Threads like this, that from the start, start out bashing another (fill in the blank) are self-serving drivel.
I've been a USCCA member for two years. I let Tim Schmidt send me several join-up offers until I got one with a significant discount/prize. I did the same with the renewal. Then I put him on my spam list and havn't heard another word.
The magazine is small, to the point, mostly on target and carries with it far less annoying advertisement. It has evolved into something mildly entertaining and enjoyable.
The forum is typical gun faire: lot's of people (most new), few with any real knowledge, everyone with a strong opinion (on everything), short on common sense or actual experience.
Here's a fact: it cost a great deal to pay for the space and the bandwidth to support a forum and there are two sources to get that money: your own pocket or advertisers and subscribers---$47 is cheap when one considers the magazine.