Discussion in 'Handguns: General Discussion' started by miamivicedade, Sep 4, 2021.
My collection will never be complete. There will always be "just one more" that I want.
I nearly bought one of those 30ish years ago.
gunbroker is your friend, especially if you are looking for the higher-quality original gen2 bond arms derringers:
second one is “buy now” for $300, which is just $50ish more than the price of a lesser-quality rowdy/roughneck.
since b.a. derringers are built stoutly and shot little, i wouldn’t worry about getting a used-up lemon. i do worry about the lower finishing of the rowdy/roughneck, as worry-free barrel interchangeability requires uniform platform finishing to a consistently high level of common precision. i learned the hard way, others are happy, ymmv.
Anyways, back to the SnakeSlayer. If you want to do it up right, buy the generic ClipDraw. But don't use that glue strip. Have a good gunsmith drill and tap it so the clip screws directly to the firearm. It works really well!
Do gimmick derringers shooting obsolete/irrelevant cartridges have a real world purpose in 2022?
lol come on guy. Of course not. You'd be better served with a snubbie J frame .38.
Actually Rowdys are about $300. Roughneck about $280. So you are saying the Rough Series are lower quality based on some trouble mounting a different barrel? I would guess that that was a factory defect. The Rough Series guns are supposed to be every bit as high of quality as their more expensive guns, just a budget finish.
Absolutely they have a purpose. They are a lot of fun to shoot. We buy them more as toys than for self defense.
I think they were referring to the American Derringer 'Alaskan Survival 45-70' Derringer I posted. Those are on Gunbroker though.
I think you got a lemon Roughneck. Mine has been 100% reliable, and completely interchangeable with the normal barrels. Again, zero problems over two years. Also, I bet I've fired more rounds than your average derringer buyer. My estimate is 300 rounds out of the derringer so far. It passed the 300 round test, which is pretty normative for any guns to test whether it is working properly or not.
1) Collectible: As far as history, derringers are one of the most iconic handguns
3) Still serve same function they did 100 years ago, but even better quality and more powerful cartridges. Are there better self defense guns? Of course.
Right, in my experience the Roughneck and Rowdy BAs are plenty quality and reliable. Their frame isn't as polished, but in reality one doesn't need that for a functional firearm. They are still better built and will outlast likely 90% of semiautos (if not all). I bet if one took care of any BA, it will last 100 years.
What does that have to do with anything? Necklaces, rings, and other jewelry don't have a "real world" purpose. Paintings or art sculpture don't have a "real world" purpose. Neither do bowling balls or golf clubs for that matter. None of those things will help you when attacked by marauding hordes of evil-doers so they must be useless too. There are lots of things that have no real purpose yet, oddly, some people enjoy having and owning them.
I have (so far) 7 Bond Arms derringers. I carry a J frame "snubbie".
I like it. Why monkey with switching out barrels. This is how I was thinking too. Maybe I should get that Roughneck 45 ACP vs. another barrel.
And I too carry a J-frame.
That's my view.
People collect far less functional things than firearms, including derringers. They collect jewelry, art, antiques, etc.
I’ve carried my BA only 3 odd times. My normal carry is a .380 semi auto.
For me anyway, shooting is fun and having a gun with a purpose is practical, but as already mentioned previously a collection, even if not fired, is very satisfying just like jewelry, art, etc etc is to someone else.
The person asked for a 'real world purpose' on something as subjective as a gun. For a *real world purpose* the answer is no. Only a knucklehead would genuinely carry a 2 shot gun in a goofy caliber, if my definition of real world purpose is the same as the OPs.
If the purpose is C&R (no, they're new production) or just neato range toys, sure. Fine. That's a purpose I guess.
Jewelry and art can appreciate in value, not gimmicks like modern production derringers.
The rest are range toys and firearms that I bought because they were cool and interesting. I enjoy them. None of them are worth much, but I like to shoot them and tinker with them and admire them.
My kids are already taken care of, but after I croak they can get some more money from my firearms. My tools and antique vehicles will also be worth something. I'm guessing they'll just give away my thousands of books.
When my dad passed, he had 20-something guitars, My stepmom gave them to me and my sister, We spent a few hours estimating their value and dividing them up. We each saved a couple for sentimental reasons, and the rest we slowly sold on Ebay. My dad loved his guitars and enjoyed them. He didn't purchase them as investments, but we did well with them regardless.
What barrel would give me more recoil? .2.5 inch 45 ACP? 2.5 inch .357 magnum? The .357 ought to really kick, more than any other barrel they offer, because they don't offer magnum barrels in either .44 or .45.
.357 mag, compared to .45 acp or colt. But, I thought they did make .44 mag barrel at one point
Perhaps 44 Magnum at one time, but I don't see it on their site now. There are some more unusual that I am not aware how they would recoil:
They've never made a .44 Magnum. That was American Derringer.
Any of those should give you more. The .45 Colt only would as well, I believe. With the .45/.410 barrel there is a lot of freebore before the .45 bullet engages the rifling. At the point the bullet meets the resistance of the rifling it is actually pushing the gun forward briefly, offsetting some of the recoil. I know .45 ACP seems harsher to me than a .45 Colt from a .410 barrel despite the bullets in my ACP loads being 25 grains lighter than my Colt loads and both having similar velocities from my 1911 and Ruger Redhawk respectively. There's also the issue of gas blow-by in the .410 barrel reducing velocity. The bullet is spending quite a bit of time in a part of the barrel that is larger diameter than it is.
The longer barrels (not .410) would technically have more felt recoil due to higher velocities and longer recoil impulse time but how noticeable it would be I can't say. I haven't done a side-by-side comparison between my 2.5 and 3" .45 ACPs but I suspect the difference would be negligible.
Back to the dry firing. Found this page at Bond Arms that repeats what my manual says about not recommending snap caps, but to use spent cases to dry fire, but adds that dry firing should be "for a few rounds only." It sounds like they basically do not recommend dry firing. I am okay with that. I want to fire real ammo, more fun!
They totally do not recommend any dry firing of the .22s, but I would think so long as you put the spent case so that a fresh part of the brass rim is under the firing pin it would work. Notice on the .22 the barrel centers are closer together so that the firing pins align with the rim. That was a clever way to accommodate rimfire without redesigning the frame with the pins closer together.
Not going to lie, if they come out with a new .22 BA I'm all over that. Or .32.
Some of these barrels are random lol. Like, who really wanted a 30 carbine derringer? Or 45-70 for that matter.
If the 45 Glock is .45 GAP, then it will be roughly similar to .45 ACP, as that was the intent of that cartridge.
Mostly useless. Surprised they even make such barrels. They do have quite the caliber selection right now, but lacking in the small calibers.
Right, I would bet you that there is a far bigger demand for .22 lr, .32 acp, etc.
Yeah, either .22 or .32 would be fun. Depends on my barrel budget. Right now I am waffling between a 2.5" .45 ACP or a 3.5" .45 ACP and leaning to 3.5", but then that is $100 short of the whole Roughneck, a second gun for only an extra $100. But I would like the .45 ACP and then once I buy a stash of ammo for it, I will have good reason to get a .45 ACP semi-auto, looking for non-plastic and full DA. The AMT Backup .45 looks great. Neighbor has it, but on this site it gets a lot of bad reviews.
Separate names with a comma.