Blowing out primer at below recommended start load 300WM

Status
Not open for further replies.

windfall

Member
Joined
Oct 5, 2012
Messages
10
Looking for advice on why loads are too hot even though I'm BELOW the recommended start load on my 300WM.

I'm using Berger's manual for 210 gr VLD target (page 767). I'm using:
-RE-22
-New Norma Brass
-210 Berger VLD Target
-Standard blue box Federal primers

Book says start load is 67.5 with a max load of 71.1. I'm at 66 gr and blew out 3 of the 26 rounds I shot today. ALL of them show signs of high pressure with a dent from the extractor.

I started getting this problem when I switch from Berger 210 BTLR to 210 VLDs. Naturally, I re-measured the ogive off the lands and reset the bullet seating die appropriately. What am I doing wrong?

thanks in advance
 
I started getting this problem when I switch from Berger 210 BTLR to 210 VLDs.
The VLD may have a longer bearing surface, thicker jacket then the other bullet. Seating the VLD base deeper into the case may raise pressure. Brass that is heavier then the brand used in the load data may raise pressure. The ogive into the rifling may raise pressure. http://www.bergerbullets.com/wp-content/uploads/2013/03/COAL.pdf How are the primers "blown out" Pierced/blanKed, faling out of the brass, gas leakage between primer and brass, hole in rounded corner of the primer cup??
 
Last edited:
You may want to confirm the load data from another source.
The next stop should be the powder manufacturers recommendations if possible. Normally they are available on line.
Luck
T
 
Thank you for the replies. 3 of the 26 rounds blew the primer out of the primer pockets. The other 23 showed pressure signs in the primers, The cases looked heavily "slammed" against the bolt face with extractor pin marks. Almost all of the rounds fired were difficult to open the bolt to extract the case, as if the brass was expanded too much.
You're response is leading me to think the VLDs are too far in the barrel and causing too much chamber pressure. Is that what you're suggesting?
 
My first guess would be the brass is a lot heavier than what the load data is using. But if you read post #4 above, it may be the bullet construction?? A bullet jammed into the rifling will raise pressure.
I'm BELOW the recommended start load
This may cause problems also. If your loading using the exact same componants used in Berger's manual for 210 gr VLD target, then the below recommended powder charge may be a problem??
 
Like said above, that bullet is very long and it's possible you are into the rifling.

You gave us a lot of information you got from the Berger load manual but you did not tell us what COAL they tested the data at. Did you keep using the same OAL as you were loading with the Berger 210gr BTLR when you switched to the 210gr VLD bullet? If you did you are probably into the rifling like the above posts suggested and that will raise the pressures, sometimes by a lot.
 
Norma brass is the heaviest, thickest brass available. It will reduce case capacity by a few grains.

Did you use Norma brass before with the other bullet?

If you want to, fill a Norma case with water then pour it into a different manufacturers case and see how much difference there is.

Does Berger call for Norma brass in their load data?

Are you shooting over a chrony?

Have you checked with ALLIANT for a recall on that batch of RE-22?

Have you checked with Norma for a recall on that batch of brass? Perhaps it was "super-sized" from the factory.

Have you measured the diameter of bullets from Berger to confirm they are proper diameter?

Have you slugged your barrel to check diameter?

Does the barrel heat up very quickly compared to the previous loads, indicating a bullet to bore problem?

Have you checked head space?
 
In revolver rounds, which I have lots of experience with, if you go too low, the primer can back out.

With proper loads, the case is pushed so hard against the recoil shield that either:

A. the primer isn't allowed to start to come out

or

B. the primer starts to come out, but is reseated when the case is pushed back against the recoil shield.

I'm not well versed on rifle reloading (all I have is an AR-15).
Is it possible your below standard load is too soft???

At least this gives you another avenue to consider.
 
Generally there is little mystery to reloading mishaps, at least in my experience. As for this problem, I can only use past experience to try and diagnose the cause.

Not too long ago my Son picked up a bunch of 7mm RM from a yard sale. The loads were all below, in fact significantly below published minimum using a slow burning powder IMR-4350. Rather than let me pull the bullets and re-do the loads, my Son insisted on just shooting them up so we could get to loading the brass. What happened, is most of the primer's were backed way out, black sooty brass, and obvious signs of blow back over the case shoulders also. Some primers actually pierced, most all leaked, and extraction was stiff, very similar to that of an over charge high pressure load.

Slow burning powders such as RL22 do not perform well when taken down below published minimum. I load regularly with this powder and have seen how it behaves.

Providing there are no unmentioned issues such as brass that is exceeding maximum length, what is the resized length of the brass? 300 WM does have a short neck to start with, and is some what prone to pinching in the throat when not maintained within spec..

Other wise I strongly lean toward light powder charges simulating high pressure effects as the likely culprit here.

Another possible is seating depth, although I doubt at that powder charge that seating into the lands would raise pressures enough to result in blown primers. It's never happened to me, and I commonly seat right up to the lands, and even slightly into them with powder charges at or above mid table.

GS
 
I just remeasured everything

So, I spent a couple hours in my garage and remeasured everything. I took out my Hornady OAL measuring rod and measured the two different bullets in my rifle: Berger 210 VLD and 210 BTLR.

This high pressure problem started when I began using the VLDs.

Looking at the two bullets, I can see that the VLD is "pointier" so it seemed obvious to me that the VLD would set farther into the barrel. Not the case. In fact, the opposite is true.

The VLD is slightly longer at 1.468 while the BTLR is 1.463.

The OAL for the VLD for my custom barrel "on the lands" is 3.406 while the OAL for the BTLR is 3.492. This results in an Ogive for the VLD at 2.729 and the Ogive for the BTLR at 2.800. And based on what 243winxb suggestion, I believe the bearing surface of the VLD is longer than the BTLR which I suspect means more friction in the barrell and so the charge is relatively hot.

My thinking is that when combining the fact that the VLD bullet is farther down in the case and that the bearing surface is longer, these may both equate to higher chamber pressure.

I've built a new batch of BTLRs at the minimum recommended Berger charge of 67.5 and will test them tomorrow. I'll let you guys know the outcome. Thanks again for the ideas. (BTW, I have a custom 29" Hart barrel. So, your rifle will likely have different numbers.)
 

Attachments

  • Cartridge_Comparison.jpg
    Cartridge_Comparison.jpg
    30.9 KB · Views: 32
  • Bullet_comparison.jpg
    Bullet_comparison.jpg
    31.2 KB · Views: 31
Last edited:
As far as highpowered rifles are concerned; I have read and heard that less powder can build up pressure quicker than more powder. I am not an expert, I have only been reloading for about 2 years. However, I am still not clear why you went outside of the data? I am honestly asking.
 
It might be from the flash, but is that a mark on the right bullet Also looks like a ring from the seating stem right above it. If the VLD round was chambered in the rifle, you may have a short, tight throat/leade in your custom barrel.
 
Last edited:
Randy in Arizona

Actually, no I haven't been measuring case length since these are all brand new Norma brass. But I'm measuring ogive of each and making sure they don't vary too much from one to another by +/- 0.002
 
I shot 6 rounds today with the BTLRs at 67.5 and 3 of the rounds popped the primers.

BTW, I'm reading everybody's responses. The thing is, I didn't have a problem with pressure with the BTLRs before. However, I have since changed R-22 lot numbers. So, I'm now thinking that the powder lot may be hot as someone suggested. I'll see if I can call them tomorrow.

I also bought a box of Federal 180s (at $70!!!) as a sanity check. I'll have to test them next weekend. I noticed that the ogive of these is 2.805 which is pretty close to the ogive of my BTLRs at 2.815.

I'll also try the another batch with a different powder lot next weekend.
 
You are loading your VLDs into the lands, correct.

Loading into the lands will cause a higher pressure situation than what your manual intended.

Back the charge down or seat the bullet deeper!
 
Loading into the lands will cause a higher pressure situation than what your manual intended.
Maybe, but maybe not. Berger suggests seating the vld to the lands; their manual may be based on that.

FWIW, I had a fast lot of Rx25 a while ago.

As mentioned above, check your brass length. I would also clean the barrel.

Do you have check weights? Your scale could be lying to you.
 
BTW, I'm reading everybody's responses. The thing is, I didn't have a problem with pressure with the BTLRs before. However, I have since changed R-22 lot numbers. So, I'm now thinking that the powder lot may be hot as someone suggested. I'll see if I can call them tomorrow.

Powder is blended, Accuracy Arms told me the industry standard is + - 10%. If you changed powder lot, primers, case, bullets, anything, don't assume pressures will stay the same.

If you are blowing primers, cut your loads. I would cut by a grain, then continue to cut by a half grain till the primers stop blowing.

Books are guides, each gun is different.
 
At this point, I'm betting that the technician reviewing your chambers blue print is going to yield some possible answers. I'm kind of leaning toward a shorter or tighter than industry standard (SAAMI) throat that may be causing the mouths to get pinched or restricted, even though the brass is trimmed to minimum and even with projectile not into the lands? Your chamber may need some additional work, might be too tight one way or another by just a smidge.

GS
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top