Discussion in 'Handloading and Reloading' started by Mike44, Aug 20, 2014.
Some chambers have shorter leades than others, so you have to load your ammunition for that chamber. Seat the bullet so there is just a couple thousandths of the shoulder above the case mouth and see if that solves your problem. If it does, and the rounds will still feed from the magazine reliably, then work up your load with that OAL, whatever it turns out to be.
Hope this helps.
I have gotten lazy and seat them all to suit my shortest chamber of late, though.
About .93" to the shoulder instead of MEhavey's .94".
My 45 ACP Springfield
Had a short chamber and with my lead lead bullets, I would have chambering problems. Same rounds would drop into my S&W 625-8 revolvers without issue.
I had a gunsmith open up the headspace which helped.
I ended up buying and fitting a KART barrel which has been very nice.
To much head space will allow primers to protrude and pop out. I have read that some GI 1911's actually headspaced on the extractor due to generous tolerances. Not a problem with crimped primer pockets.
jacketed bullets have never been a problem
Headspace checks are not determined by plunking either. Plunking is to see if your loaded cartridge fits the chamber. If it doesn't the taper crimp is usually the issue.
"...Hodgdon web site shows 1.225"..." For a LSWC. 1.200" for an RN. Don't worry too much about OAL. Too short is more of an issue.
My old Lyman book says 1.275" is max OAL. Been using that myself for eons.
Many thanks to everyone for the helpfull replies
I must say that this is a great forum. Many thanks to all who replied. I am going to shorten the OAL as suggested then test some dummy loads for feed issues. If all is well, I will work up a load.
Never say never, I have loaded thousands that do.
They don't headspace with the bullet against the chamber mouth, that diameter is irrelevant; they headspace with the SWC shoulder against the origin of the rifling.
Hodgdon OAL numbers are just weird.
The SAAMI maximum can cause trouble if you are not loading the elliptical nosed hardball bullet, too.
45 acp col
Jim Watson +1 How i do it for slow fire cast lead rounds. Depends on how the barrel is chambered. I learned it from an old NRA reprint on the 45 acp years ago. [/URL][/IMG]
There is one caveat about the Lee Factory Crimp Die (FCD). Particularly with lead lead bullets and exacerbated with thick-walled brass, the Post-sizing ring has the POTENTIAL to cause the bullet to be undersized for your bore.
Some people go so far as to knock the post-sizing ring out of the die to avoid this. (But getting it back in is probably impossible).
With undersized bullets, leading may occur and accuracy and velocity may suffer.
Like I said, there is the potential for these problems, which has not stopped me from using the 4-die set for my 45 ACP shooting with lead bullets. I just measure a previously loaded and pulled bullet. No problems for me so far, but if I ever get a 45 ACP with oversized barrel bore or overly thick brass, it could happen.
(edit) There is also the question of the post-sizing causing a reduction in neck tension (this is also primarily exhibited in lead bullets), but that is another subject.
I settled on a OAL of 1.240 after cycling dummy rounds. I set the Lee FCD to crimp to .471 and checked that the bullets were not getting squeezed to a smaller diameter. I worked up a load using AutoComp. All of the rounds (75) cycled fine and shot well. I did get one crushed shell on eject, so I will up the load a little so see if that helps. I found that the barrel was easy to clean up with two passes with a bronze brush. I really like the clean holes in the targets. After I use up my supply of plated 45ACP bullets, I am switching to the Missouri Bullet Bullseye #1 200gr. LSWC. Thanks to everyone for the helpful information.
Not disagreeing ....this is a search for knowledge....how do you know that is what happens? How did you measure that?
When the cartridge is head spaced as described, where is the mouth of the case in relation to the headspace step in the barrel?
Using an auto pistol barrel find a MAX O.A.L with your bullet
Pete D. See Walkalong's thread http://www.thehighroad.org/showthread.php?t=506678
It sounds like you did everything correctly and you have a good load.
What are the charge weights of AutoComp you are using? What was the original charge and the upped charge weight? I have not tried Autocomp yet, do you like it? How accurate is AutoComp compared to the powder you were using?
I first tested with 5 rounds each at 6.6, 6.7, 6.8, 6.9 and 7.0gr. I decided on 6.9 given that it cycled and ejected fine and the shells were not charred. I did get one crushed case with further testing, so I decided to go to 7.0. Today I shot the last of the bullet samples I had (28) and they worked fine with no crushed cases. The Hodgdon web site shows a range of 6.6 to 7.2 gr. for 200gr. LSWC bullets with Autocomp.
I am using Autocomp because I could find it and it can be used in .380, 9MM, and 45ACP (these are the only calibers I load so far). Autocomp meters very well using my Lee Pro Auto Disk Powder measure. I can't offer any useful comparisons with other powders as I am fairly new to reloading and don't have experience with other powders other than Accurate #7 which I used for 9MM until I ran out.
You CAN, but you SHOULDN'T
Headspacing for your purposes is to hold the cartridge up against the breechface so the firing pin strike will ignite the primer, right?
You can accomplish that by the bullet engaging the rifling, But this is not reliable if you happen to fire your cartridges in a different gun or a different barrel or if your rifling eventually gets a little worn or if your bullets' ogive differs one to another.
You can accomplish that by the extractor engaging the extractor groove. People have even been able to fire 380ACP and 9mm Makarov in a 9mm Parabellum chamber. I imagine this would allow 45GAP to be fired in a 45ACP chamber in the same way. But this is not reliable if you have a slightly thinner rim or a little wear on your extractor.
SAAMI specs suggest the proper way to headspace is on the case mouth.
p.s. Many rifle shooters (whose cartridges headspace on the shoulder) set their bullets to just "kiss" the rifling (seeking superior accuracy), but they DON'T use the bullet to headspace.
My Sig 1911 barrel has almost no leade with sharp angled/quick start of rifling (left picture) as compared to 40S&W Lone Wolf barrel with longer leade and slower start of rifling (right picture). With the same Missouri 200 gr SWC (Bullseye #1), my max OAL/COL is 1.245". Any longer and the shoulder of the bullet/bearing surface will hit the start of rifling.
Sig 1911 barrel with almost no leade and Lone Wolf barrel with longer leade (white arrow)
Glad things worked out.
Separate names with a comma.