AR15 and AK47, or M1A?

Buy the AR15 and AK47, or just the M1A?

  • Get the Colt 6920 and Arsenal SGL21-61. Simple tools for the utilatarian.

    Votes: 102 76.1%
  • Get the M1A SOCOM. It's as simple as it is elegant.

    Votes: 32 23.9%

  • Total voters
    134
  • Poll closed .
Status
Not open for further replies.
I'll give you that, in a situation where you were engaging targets on the street where you may be poking holes in car doors or cutting through sheet rock and studs, the 7.62x39 is going to shine. But as far as room clearing, depending on shooter discipline, one could argue the "knockdown power" doesn't mean much. I think of it like this, in a room that is say 20'x20' or smaller, your maximum engagement range is less than seven yards so that 7.62 bullet is still screaming fast meaning it's more likely to just cut through soft targets' leaving a neat little hole and not transferring much of it's energy. The 5.45 with it's hollow cavity in the nose is likely to still yaw and tumble meaning it will transfer the majority of it's energy and not OVER PENETRATING which is something people overlook all too often. Another factor to consider is that in that situation, I wouldn't trust one round to do the job so I'm going give him a hammer pair or maybe even do a triple tap for insurance. So which weapon is going to allow me to get back on target the fastest? Probably that 5.45x39... that is how I justify using it in my mind anyway.
Touché, Chisum, touché.

But we can agree that either round has shortcomings, so it then becomes "what niche needs filled?" Triple taps, or putting them down the first time? Hmmm...

But, since the OP has decided AK47 is the way to go, he knows his niche.

To the OP: The AK doesn't have horrible recoil, but if the little miss is recoil adverse, get her the AR.
 
Barring the Colt 901 showing up anytime soon.. and you still have to buy a 5.56 upper for it, the AR/AK combo is pretty flexible. The MSRP is around 2 grand.

With the Socom you give up the longer barrel, on an AR you can buy a dedicated target/varmint upper for long range.
 
gotta add the M1A as being more "collectable" in terms of history & beauty.
As simple tools the AR/AK combined (2 calibers) would be more "practical"
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top