Did I get a decent deal on a Combat Masterpiece?

Status
Not open for further replies.

jj1962hemi

Member
Joined
Aug 28, 2011
Messages
273
Hey Gang,

I just made an impulse buy of an S&W (pre-Model 15) Combat Masterpiece in 38 SPL on GunBroker. Do you think $405 was a good price? I posted the GB link , but can't get a picture to post (see below).

Rest of description:

At some point this gun was factory repaired and re-blued. All lettering and marks are crisp. There is a "S" and a Diamond symbol on the barrel (by serial number), on cylinder face, on left side of grip frame (under grip panels), Also "R-S" and "11-80" I believe the diamonds signifies factory re-blue 11 80 is Nov, 1980. "S" standard blue finish. "R" for repair. Original Smith & Wesson factory diamond cut wood grips (serial numbered to gun), square butt. The bore is excellent, bright and shiny. The mechanics function flawlessly. Serial # K164139. Serial number on barrel, butt, cylinder face, cylinder yoke and grips match. Included with this gun is an original Factory box and oil paper. The box is 2-piece blue Bangor Punta type used between 1966 & 1985. Guns returned to the owner after re-blue or repair were shipped in a factory box without end labels. This would fall in line with 1980 re-blue date. This gun was originally shipped from factory in 1952. Hammer and trigger are nickel plated. This gun has anti-backlash trigger and adjustable stop. Possible upgrade when gun was sent in for re-blue. Gun looks like it wasn't shot much after returned from factory. A really nice condition for for this early S&W 5-screw pistol.


www.gunbroker.com/Auction/ViewItem.aspx?Item=283765810
 
It looks great. I enjoy my 15s, shoot them on a regular basis. I don't think the re-blued are great for collecting, but looks like a great shooter. Enjoy.
 
I'm a shooter more than a collector, but I assumed a factory re-blue is better than a typical re-blue. I have a Model 66 that I love and didn't want to pass this up.
 
Four c-notes for a shooter Combat Masterpiece? Not bad in this economy. 'gatz.
 
As with a lot of fine old revolvers, they become "discovered" and the prices ratchet up. The model 15 Smith and Wesson certainly falls in both categories. The fine old revolver category and the recently discovered category. A couple of years ago great bargains on "shooter quality" model 15's could be found as collectors were not intersted in pieces primarily because of their finish and people that would buy aggressively in the "shooter" category were all focused on more famous models.

The secret is out now about the .38 special only model 15.

Most of the "great unwashed" threw their dollars only at the .357 model 19, old colts etc.

I have defnitely noticed a high rate of inflation in the market for fine working non-collector S&W .38's, model 10,15,64 etc.

You will notice this especially with the model 15, the "premium" old school S&W .38.

I want a good one myself and will suffer the sticker shock with you. Even at today's higher prices the market is correct and as long as mechanically correct, they ARE WORTH EVERY PENNY AND A FINE OLD REVOLVER EVEN IF .38 ONLY.
 
It sounds like I'm in fine company. I would have preferred the 6" version, but I thought it was a good deal. It's also close to home, so I avoid shipping and trf fees. I should probably "thin the herd" a little to give myself some more flexibility should something else become available. So much to do....so little time.
 
I've got a 4" model 15 also which has a bit of history having been a carry piece for a US Marshal, then a local Marshall, then it came to me. It is a treasured possession of mine, beautiful to behold, even finer to shoot.

I think you did well for what you paid, I wouldn't think twice about paying that price for yours.

Since a 6" gun is on your mind, keep your eyes open for a model 14 K38 target masterpiece. Mine was made in 1950 and is another working treasure.
 
I think 400 is a good price for a good gun with a high quality factory reblue (regardless of all the old-timers out there who may say they only paid half of whatever you bought it for.)

The model 15 is such a classic gun that I think you should always jump at the chance to get one.
 
I've also been looking at the hand ejectors, although I've never fired one. I like the 32-20 because it's such a solid round, particularly in the pre-.357M world from which it came. I have an old Model 3 Safety (38 S&W, not 38SPL) that I really like the feel of too. It's amazing how this stuff gets under your skin!
 
Well, I just sent off $400 plus shipping costs on a NIB 1980 M15 with TT and TH, and didn't hesitate. I carried a Security Six for most of my career but always had a soft spot for the M15 ever since the USAF. Picked up a M18 back in '82 which has a 'few' cases of .22s through it. Did manage to get a M15 back in the early 90s but my son knew a good gun when he saw it and claimed it while still a teenager.

This one is MINE. I'm going to put a spring kit in it and custom Spegels on, and enjoy one of the finest guns ever made.

AND earmark it for my grandson (now age 3) to have some day.
 
Not bad. Nice looking gun really.

You did OK. Those diamond magna grips alone go for 75-85 bucks around here.

I've got one from 51. Great shooter.

The original finish would have been the flat, matte finish S&W used during the post war years to speed up production.

100_0321.gif

100_0324.gif
 
Last edited:
Thanks guys! I need to go do the paperwork this weekend and get it out to the range. It might take a few weeks, but I'll report back on it. There's something about a wheelgun that just works for me. It's funny, I've been looking at Glock M22s (and M27s), realizing I should just bite the bullet and get the most popular, one of the easiest to fix, reasonably priced and reliable semi-autos around.....then the Combat Masterpiece came around and......I guess I can wait a little while for the polymer pistol (will be my first).
 
jj1962hemi, if you over paid, and I'm not sure you did, the amount was so small it won't matter in 6 months. Prices of classic revolvers such as your have been increasing at an alarming rate for the last two or so years. Like a FOOL I did not purchase a factory refinished M 27-2 3 1/2" for $600.00 two years ago, today I would consider myself lucky to buy the same revolver for $800.00.

Sadly with the upcoming election and the needless fear surrounding it I don't believe that prices will be coming down anytime soon.
 
Your revolver is much finer than anything made by S & W in decades. The price you paid is actually cheap when compared to what their new revolvers are selling for. Shoot it like you stole it. I looked at the pictures and it does not look like a re blue to me. The lettering is just too crisp.
 
Horrible deal, I feel so bad I will give you your money back plus some for it....lol. You did great. That looks to be a hellova nice Smth. Congratulations, I had to pull your chain a little. Its a great deal if you ask me and I'd buy em all day long for that.
 
Thanks guys! I'm in for $443. I filled out the paperwork today, it's an LGS, but I had to pay sales tax.

The seller says it's a factory re-blue, which is why the lettering is still crisp. The bluing is beautiful and the drag line is hardly there. I'll probably pick it up Saturday, if I can't get there earlier.

I am hard pressed to buy new guns when such nice older ones are still around. I purchased a few milsurps lately for a few hundred each and it strikes me that you can't buy that kind of quality today at a multiple of the price. Now I need to get it out and shoot it!
 
I found a M-15-3 refinished in teflon by a Calif. County Sheriff's office, mounted with Hogue Combat Grips, for $350! I carried an M15 'Combat Masterpiece', when manning security posts at my BUFF base in SEA. It's my "Evil Black Revolver"!
 
I agree it's been refinished but I'da popped for $450 in a heart beat.

You got a dandy shooter there. You're grand kids will enjoy that one if you take care of it.
 
The gun looks like it's a fine shooter. It appears to have minimal use and I suspect most of the wear and tear was to the frame, cylinder and barrel. Rebluing took care of that, and the reblue job looks like it's fairly decent; however, as they say, rebluing hides a multitude of sins....
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top