Quantcast
  1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

.38 Special+P vs. .357 Magnum

Discussion in 'Handloading and Reloading' started by jkulysses, Apr 8, 2010.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. jkulysses

    jkulysses Member

    Joined:
    Apr 3, 2010
    Messages:
    211
    Location:
    Oregon
    Is the .38+P sufficient in a 2" revolver for self defense concealed carry or should I just put the .357 Mags in there? I tried searching but wasn't having much luck. I'm picking up my new revolver tomorrow and not sure which rounds to pick up for when I actually carry it. I got a few boxes of regular .38 Special just so I can get used to the gun but haven't bought any actual self defense rounds yet.
     
    Last edited: Apr 8, 2010
  2. Gryffydd

    Gryffydd Member

    Joined:
    Jan 7, 2009
    Messages:
    1,781
    Location:
    W. Washington
    If the gun takes both, buy and try both. If you the 357 rounds work for you--recoil isn't too bad and you can still make followup shots quickly, might as well carry them. You may find the experience is less than pleasant though. Not to mention issues with too much muzzle flash and eardrum busting loudness. There are a lot of good reasons to carry .38s for defense even if the revolver can shoot 357s. But to answer your first question, yes, .38+P is definitely sufficient.
     
  3. 243winxb

    243winxb Member

    Joined:
    Jul 7, 2004
    Messages:
    8,995
    Location:
    USA
    For defense, bullet design is very important. Federal Hydra-Shok JHP work well. .38+P is sufficient in a 2" revolver for self defense concealed carry. Recovery time from recoil is important. Depending on the weight of your firearm, you might not evey like the +P. My 10 oz. gun is a handfull.
     
  4. jkulysses

    jkulysses Member

    Joined:
    Apr 3, 2010
    Messages:
    211
    Location:
    Oregon
    It's fairly heavy so shouldn't be as bad. It's like 26 oz which is right up there with the Ruger sp101 lol.
     
  5. hydraulicman

    hydraulicman Member

    Joined:
    Jun 18, 2009
    Messages:
    226
    my ruger sp101 roars with .357 mags

    I load 38s for self defense because i can shoot them better with my weak hand if need be
     
  6. 351 WINCHESTER

    351 WINCHESTER Member

    Joined:
    Mar 19, 2007
    Messages:
    4,051
    Years ago I tried to master a 2 1/2" model 66 with remington 125 full house loads. The gun crapped out on me around 350 rounds and no I never mastered it. Way too much recoil and muzzle blast.

    Now, if someone was on top of me betting the hell out of me a .357 would be a very good thing to have.
     
  7. Steve C

    Steve C Member

    Joined:
    Jan 5, 2006
    Messages:
    4,673
    A snub nose revolver is a compromise where you give up power for portability. There is significant velocity loss of about 150 to 200 fps from a 4" barrel when you drop to a 2" barrel. You can buy some pretty hot .38 spl loads from Buffalo bore that will approach what you would probably get from a mid range .357 mag and and make up most if not all the 2" difference. They definitely have more pop to them than the .38 +P offerings from the major manufacturers.

    The more powerful and theoretically more effective ammo is going to produce more recoil, flash and muzzle blast that is amplified in a short barrel pistol. As Gryffydd posted, its best to try some different rounds out to see if you can tolerate this and want to shoot them.

    In selecting .357 magnum ammo the 125gr Remington Golden Sabers may be a good option as they are loaded to a mid level velocity of around 1,220 fps from a 4" barrel while the typical full power 125gr mag is loaded to 1,450 fps.

    Ammo is probably over thought for civilian self defense, its psychologically about what gives confidence to the person carrying it. Ammo selection is much more important to those in Law enforcement who run towards danger. Even a mild wad cutter load or the often maligned 158gr LRN will work for self defense under most circumstances. Now that is the logical rational mind talking, because I don't pay much attention to it and still want the most effective ammo I can carry.
     
  8. BADUNAME37

    BADUNAME37 Member

    Joined:
    Aug 10, 2008
    Messages:
    4,434
    I find that it is more important to have an accurate and controllable load, i.e., one that you can 'rapid-fire' the cylinder-full and still be COM within 21 feet, than it is to have a 'Bazooka' that is deafening, has about a 12" group at 21 feet and takes a second or two to get situated back on target with the thing due to all the recoil, muzzle flash, etc.

    Besides, the calmer loads will make your gun last longer -- especially over severely, extremely POWERFUL loads that seem impressive! A steady diet of those and you can loosen up a gun in no time!:eek:
     
  9. BADUNAME37

    BADUNAME37 Member

    Joined:
    Aug 10, 2008
    Messages:
    4,434
    bump - double post - please delete
     
  10. ArchAngelCD

    ArchAngelCD Member

    Joined:
    Nov 25, 2006
    Messages:
    22,115
    Location:
    Northeast PA, USA
    Well stated post and I agree as long as the .38 Special +P ammo you are using will perform well from a short barrel. (like the FBI Load, 135gr Speer short barrel ammo and a few others)
     
  11. Old Shooter

    Old Shooter Member

    Joined:
    Feb 10, 2010
    Messages:
    1,040
    Location:
    Virginia
    Yes, 38 Special +P will work fine for your 2" revolver for self defense loads.

    .357 will work just as well with a lot more flash, bang and boom without much if any improvement in performance at self defense ranges.

    Try both. My choice is the .38 Special 158 gr SJHP but others prefer the .357. with 125 gr JHP.

    I can rapid fire the 38's with good recovery and on target accuracy, I can't do that with the hot 357's.

    Your results may be different.
     
  12. joneb

    joneb Member

    Joined:
    Aug 18, 2005
    Messages:
    3,724
    Location:
    Oregon
  13. TonyT

    TonyT Member

    Joined:
    Apr 22, 2004
    Messages:
    1,353
    Location:
    Michigan
    I stick with 38 Special loads in my snub nosed revolvers. The report of 357 Magnums in those short barreled guns is more than I can tolerate and I am unable to adequately control those light revolvers with 357 Mag ammo.
     
  14. RebelRabbi

    RebelRabbi Member

    Joined:
    Jan 22, 2010
    Messages:
    78
  15. angel1216

    angel1216 Member

    Joined:
    Jan 1, 2008
    Messages:
    185
    Location:
    Grand Prairie, TEXAS
    both are proven to be effective! you can't go wrong with the gold dot short barrel. 38+P or 357.
     
  16. T.A.Sharps

    T.A.Sharps Member

    Joined:
    Dec 3, 2009
    Messages:
    116
    Everything stated above is accurate...

    ...but as this is a CCW question, there could be a Legal hassle using a .38spl in a .357, or using a magnum cartridge at all.

    Generally it is a good idea to use the round the gun was made for. And to stay away from magnum rounds. For no good reason, just that it would be something to give a prosecutor an inch of meat to bite on too.
     
  17. Hondo 60
    • Contributing Member

    Hondo 60 Member

    Joined:
    Sep 6, 2009
    Messages:
    5,324
    Location:
    Manitowoc, WI
    T.A.Sharps:

    Huh? Sorry but I don't follow your answer. If the gun in question is a 357 magnum, how can you...

    Maybe I'm just thick. but that doesn't make sense to me. (Not trying to flame, just trying to understand)
     
  18. AKElroy

    AKElroy Member

    Joined:
    Feb 11, 2009
    Messages:
    3,417
    Location:
    Past & Future Republic of Texas
    Do you have any evidence to sight for this claim? I am aware of exactly ZERO such prosecutions, and studying this topic is pretty much my only hobby. Using .38 spl loads in lighter .357 chambered guns is an extremely common and prudent practice. How it could paint one as bloodthirsty escapes me.
     
  19. Hey_Allen

    Hey_Allen Member

    Joined:
    Sep 3, 2008
    Messages:
    111
    Location:
    Tacoma, WA
    .38 special is also listed as an approved cartridge by the manufacturers of the said .357 caliber guns, to the best of my knowledge.

    Personal preference, I carry .38 special in my SP-101, rather than .357 mag, for the same reason as many above.
    With .38 special, I can control it and keep it on target.
    When I have the .357 mag rounds going downrange, it's definitely a good bit more difficult to keep on target, and I'd hate to hear it without plugs in!

    Personal ammo preference, Hornady Critical Defense, and Winchester PDX1. Whatever floats your boat, though.
     
  20. OYE

    OYE Member

    Joined:
    Apr 17, 2010
    Messages:
    532
    357 Magnum Velocity Variation in Different Guns-different barrel lengths.
    Speer Manual # 12 has an interesting article on Page 435 by that title. They tested 27 different .357 handguns with the same load in 3 different bullet weights. Worth a read.
    Example: 158 grain spread in the 6 in. barrel models was 1002 to 1284 fps
    Example: 158 grain spread in the 2.5 in. models was 989 to 1034 fps ( Whoa !!!!!!)


    Wouldn't want to get hit with a +P or a 357. Doesn't seem consistent with being alive.
     
  21. T.A.Sharps

    T.A.Sharps Member

    Joined:
    Dec 3, 2009
    Messages:
    116
    I know there is nothing wrong with shooting .38's in a .357mag. That is one of the great things about getting something chambered in .357mag.

    Yurko
    That was meant to be two considerations for a concealed carry weapon, not for a .357 load, perhaps I didn't word it clearly.

    And the other part was from my concealed carry class, and the cases they cited I didn't bother to write down. But some of the points were...

    Loading a 38 in a pistol marked .357 brings into question your intent. For the same reason you "can't" load rock salt in a 12ga.

    And the hippy liberal idea that if you use a round marked magnum, well that just means you REALLY want to kill someone.

    THESE ARE NOT MY IDEAS, these are maggot infested hippy liberal ideas that can be used to put blame and doubt on you in a court, and I wouldn't trust a prosecutor not to.

    Personally, I don't think there would be anything better than to carry a .357mag with whatever load you like the best. I know both of the ideas are retarded, and don't make any sense, but they were brought up in my class and I would rather error on the side of caution, and not find out in court how liberal the people in my county really are.

    jkulysses
    To your question, I think, legally, using a .357 in it would be best for carrying that revolver.
     
    Last edited: Jun 26, 2010
  22. amd6547

    amd6547 Member

    Joined:
    May 27, 2006
    Messages:
    1,773
    Location:
    North Coast of OHIO
    Speaking as a well armed old hippy, I find those concerns to be pathetic.
     
  23. Cody Banks

    Cody Banks Member

    Joined:
    Mar 16, 2010
    Messages:
    13
    I had the unpleasant experience to pop off a .357 at the skeet field one day, without my muffs on. It actually tore into my soul and ripped out my spine. I have been shooting since I was 8 years old, and at 56, I can honestly say that one shot was the loudest piercing sound I have ever heard in my life. Always wear ear protection, and with magnums, use plugs and muffs too.
     
  24. zxcvbob

    zxcvbob Member

    Joined:
    Sep 15, 2007
    Messages:
    5,061
    Location:
    S.E. Minnesota
    That one is just ridiculous.
     
  25. Old Ranger

    Old Ranger Member

    Joined:
    Jun 30, 2010
    Messages:
    67
    There is .38 + P factory ammo out there specifically designed for snubbies. My carry is a snubbie; so I've tried some of it in wet pack and chronographed it. Some stuff, like the hydra shocks - - - don't open up. Gold dots sort of do, and penetrate well - - - but the best all around factory load I've found; at least for my snubbie; is the Remington Ultimate Home Defense load. It doesn't penetrate wet pack like the Gold Dot, but it mushrooms completely and clocks about 930 out of my little dragon.

    I do roll my own, and can get about the same velocity - - - but I only carry factory ammo. I think too, that the .38 with that load is better than .357 for a variety of reasons.
     
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page