material on that BB covers fine doubles, a subject in which finances have limited my participation. But, there was a thread on Browning's reissue of the vaunted Model 12, and pumpguns are a subject dear to my heart.

I like the Model 12 in both Winchester's classic and the re-issue, even though some sneer at Japanese made arms. Not me. If a rose is a rose is a rose, a pumpgun well made of quality materials by free people is a fine pumpgun is a fine pumpgun is a fine pumpgun.

But, one poster there, when 870s were cited, made the comment that Model 12s have more "Soul".

To him, maybe.

But soul is not a factory option. We install it one memory at a time.

Consider my oldest 870, mine since 1959. The story in the Archives here, "A Christmas Past", tells how my father gave it to me on a pheasant hunt.

Since then, it has taken game from dove to deer, busted clays, slapped down steel plates, and in 1971 or so in Venice Ca, it helped me convince two criminals that breaking into my apartment in the wee smalls was not only illegal, but a really stupid idea. It now is semi retired and serves as part of my home owner's insurance plan.

There's a lot of memories with that shotgun in it, and it has soul up the wazoo.

Or take Frankenstein, my over publicized parts 870. The tale of its birth, " A Kitchen Table 870" is also archived.

Since the lightning flashed and it sat up on the operating table late in the 80s or early 90s, it has taken much game, served well on divers ranges and functions at 100% regardless of the task.

Since I built it, it helped me take my only true triple on a quail covey flush, gone 11 snow geese with 14 shells, and helped me educate some folks that a shotgun need be neither pretty nor costly to be good.

It's a junkyard mutt with the heart of a thoroughbred. It takes love to make it beautiful, but it's not for sale at any price.

And it too has soul dripping off it like honey on a biscuit.

Some newer guns here are getting soul.

Number Six, my most recently acquired 870, was made in 1955 and lightly used prior to me. I'm changing that, and it has done well in the dove fields.

Number Four, AKA Jessica for the Allman Brothers instrumental, is a 20 gauge Youth model I got for the kids in the early 90s. They've moved on and a friend needed a youth stock for a 28 gauge 870 he got for HIS kids. I ended up with a straight grip stock on Jessica that redefined the term "Quail Gun" and made it a fast handling, light uplander. It's got some soul now, and I'll add to that as time allows.

In case you've followed all that, here's how to add soul to your shotguns.

It's not like bolting on a accessory. Or redoing the finish.

You use it. And you do that in the company of those you care the most about, family and friends

Use a worked over $50 bolt action 12 gauge to take a county record after a friend called it "The Ugliest Shotgun in Howard County".Also archived.

Or take a fast double on dove with an well known pumpgun while your oldest child, too young to shoot, watches wide eyed behind her miniature shooting glasses. Or watch said child, older, bust her first clay with another,similar gun bought just for her.

Or lend it to a friend when his autoloader seizes up to kill his first giant Canada goose.

Or just carry it through some pretty country, admiring The Creator's work.

Do that, and your shotgun will see soul showing up uninvited but quite welcome.

The best to all this Holiday Season.....
 
Last edited:
Some people seem to think they can buy 'soul' the same way they think they can buy skill. Well said, Dave.

lpl
 
This post made me consider which of my shotguns has the most "soul."

I'm leaning toward the Model 12 my father bought me as a high school graduation present. It's a 16 gauge which also gets it soul points.
I've taken quite a few grouse with it. Including birds killed with the help of the best dog I ever had, a black and white Springer. It's also gotten two geese and some squirrels, but no rabbits. I killed a three point buck with it on a ridge in Michigan's U.P. It was my house shotgun--until I got a Mossberg 590 for that role.

The other contender is a 20 gauge OU made in Italy by FIAS. It has killed rabbits for me, and many grouse including the last two I got back in November. No geese or deer, though I've thought about trying it on both sometimes.

I bought the 20 myself after eyeing it in the used rack of a local gun store for a couple of weeks. It weighs six and a half pounds and just feels like grouse season is going to start tomorrow every time I pick it up. Yeah, it has soul too.
 
It makes me smile when someone else shares my opinion of a pumpgun well made of quality materials by free people is a fine pumpgun is a fine pumpgun is a fine pumpgun. Or a fine gun in general.
 
Thanks, folks. I mentioned pumpguns because A, I know a bit about them and B, there's an awful lot of them out there getting the Dangerfield treatment.

No respect.

But. there's tons of soulful guns out there. I saw a couple being souled up today.

One gangling teen has had his made in Turkey Chas Daley for a few weeks. His better trap round today was 23/25. Even with a Mod choke, he was getting enough smoke to make any of us happy.

His 11.5 year old sister is 80 lbs of determination with her similar Daley 20 gauge pump. Her learning curve is steeper, but no one shows more heart and it transfers to that bargain basement shotgun.

She calls for the birds with a savage scream heard three ranges away. Her shotgun WILL have soul.

Later, I admired a Model 21 in 20 gauge in the clubhouse. A recently made one, it had exhibition grade wood, elegant lines and engraving seldom seen in these parts. I handled and shouldered it and voiced my regard for it.

Quoth the owner, " It's pretty, but I can't shoot it". Under questioning, he admitted he preferred a couple Elsies he had.

Under those circumstances, I doubt that Winchester will accrue soul until another shotgunner assumes custody.
 
IMO, soul exists in a gun from the memories it contains. My dad's old Mossberg 85A is about as ugly as guns come. A 20 gauge bolt action, the bluing is long turned to plum-brown and the well-worn wood is plain as can be. I'd be hard-pressed to get $50 for it from a stranger if I were ever foolish enough to sell it.

He bought it back in the 1930's and it was the first and only shotgun he ever owned. It kept a steady supply of grouse and rabbits on our table when I was young and it was the first shotgun I ever fired. I can still clearly remember him helping to steady the fore-end for me and the thrill of feeling the kick and the blast from that first shot.

Every time I pick it up a thousand memories of hunts with him come flooding back. It has more than soul - it's a time machine that transports me back to those happy days like nothing else can. I wouldn't sell it for a million bucks.
 
But, one poster there, when 870s were cited, made the comment that Model 12s have more "Soul".

To him, maybe.

But soul is not a factory option. We install it one memory at a time.
And most uptight Winchester collectors will tell you a pre-64 has the most soul. I don't buy it; you have inherent quality built into a gun (which can be proven) but most stock offerings from the major manufacturers were very comparable, and an abstract thing as "soul" is the only way collectors can justify model 12 high prices.
 
Amen, Bud. That's what I'm talking about.

Huntsman, I always wondered why the Model 12, good as it is, is raised to the level of myth while Remington's equally good 31 is ignored.

In any case, it's not Soul that did it.
 
Soul, like beauty, is in the eye of the beholder. I've owned one of the Japanese reproduction Model 12s. It was a high-grade version and one of the few branded "Winchester" instead of Browning.

But I've also owned a 20 gauge Wingmaster Lightweight and a 20 gauge 870 Skeet. For my money both had as much "soul" as the faux Winchester and the Skeet perhaps had more. I don't own any of them currently but of the 3 the one that was easiest to part with was the Japanese Winchester and I don't miss it.

My favorite was the 870 Skeet. It was beautiful, silky smooth and I shot it well. The reason I parted with it is a long story but sometimes in life you can feel better about someone else owning a great gun even though you gave it up.
 
But soul is not a factory option. We install it one memory at a time.
Part of a gun's soul, to me, is the time and effort that went into making it. That's not the sole definition, if you're pardon the pun, but I think that it's still a variable worth discussing. A gun that was made by people that were proud to have made it - well, to me that gun has a soul that is visible.

And yes, that soul can be bought.

Now, the buyer can certainly squander that soul. And that's a shame. But that doesn't meant that the gun wasn't born into a soul of its own.
 
I have only owned my Browning BPS for about two and ahalf months but it has more soul than any of my other guns.

I had it for a week or two and had not gotten to shoot it yet. My wife was was out doing some shopping when I decided to go shoot it one weekend.

So I loaded it and my four year old son in to the truck with some clays.

Where I go shooting clays at is pretty much just a parking lot with a field around it.

I got my son out of the truck and everything else. He says"I'm cold dad" so I put him in the truck with the window half way down. I launch a clay and try to shoot it. The look on his face when he heard that first BOOM was priceless. When I hit the next one he yells out "you shot it dad" and he was so excited and proud that he was involved in this. The memories are almost bringing tears to my eyes and I will say I'm getting choked up thinking about it.

He thought that was one of the neatest things. We really connected and I felt like he was my best friend.

I don't know if this is soul or one of the best memories I have in life, but I'll never get rid of that shotgun because of the memory that I have with it.

What I just typed here doesn't do the memory justice, just being there and experiencing his first experiance, and excitment around a shotgun will always be priceless.
 
Last edited:
True to my word, I picked up an 870 Wingmaster... man it's purdy! I'm guessing it was made in the 60s or 70s, I'll call Remington in the morning to get the date. It's got a few "soul marks," but in pretty good shape nonetheless. :)
 
Great post Dave.
I have a few with soul and some that are comming along.
It comes with age most of the time or we could say with each pull of the trigger.
 
Well written and clearly rings of the truth.

My "soul" gun is the 12 gauge Wards Hercules Model 10 single shot that my wife's grandfather traded to my father for $3 and some scrap steel when they were young men. It is the first shotgun I ever fired and the first weapon I every took game with. No bluing, cracked buttplate and all. Market value? zero dollars. Priceless to me.
Unfortunately I gave up hunting long ago and my mid 80s "like new" 870, now regulated to a home security position, will probably never ooze soul in my hands.... but I can be it's keeper for a while.
 
Thanks, guys.

Paul, you added to the soul when you passed it on.

One of the Geezers and I had a conversation a while back. He has lots of high grade shotguns, with a real emphasis on fine SxS art.

He opined that part of the attraction was knowing that some good folks had custody of these gems and passed them on as he will some day.

He beleives that soul cannot be bought or sold, but can be freely given. And gratefully accepted.

He also believes that the difference between just owning a gun and thinking you are the custodian is partly based on the soul of the shotgun.

Rbernie, guns made with pride and care may accrue more soul, but IMO we put soul into them. A reflection of us, and more.

Clint, thanks. you just improved a good morn.

Amen, Ben. If you stuck it in a rack with identical other shotguns you could still find it first try, I wager.

Congrats, Floppy. The soul will show up soon if you use it.

F4, if we use them.

76, when you pass that 870 on to a loved one, they will find soul oozing off it. Trust me.
 
wow, reminds me of the old and beat up revalations .410 single shot my grandfather bought at a yardsale for $85. its now my most treasured shotgun. i think of my firearms the same way as my old chevy truck... every scratch, every dent and every battle scar has a story behind it, and is a memory well cherished... unless its made by a shopping cart
 
Soul.

Mom went back to her house yesterday after a 6-week stay here at our place in bee-yooo-teee-full Western Howard.

I haven't been to PGC since she came to stay - hospital visits, surgeon visits, antibiotic drip visits.

She was a shooter, once upon a time. Small-bore and trap.

In '66, The Old Man bought 2 870TC's. One for her, one for him. She has her's back now. I gave it back to her when The Old Man died last March. His TC is still mine. Dave knows this gun. With her 34" full(er) choke target bbl she swings, as Dave says, "Like a wrecking ball..."

First gun that I ever shot, at the tender age of 5 or so, standing on The Old Man's shoes, my back against his knees: Me pulling the gun in tight to my shoulder, him holding the fore-end, and then squeezing the trigger to send a 1-1/8-oz load toward the pattern board at Staten Island Sportman's Club.

He gave me the gun about 12-years ago when he gave up on shooting (and on life, truth be told).

I may sometimes "whore about" with some of my other shotguns, many of which I got from The Old Man, but I always come back to Dad's TC Number One for serious shooting.

Always.

Soul.

Ed
 
Jacob, I know what you mean. When you pass that one on to a loved one, it will have more soul.

Ed, glad your Mom is improving. We missed you. Try to make it next week if you can.

I know that TC has soul. When one of your kids gets big enough, he or she will add to it. You are now.
 
I don't own any shotguns and know almost nothing about them, but I always enjoy reading what Dave writes about them.

Thanks, Dave.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top