So I screwed up (bought upper w/o M4 feed ramps)

Status
Not open for further replies.

Arizona_Mike

Member
Joined
Feb 15, 2013
Messages
3,452
I got a great deal ($40 under retail, more if you count shipping) on an oversized Sun Devil octagonal billet upper receiver for a heavy varmint build I'm planning. What I like about the Sun Devil is that you still get a dust cover unlike some other octagonal receivers.

When I got home I realized that it did not have M4 ramps and when I checked the web page saw it was a $10 option.

Should I:
-Not worry about it and get a barrel with M4 ramps?
-Specifically get a barrel with M2 ramps?
-Free hand the ramps with a file (I'm pretty good with this kind of work)?

Mike
 
Last edited:
As I understand, M4 feed ramps are only necessary with the high rate of fire of fully automatic M4s. Its nice to have, but I don't think I've ever heard of someone having problems because they didn't have them (especially in a varmint rifle).
 
I understand that you never want to use a M2 extention in a M4 receiver because it gives you a step (ramp, flat, ramp). The opposite just gives a ramp as short as an M2 but as steep at an M4 and I'm not sure if this is an issue.

Mike

PS. Actually a rifle length barrel in a carbine lower can cause problems due to a much longer gas pulse. That's why the Canadians use H2 buffers in their hybrid M4 based rifle and the USMC is experimenting with the new H6 buffer for a longer barrel carbine. I would expect this to get even worse if I got with a 22, 24, or even 26" barrel vs 20".
 
NM, didn't realize you didn't have a barrel yet and mistakenly thought you had A2 style feed ramps on the non-existent barrel & M4 cuts on the upper.
 
Last edited:
Got this from another site, explains it well. I think you are OK.
attachment.php
 

Attachments

  • feedramps2.jpg
    feedramps2.jpg
    101.8 KB · Views: 483
Got this from another site, explains it well. I think you are OK.
Thanks MErl. A picture really is worth 1000 words and matches what I was picturing in my mind except for the steepness (the M4 cuts seem to be the same slope but go deeper toward the chamber).

I'm not going to find a threaded .223 Wylde varmint bull contour so I think I'm going to go with the Squad Designated Marksman (SDM) Contour: Fluted bull to the gas port and .730 for the last 8". This will still allow me to use an adjustable gas block to tame the extra long gas pulse (esp with a suppressor).

e27f33bd31a65424f16e0ce330b452d2.jpg


Mike
 
Just get an A2 barrel. Larue purposefully omitted the M4 ramps on the OBR to maximize accuracy and because they weren't needed for reliability.
 
Check out Lilja barrels at www.riflebarrels.com. According to their site they are now threading their bull barrels. Their barrels are amazing!!! Have a 24" bull on a custom build of mine and it holds 1/4 moa with no problem. if you would like some pics as evidence PM me with your email and will send you some.

Eddie
 
I sent Lija an e-mai but it looks like only their 17" Navy Recce and 20" AR740 are threaded. The 740 is basically .750 for the first 12" and .740 for the last 8" (and larger at the extension and gas block shouder, of course). Not quite as heavy as I had wanted.

Mike
 
Getting a raw barrel threaded is not a big deal. OTOH something like an AK with a pressed in barrel is a lot more trouble -- I know people sometimes use coaxial cutters and dies with bore fitting pilots, but this will never match the quality and concentricity you can get with a good lathe and 4-jaw chuck.

So I'd suggest getting the barrel you really want and have it threaded before you install it.
 
Thanks MErl. A picture really is worth 1000 words and matches what I was picturing in my mind except for the steepness (the M4 cuts seem to be the same slope but go deeper toward the chamber).

I'm not going to find a threaded .223 Wylde varmint bull contour so I think I'm going to go with the Squad Designated Marksman (SDM) Contour: Fluted bull to the gas port and .730 for the last 8". This will still allow me to use an adjustable gas block to tame the extra long gas pulse (esp with a suppressor).

e27f33bd31a65424f16e0ce330b452d2.jpg


Mike
Having been a SDM I can say this setup is great. Not terribly heavy and still really accurate.
 
Back to the M4 feedramps: I recently bought a 5.56 barrel from a company called Sota barrels. Had previously bought a .300 Blackout barrel from them and like it.

On their website, they claim that all their barrels have M4 feedramps. Having no reason to verify that my new barrel had M4 ramps, I went ahead and installed it on an upper with M4 ramps. Got to the range and ran into a plethora of feeding problems...lots of setbacks.

One eyeballing of the extension-to-receiver mating revealed the aforementioned "ledge" caused by a non-M4 barrel extension mated with an M4 receiver.

Removed the barrel and took a good macro pic of the feed ramps, which were obviously not M4. Sent the pic via e-mail to Sota. Got an e-mail back saying that they couldn't tell from the pic if they were M4 feedramps or not, and that they'd need a side view of the barrel. I suspected right then that they didn't know an M4 feedramp from an elephant's butt.

Sent that barrel back and they sent me another, which they assured me would have M4 ramps. Didn't even bother to install the replacement, as it obviously didn't have M4 ramps.

Sold the new bad barrel to a friend of mine at a loss. He had a friendly gunsmith recut the ramps into M4 ramps.

Never heard back from Sota when I notified them about the second barrel. Worst customer service of any company with which I've ever done business...including Botach! :cool:

Here's a pic of the second barrel, simply mated, but not installed. Looks just like the "bad" illustration in post #5, doesn't it?

aff18f0d-7c34-460d-adb4-4e227acd92ac_zpsa80dcfe1.gif
 
Last edited:
I'm building a 20" SDM-R (without front sight and 15" handguard) and just discovered that the official SDM-R used a special M4-type flat-top upper without M4 feed ramps. So I didn't make a "mistake" after all--just being more authentic :)

Mike
 
Here is a couple pics of my SDM-R I had in 05. Very accurate with M262 and could easily hit a man sized target out to 800 meters. Only thing really holding it back at range was the ACOG. They are AWESOME scopes but not made for real long range precision.

dfADFD.jpg

sdasda.jpg

sdadsasda.jpg
 
Great pics C-Grunt. The Rainier ultra-match barrel i'm going with is also built by Shilen just like the real gun so I have high hopes for accuracy.

The question will be to get the rifle gas to work on a carbine buffer. Should I use a H2 like the Canadians are or the special 6-weight H6 buffer the USMC is experimenting with?

Mike
 
Thanks for the offer but the barrel is out of stock and last time I waited for a Rainier UltraMatch barrel it was over 6 mo.

I use an H2 in my 300BLK 10.5" SBR. I'll be sighting it in this weekend.

I'm in the town of Maricopa (in Pinal County) and hang out a lot in Chandler and Mesa, BTW.

Mike
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top