Seating die issue

Status
Not open for further replies.

AA080

Member
Joined
Apr 3, 2009
Messages
7
I am new to reloading straight walled cases and I notice with either Lee or Hornady dies that when I do not crimp, the case lip catches on the die/stem during the downstoke. I am sure I am doing something wrong, but I can't figure it out. Any ideas?
 
AA,

What cartridge are you reloading? When are you getting contact? When running the charged case & bullet up into the seating die?

The belled case mouth may be hitting the seat/crimp die body.

Koski
 
Hi Steve,

This happens for .357 and .44. I am getting the "catch" just about when 3/4 of the cartridge is completely out of the die on the downstroke. I am seating the bullets out pretty far for a singleshot if that helps.
 
+1

You pretty much have to crimp straight-wall calibers, at least enough to straighten out the case mouth bell you put there to get the bullets started.

rc
 
AA,

I'm not sure why you're getting a catch. But as the previous guys said, you should at least straighten out the case wall for a real light crimp. This may eliminate the catch feeling.

Koski
 
+2

Set the die so that it "just" removes the bell.
(You can run your fingers up over the case mouth/bullet junction and judge that by feel)



(post: And if you don't get rid of that bell, you may also have trouble w/ the case entering the cylinder.)

.
 
Last edited:
This happens for .357 and .44.
You should be roll crimping into the bullet cannulure on jacketed bullets, or crimp groove on lead bullets.

This is necessary for several reasons.

#1 You will get more consistent powder burn and better accuracy with Magnum loads.

#2 You will not have bullets slipping foreward out of the cases from recoil and locking up the cylinder so it won't turn.

#3 The roll crimp will make chambering cartridges far easier if you don't have the sharp case mouth catching on the edges of the chambers.

#4 Thats what you are supposed to do.

If you adjust the seating/crimp die to properly roll-crimp, the "catching in the die" problem will go away, and you will be producking much better reloads at the same time.

rc
 
I am seating the bullets out pretty far for a singleshot if that helps.

Just because you're loading for/shooting a single shot does not mean you can skip the crimping stage of loading handgun shells. As RC said, it ensures complete powder burn by holding onto the bullet for a tiny fraction of time to let the powder burn get started.


seating the bullets out pretty far

Why? Seat them to the cannelure/crimp groove and crimp them there. I can see no reason to seat long.

When I was loading for a contender in .357 and 44 magnum, I seated to the crimp groove and crimped heavily to help the slow burning powder charges get a chance to get up to pressure. These were used for IMHSA silly wet shoots.
 
Agreed.

I can no reason to seat them out far and they should be "roll crimped"
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top