9mm choices...

Uhhhh. I believe you HAVE narrowed it down to S&W

Sorry, but none of the above. (Well, maybe the Walther PPS for CCW). They're all fine guns but I'd go for a SIG P250 or the P250 2SUM which gives you everything needed to have either a full-size pistol or a compact pistol.

My personal preferences tend toward full-size, DA/SA pistols with external hammers. I have a Beretta PX4 Storm and a FN-Herstal FNP-9, both of which I have found to be superb pistols and very dependable. I will confess I bought the PX4 to go with my CX4 Carbine; the interchangeable magazines with up to 20-round capacity makes a lot of sense to me and both are great guns at the range.

It's not clear how you will use this pistol.

I can only speak about the models I have owned and I won't speak about those I haven't.

I have and carry an XD9SC. It has a pretty fat grip but fits my hand and conceals well. It has been completely reliable and I can shoot it accurately to 50 feet; no complaints and very happy.

I don't have any of the others you listed. I do have a CZ75B which is a full sized semi auto and has been an excellent range gun for plinking and falling plates. It is accurate(as CZs tend to be) and completely reliable.

I previously owned a Taurus PT92 which was also reliable but I couldnt' hit anything with it. It turns out it was me. I have become a better shot and might like to get it back.

There are plenty of other good choices but you learned that as you trimmed your list down to those four, right?

I went through the compact 9mm shopping conundrum a few years back. I went with the S&W M&P9c and have absolutely no regrets. It's a very fine compact that still gives you 12+1 capacity.

I own two PPS models (9mm and .40 S&W). I also own and carry a P99C on a daily basis. Both models are excellent for concealed carry. I use the P99C each day because I'm more accurate with it, for whatever reason. I've tried the S&W and didn't care for the trigger; as with all guns, I guess, it's an individual thing. The P99C with the AS trigger configuration is about as good as it gets, IMO. It's also the most likely explanation as to why I shoot it better than I do just about anything else, including the rock-solid PPS.

Sub-compact? Glock 26, best 9mm subcompact, or if you want really small, then Kel-Tech, IF you decide you want a full size, Glock 17, or Beretta 92, which can handle extremely high pressure loads. And Beretta's just last.

CZ-75D PCR or P-01 should be added to the list.

If you don't, those others will break on you and you'll wish you had...