Quantcast
  1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

1911 vs glock (or xd)

Discussion in 'Handguns: Autoloaders' started by gibson_es, Feb 7, 2013.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. gibson_es

    gibson_es Member

    Joined:
    Jul 13, 2011
    Messages:
    204
    Location:
    tampa bay
    Been reading on this. Its something i dont have enough knowledge with i guess.

    I first owned an xd 45 compact. I loved it. But i couldnt carry it concealed because no matter how i tried i always printed.

    Then i got a colt commander 1911 in 45 acp as well. Loved the feel. It felt better to me then any glock or xd or revolver. And it was thin enough i could conceal it . But it didnt feed hollow points too good. Tried all kinds. And i was sure to have a malfuntion every 50-100 rounds. Only with hollow points though. So now that's gone.

    Right now im thinking on a wilson combat. But that's a steep price. However, once a gun is owned. The price doesnt effect how well it will save your life.

    That said. I want a gun i can carry and not worry about. Im not talking maintenance. Im talking what it can handle and still function. One thing i like about glock is how much abuse it can take. While i dont plan on dropping guns from helicopters any time soon. It would ne nice if i go to the mud hole or if im in the swamp or i dive out of a boat for something that i can ttust it to work if i have to use it before i get home to clean it. And im not sire how the 1911's colt or wilson either one can do with these things. My colt i got used 13 years after it was made. It may not be the guns fault. So im also considering a new xse colt.

    Any thing out there showing what any of these can handle? I looked for articles and youtube videos. Not alot out there. I did find one that didnt end well for the sig 1911 as far as testing goes. I have never been a big fan of glock. But when it comes to safety i am willing to put my feelings aside. I also am thinking aboit the XDs.
     
  2. mljdeckard

    mljdeckard Member

    Joined:
    Jun 5, 2006
    Messages:
    12,738
    Location:
    In a part of Utah that resembles Tattooine.
    If you can't carry an XD .45 c without printing, you need a new gameplan.

    Did you have the commander looked at to see if it needed to be throated?
     
  3. gibson_es

    gibson_es Member

    Joined:
    Jul 13, 2011
    Messages:
    204
    Location:
    tampa bay
    No i did not. I was not familiar with that at the time. Not in its entirety anyway.
     
  4. savanahsdad

    savanahsdad Member

    Joined:
    Jul 28, 2012
    Messages:
    1,287
    Location:
    WI
    I was at the range tonight , I took my S&W mod 19-5 ( 357mag) my Super BlackHawk (44mag) , my Braco 380, and my S&W 1911 (45ACP) a friend and his wife brought a XD 45 full size , a XD 40 and Bersa 380. , winner for the night was my S&W 1911 , shooting 200gr cast SWC , after they left I shot a 3" group at 30' , OH that was a 25 round group, the funny thing was the first 5 rounds were 3" and the other 20 rounds stayed right in there ,


    so I vote 1911 , and there is a Glock 17 in my safe , and it has spent most of the last 13 years there ,
     
  5. Autolycus

    Autolycus Member

    Joined:
    Feb 13, 2006
    Messages:
    5,456
    Location:
    In the land of make believe.
    I would just trade the Commander in for a Glock 19 or Glock 17. The Glock is reliable and it will take a beating without being nearly as fussy as any 1911 style pistol.
     
  6. gibson_es

    gibson_es Member

    Joined:
    Jul 13, 2011
    Messages:
    204
    Location:
    tampa bay
    Sorry but caliber isnt up for debate. I switched from 9mm to 45 acp a few years ago and dont care to go back. There great to have at home for the range. Maybe even shtf. But i personally prefer the 45for for edc. And home defense. (As far as handguns go)

    Also, i stated that the commander is gone... so no trading in.
     
  7. Firefightermdc

    Firefightermdc Member

    Joined:
    May 27, 2012
    Messages:
    12
    Glock. Just got rid of one of my 1911s (springer micro) to fund a gen 3 glock 36. Single stack .45. Awesome. Xds is a great option too, just like the Glock a little better

    Sent from my SAMSUNG-SGH-I317 using Tapatalk 2
     
  8. ugaarguy

    ugaarguy Moderator Staff Member

    Joined:
    Mar 19, 2006
    Messages:
    12,042
    I like 1911s when they're built right, but with everybody and their brother making a clone they aren't always built right. When built correctly a 1911 is as tough and reliable as any pistol made. Wilson's are nice, but there are other excellent options in that price range. There are even some great options at lower price points. If you go back to a 1911 do plenty of 1911 specific research, and be ready to pay to play. We could fill up an entire thread on this topic alone, so I'll stop here.

    If you want to skip all the research and debate, then just get a Glock, XD, or S&W M&P in .45 ACP; or a SIG P220.

    I'm not a big Glock fan for personal reasons, but they tend to work really well, the price is reasonable, and there's huge aftermarket support for them.

    I like the XD pistols a little better than the M&P pistols; but S&W offers a pretty substantial discount to LE, active & retired military, and disabled veterans through their LE distributors, so I own M&Ps. I like all the options such as interchangeable back straps, thumb safety or no thumb safety, and magazine disconnect or no disconnect S&W offers on the M&P series. You can really get what you want feature wise with an M&P. The M&P pistols are the only line that even approaches Glocks, SIGs, and 1911s in aftermarket support. If they made the M&P Shield in .45 ACP I'd be all over one.

    The classic metal frame SIGs are just great pistols. They're reliable, durable, and tend to be very accurate. They have great acceptance in military and LE use, so holsters and aftermarket support are superb. I prefer their DAK and DAO models, but most folks like the standard DA/SA better. Their frame mounted de-cocker on the DA/SA models is the best execution of such a feature on the market in my opinion. If you're willing to spend 1911 money and carry a metal frame pistol I wouldn't overlook SIG.

    After some early design revisions the Ruger SR series pistols have also been excellent. I don't care for their huge loaded chamber indicator, but I'm a big fan of the low profile frame mounted safety, and very slim overall profile of the SR series. Holster selection and aftermarket support aren't as good for the SR series as for XD and M&P pistols, but there are still good options available. Ruger added a .45 ACP model to the SR series this year, so I'd keep an eye on reviews as those get out and folks get some rounds through them.

    You have plenty of very good options, so take your time and find what works best for you.
     
  9. 2zulu1

    2zulu1 Member

    Joined:
    Jul 18, 2011
    Messages:
    1,089
    Location:
    Arizona
  10. Girodin

    Girodin Member

    Joined:
    Mar 22, 2008
    Messages:
    5,565
    As a general rule the poly framed striker fired guns are going to be easier to maintain than a 1911. I say that as someone who owns and really likes 1911s. As between which of those poly framed striker guns there are a whole bunch of really good choices, choices that go well beyond Glock and the XD. The good news is that you really can't go wrong with most of them. The bad news is that means there are a lot more guns worth looking at. While some people will insist this make or that make or a particular model is per se better than they others, I think they are up in the night. Much of it comes down to tastes and preferences although there are some comparable constants between them.

    Try to check out Glock, XD, M&P, Walther, etc and see what strikes you. Then learn to use that gun well. One you may want to give a hard look is a Steyr. It is very similar to a glock in a lot of ways. However, I cannot tell you how many avowed glock haters, have shot mine and come away really liking it. Some have even gone out and bought one. I describe it in various ways, but one description I sometimes use is, a glock for people who hate glocks. I don't allege it is per se better than glock or an M&P, etc. But I do like mine a lot and as of now choose to carry it instead of the glock it replaced, or any of my 1911s, or various other guns (which includes several other viable carry guns from most of the major manufactures).

    You could probably go with any of the guns you are talking about and be happy. Its more a matter of learning to shoot and run the gun well.
     
  11. Walkalong

    Walkalong Moderator

    Joined:
    Nov 20, 2006
    Messages:
    47,545
    Location:
    Alabama
    I really like the XD/XDM guns, but I prefer 1911s. Only the individual can decide which platforms they like/prefer over others.

    All fine guns.
     
  12. MarshallDodge

    MarshallDodge Member

    Joined:
    Nov 7, 2005
    Messages:
    2,303
    Location:
    Utah, USA
    Polymer pistols in 45 tend to be very thick. The new XDs is an exception.

    Like others have said, a well built 1911 can be reliable. I usually recommend to someone that purchases one to shoot it hard with all the different ammo that they plan on using. If it doesn't run then send it to a competent 1911 gunsmith for a reliability package. Competent is the key word.
     
  13. KenW.

    KenW. Member

    Joined:
    Nov 30, 2003
    Messages:
    1,096
    Location:
    Out West
    I carried a full-size 1911 on-duty and off for more years than I can remember. Switched to the XD45c because I wanted a gun with a rail. Now I have the 1911 and three XD pistols (and a j-frame, BHP, GP-100, etc).

    If you can't carry the XD45c concealed, it's your choice of holster-belt combination and manner of dress more than the gun. Especially with the flush magazine.
     
  14. tarosean

    tarosean Member

    Joined:
    Oct 22, 2010
    Messages:
    5,403
    Location:
    TX
    I'm gonna agree with this. While I don't own one its a small enough gun it shouldn't be a problem.

    What's your body type OP? What position where you trying to carry it? IWB or OWB? Type of holster?
     
  15. Aceoky

    Aceoky Member

    Joined:
    Mar 12, 2008
    Messages:
    121
    The 1911 is a time tested and proved design IMO, there are plenty of reliable "plastic " pistols to choose from, what feels best to you would be my advice. For ME that is a 1911 , it feels like it's a part of me, and the trigger is so much better even on a lower $ 1911 TO ME . I hate to say this as it's beaten to death, but it's the Ford Chevy thing, (IMO) what I prefer in a 1911 you and many others will prefer in a Glock or M&P etc.
     
  16. gibson_es

    gibson_es Member

    Joined:
    Jul 13, 2011
    Messages:
    204
    Location:
    tampa bay
    As for the XD. I havr a great gunbelt. I tried a crossbread super tuck. Adjusted every way possible. And o had another holster that was all leather i picked up somewere. Neitjer worked well.. i were loose pants and shirts. Im a big guy. Amd i think my issue was not my weight per se, as big guys carry all the time. But i have oddly shaped oversized love handles and no matter what they pushed the gun handle outwards, printing. Tge 1911 it did as well but not enough to print.

    Im working on the weight thing. It camr about after a broken leg and ankle 3 years ago and i sat around for 4the months were i couldnt walk. So im trying to get back to my $210 i was at before (im 6' 2") but until then......

    If i go with a new colt. The xse maybe. It would be commander. If i take ot to a smith for throating/polishing and get good mags, so u guess feel it would be reliable with hollow points? And would it hold up agains mud and such and still fire reliably before cleaning?

    I really would like to go with a 1911for many reasons. But the two things listed about are criteria that must be met. Gun price of the xse and mags and thraoting is much less then a wilson off the self. But if the quality just isnt there with the colt its ultimately a waist of money.
     
  17. otasan56

    otasan56 Member

    Joined:
    Oct 20, 2011
    Messages:
    292
    Location:
    Hartford, VT
    I like my two M1911a1 pistols just fine. I use them in competition shooting matches. But for CCW I use my G17. 17 rounds of reassurance.
     
  18. Skribs

    Skribs Member

    Joined:
    Oct 29, 2010
    Messages:
    5,807
    Location:
    Lakewood, Washington
    Well, XDs and G36 would be up your alley if you want a single-stack .45, at least in terms of size. Probably better than most 1911s.

    Personally, I think the 9 is fine. Overall there's not going to be much difference. But if you want .45, I ain't gonna argue, just state my opinion is all.

    I can't speak for the durability of the 1911, but most "Glock vs. 1911" threads turn into questions of manual safety vs. passive safety. The manual safety provides some extra protection (if something goes into the trigger guard with safety on, it won't depress the trigger), but it also can provide a false sense of security ("it's on safe don't worr-" BANG). Personally I want a simple gun, so I'd go for the Glock or XDs if I were in your situation.

    If you have a problem with a double-stack printing, try going up a shirt size, i.e. if you wear a large, go XL. Alternatively, if legal in your area, you can consider open carry.
     
  19. Eb1

    Eb1 Member

    Joined:
    Jan 15, 2008
    Messages:
    3,010
    Location:
    USA
    I love my 2007 XD9 4", but I cannot carry it without printing.
     
  20. tarosean

    tarosean Member

    Joined:
    Oct 22, 2010
    Messages:
    5,403
    Location:
    TX
    Are you trying at 3 o clock? You can use the "handles" to your advantage by going behind them @ 4-5 o clock...
     
  21. gibson_es

    gibson_es Member

    Joined:
    Jul 13, 2011
    Messages:
    204
    Location:
    tampa bay
    Safeties are not mu concern. Part of why i started a new thread was necaiae your right, thats were they emd up. I wanted a view from a different angle. Unfortunately floroda does not habe open carry. Aa for shirt size i actually yried goong up two sizes. Tried some that were big and tall as well... no hope. Im considering getting the xse and a glock. Carrying the xse on a day to day. But when i plan to go on tje water or to the mid hole or in the woods, go with the glock...

    Or maybe a revolver and not a glock. The only issue there is that the one i want is no longer made so i gotta search for it. Lol.

    Im left handed. I was trying at 7-9. Any were in there. Gave a few other options a quick try like 10-11to and 6. But most effort was between 7-9... the lefties 3-5.
     
  22. Eb1

    Eb1 Member

    Joined:
    Jan 15, 2008
    Messages:
    3,010
    Location:
    USA
    If I am not pocket carrying my 731 UL 32 H&R 6 shooter. It is at 2-2:30 IWB. Makes for a quick grab, and doesn't bind when driving or sitting being a small J frame. Something to think about.
     
  23. MCMXI

    MCMXI Member

    Joined:
    Jul 1, 2008
    Messages:
    7,373
    Location:
    NW Montana
    I would suggest that you take a serious look at a Dan Wesson V-Bob if you want to carry a 1911 and not pay $3,500 for the privilege. I have a couple of Dan Wessons and they have proven to be extremely reliable regardless of the type of ammunition. I've shot a bunch of 185gr and 230gr Golden Saber JHP with no issues at all. If you decide to go the DW route, I would recommend that you contact Dave Severns and order from him since he'll make sure that everything is as it should be.

    https://severnscustom.com/
     
  24. Storz

    Storz Member

    Joined:
    Dec 16, 2007
    Messages:
    187
    Location:
    Fuquay Varina, NC
    If you like the grip angle of the 1911 get an XD. If you like the Glock grip get that. O carry a fullsoze G17 in a supertuck and it doesn't print.

    Or perhaps one of the Kahr 45s
    Sent from my Desire HD using Tapatalk 2
     
  25. Jed Carter

    Jed Carter Member

    Joined:
    Oct 19, 2008
    Messages:
    1,410
    Location:
    LEXINGTON, KY
    I carry a CCO sized 1911 made by SIG, it feeds everything. Just to be on the safe side I use Cor-bon PowRball ammunition, this will cycle even in my most finicky 1911. Sometimes it's the magazine, or the feed ramp, or the barrel throat, or just ammunition issues. If I had a favorite 1911 that would only feed Ball ammunition, I would be OK with that. 230gr ball ammunition is very effective, but may tend to over penetrate. Federal has expanding full metal jacket ammunition that also feeds well in all my 1911s.
     
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page