Buckshot 101...

Status
Not open for further replies.

Dave McCracken

Moderator In Memoriam
Joined
Dec 20, 2002
Messages
13,936
Location
MD.
During the English Civil War in the 1600s, Cromwell's Arquebusiers used "Divers Small Schotte or Pistole Balles" in their matchlocks for CQB as well as a single large projectile of near bore diameter.

They won.

Later, during our own Civil Unpleasantness, "Buck and Ball" loads in old muskets helped give places like Bloody Lane at Antietam their names.

Earlier use of multiple pellet loads is probable, the effect of multiple hits has remained a constant since gunpowder was invented.

Nowadays, if you have a shotgun you plan on using to defend yourself, family and community, it's probably best charged with buckshot.

These days, large shot used for hunting medium game and for defense are called buckshot. A primary use in America was hunting deer. Writers like Archibald Rutledge, Nash Buckingham etc, wrote exciting stories about thick cover deer hunting with shotguns and large shot.

Currently in the US, Buck runs from about .23 caliber for 4 buck to .36 caliber or so for 0000.

The most common used is 00. Double Ought is .33 caliber and starts off at 9 pellets in a 12 gauge shell and going up to 15 in 3 1/2" magnums.

For the record, 15 pellets in the real world do little more than 9.

Can you say, "Overkill", Boys and Girls?

Some reduced recoil loads use just 8 pellets of 00. And, I've experimented with ultralight 6 pellet 00 loads. These last work just as well for inside the house. The R/R stuff patterns tightly in most cases, a good thing.

1 buck is a quite useful size also, and the biggest size available for the 16 gauge. Some 20 gauge ammo is loaded with 2 buck, but 3 buck is more widely marketed and used.

Some 410 buck loads are out there, with 2 or 3 00 pellets in them, but these are not very effective and usually pattern terribly.

Still,most buck used now is 00 and used in 12 gauge shotguns. It's quite effective for CQB in almost any conditions.

1 buck retains almost as much mass (needed for penetration) and has a higher pellet count, but 00 sells 10 times faster. Tradition and track record account for that, in my opinion. Testing has indicated that 1 buck may be where the lines for penetration and pellet count cross on the graph.

Most depts and agencies use 00, but the FBI used and still may use 4 buck, which they tested and decided on in the 50s. I believe their concern was with overpenetration, always something to think of.

Buck is also used in deer hunting, oft with dogs and in thick cover. It has little use for game much larger than whitetails. Wild hog hunters learned a long time ago that slugs beat buck all hollow on stuff weighing more than 300 lbs and inclined to bite back.

African Pro hunters often used SSG Buck(Similar to 000) for wounded leopards and such, but not for lion.

Some Southern deer hunters have worked up custom handloads of hard buck that pushed the envelope on distance limits and knockdown power, sometimes using 10 gauges and buffered loads carefully worked up to maximize effect.

Still, 50 yards is about the max distance buck should be used under any circumstances, and 25 is more realistic for most conditions and opportunities.

Like other pellet loads, patterning is crucial. I can double or halve pattern size in one 870 here just by swapping loads. While what works well in one shotgun often does well in others, vagaries are common and we HAVE to know what our load of choice will do under real world conditions in our shotguns.

As I've often written before, a HD load is best patterned at the longest possible shot opp in your house plus one yard as well as at 25 yards or so. Look for a spread of less than 15", the average width of the human torso at center mass.

As for what size, that's your choice, but 00 is hardly ever a bad idea.....
 
Last edited:
Great post!

I really like the OO RR buck from remington, it is very easy to shoot quickly and accurately, I can hit a paper plate with it as fast as I can shuck shells :)
 
Outstanding. Thanks Dave.
I've had a five round box of 3" 00 buck Winchester floating around here for about a year. They were given to me by my uncle (ain't no reason for me to spend good money on 3 inchers). I've had plans to do some paterning @ 10 and 25yds with some Horandy TAP 00 this weekend as well as some Rem 00 cheapies. I guess its about as good a time as any to use 'em up. I'll try to post some pix of both later this weekend .
cs
 
The Hornady TAP is a joy to shoot and groups TIGHT out of my 18" Cyl bore.
Picked up a box of Remmy Wally World Specs tonight (9 pellets). Maybe get out Sunday.

Stay safe.
Bob
 
Thanks, folks. A coupla things....

We have a wealth of buck these days if we stick to 12 gauge, and that's not a bad idea. Those big pellets need some room in the bore. While I've seen some very tight patterns from tightly choked barrels, open chokes, IMO, run more consistently.

Tom Roster, shotgun guru and researcher, says that a long forcing cone really comes into its own with big shot, and buck is the biggest.

When I had my first barrel done with a long cone, patterns with the ammo at hand tightened up 4-6" at 25 yards. This was in the early 80s.

8404, tradition plays a large part in 00 over 1. But, back in the early 20th Century, 00 had a bit of an advantage with the greater mass. Both sizes were made of dead soft lead, and the smaller pellets deformed more. Now, with good buck alloyed from tin and lead, and enclosed in a shot cup with buffering, the difference is much less.

Rupestris, please post some pics. Thanks...

Bob, note the kick and compare the patterns. Betcha that 3" stuff comes in last....
 
The TAP is "reduced recoil". I love it but can't find any more locally. Probably gonna order the Fed Tac from Ammoman. The Remmys are 2 3/4" 9 pellet. But they're at hand and only $6.47/ box of 15. Gotta get a Decellerator and Side saddle next trip to Cabela's. My 870 has the 4 rd mag. Also, AMAZING difference between any 1 1/8 oz load and the harder to find 1oz. Thanks for that tip a long while back. Worth repeating for new shotgunners!

How the shoulder?

Stay safe.
Bob

After Katrina and the French fiasco, I'm trying to stock up on shotty shells!!
 
Dave,

Back in the late '90s I decided to see what could be done about extending the "A Zone" of a shotgun loaded with buckshot. So I commenced experimenting. Some time and a few hundred dollars later I was prepared to obliterate 3X5 cards at 25 yards (saves money on patterning paper, ya know). Never did get attacked by index cards but boy was I ready for them if they ever showed up. The high dollar combination was a Patternmaster choke tube, Federal LE 132 buckshot and an extended forcing cone in an 18" 870 barrel with ghost ring sights installed on the gun.

Then I began wondering if there was a less expensive way to get there. Remington helped a bit by starting to make short barrels with IMP CYL chokes from the factory. That reduced barrel modification costs to a mere $30 for a forcing cone job on 20" RS barrels, even though really tight patterns still required MOD chokes the IMP CYL was useful enough to use. I started looking around to see if anyone else was interested in this stuff too. And I found that other people were.

One of them was Mark Penman. He was even writing about it on his website , now archived at http://www.jtk3.com/laissezfirearm/ :

The 75-Yard Riot Gun?
http://www.jtk3.com/laissezfirearm/870full.htm

Buckshot Patterning Test Results
http://www.jtk3.com/laissezfirearm/buckshot.htm

So I went back to the drawing board, and found that using my extended- cone 18" barrel with a $14 RemChoke MOD tube (instead of the $100 Patternmaster) and the old version of Estate Low Recoil 00 buck ($3 a box of 10), I could duplicate or improve the patterns produced by the high priced spread.

I don't want to open up the whole tight pattern vs open pattern argument again. Anyone is welcome to seek whatever level of performance out of their shotgun they want, I am not going to say that tight patterns are the only way to go. But if I WANT a shotgun to pattern tightly at a bit longer range, I now know I can make it do so. In fact that 18" barrel with the Patternmaster tube is dangerous to goblins out at 100 yards with 3" Federal Premium loads of 000 buck- pretty much an area weapon, certainly, and not a point weapon at that range, though it will still put 3-5 of the 10 pellets in the shell into an E type silhouette out there. The big problem with buckshot, as with all spherical projectiles, is poor sectional density. That means pellets shed energy far too quickly to be really effective at longer ranges.

Thing is, I can easily get open patterns if I want them. All I have to do is change ammo to S&B, and voila- instant wide open patterns. All the things that tight patterning buckshot offers, S&B lacks. Dead soft lead pellets, no grex or plastic buffering to pad and separate the pellets, no wizardly wad to absorb the punch of firing- the very prescription for real scattering scattergun ammunition. I haven't found any other shotgun fodder that opens up as much or as reliably as S&B, and I do have a couple of cases of it on hand if it is needed. Big advantage with it is, it is cheap too- even if it does smell like a mattress on fire when you shoot it. And no need to resort to duckbills (even though I have a 20" 870 barrel with a 70's vintage A&W Diverter installed on it) or spreader chokes in the process.

It's been fun and educational playing with all this stuff, and the experimentation never stops. Right now I am looking for a replacement for the late lamented $3/10 round box Estate low recoil 00 load that vanished when Alliant bought out the brand from Blount. I have a new candidate to work on when time allows... Steve, you be quiet 'bout that Fiocchi stuff now.

Thanks for the article, Dave, as always,

lpl/nc
 
:)

Seems Lee and I have come up with some of the same conclusions.
One is certainly entitled to spend more monies - sometimes NOT getting the desired result - you get the logo'd gear and bragging rights tho'

Or One can spend less monies, end up with better results than desired and hoped for. Might not get the logo'd gear, but with the monies saved one can buy sharpie markers and write whatever you want on a case.

Bragging rights : pshaw! Fear the man with one gun that knows how to use it- usually spotted with a grin, eat up targets, simple clothes...ain't saying much cause ain't got to.

Run'em

Steve
 
Bob, the difference is obvious. So is that between 7/8 oz and 1 oz. I bought some 1 oz Gun Clubs due to lack of loading time. Shot them today and noted they kicked. Not bad, but noticeable.

As for ammo, we all are stocking up. I've still maybe 100 "Old" Estates, the same each of Winchester and Fed 00, and some 1 buck Federal. I may pick up more next week, waiting on sales.

The Estate is tightest, but the rest is quite usable.

The shoulder's better, but not healed. I see an Orthopedist soon. I think all my Docs are forming a support group. Keeping me alive and functioning must be stressful...

Lee, ammo is as important as choke. I would rather tighten patterns with good ammo than a tight tube.

A&W makes me think of root beer, not duckbill chokes, heh,heh....

Seriously, open patterning ammo has its place also. Prisons, for instance, can use it for area interdiction in mass escapes. For private citizens using it inside their domiciles, the difference in spread between S&B and the high dollar stuff is meaningless.

Fiocchi?

Steve, met a guy recently with a SBE, his only shotgun. It had a 24" barrel and he mentioned it had taken game from quail to deer, shot all of the games and stood ready for HD in his house. He shot it well.
 
Sorry for the Delay. The weekend was a bust. Today was the first chance I got to head down to the indoor range for some patterning. Put about 50 rounds down range with the following results:

Shotgun - Remington 870 Express, 18.5" barrel, IC choke, Synthetic furniture.

10 rounds of Remington 9pellet 00 Buck (WalMart specials) – Average 10 yard spread = 7”. Did not get out to 25 yards with these.

3 rounds of Winchester XX Magnum 3” 15 pellet –patern at 10 yards = 10.5” to 11.5” (no need to put the other 2 down range. They make better paper weights)

15 rounds of Hornady TAP 9 pellet – Best at 10 yards = 2.25”, worst 3.5” / 25 yards = 9”

The rest were made up of 10 rounds Rottweil Blitz slugs, #6 field loads for warm up, and some #4 through the 20ga as it’ll be the combination I’ll be helping my wife get aquatinted with now that I know that they’re light on the shoulder.

The Win XX weren't as punishing as I thought they'd be but as you can see, the shot spread leaves something to be desired. I did have a folded towel over the shoulder to help with the recoil as well.

The disappointing part was that much of the ammo I put through the 18.5" bbl was hitting right of POA @25yds. Slugs were off by as much as 3". Therse were from an unsupported standing position.

The attached pix ar of the Hornady TAP results
 

Attachments

  • h-TAP10.jpg
    h-TAP10.jpg
    47 KB · Views: 154
  • h-TAP10 2.jpg
    h-TAP10 2.jpg
    35.7 KB · Views: 368
  • h-TAP25.jpg
    h-TAP25.jpg
    44.1 KB · Views: 348
Last edited:
Winchester XX 3" Mag, and what managed to find its way back into the range bag (some fell off the bench on the other side of the firing line).
 

Attachments

  • WinXX 3inch 15.jpg
    WinXX 3inch 15.jpg
    43.8 KB · Views: 97
  • shells 11-15.jpg
    shells 11-15.jpg
    43.5 KB · Views: 82
Thanks for the post . I have only used buckshot for folks ( as an le and never a shot fired with a shotgun ) and for geese normally with 4 buck and good results on the " out there " geese . I quit waterfowl when the non lead requirements came in .
 
I wouldn't discount the 5 pellet 00 buck for the .410 folks out there. Granted, at 50 yards it may pattern poorly but all the 10-20 yard patterning I have done with it suggests it is stil pretty devastating at those distances in the guns I have owned. That suggests it is passable for home defense if one does not or cannot own something bigger due to physical limitations, etc.

On the other end of the spectrum I have found my 10 bore to be extremely devastating with buckshot, as well as F shot. There is a balance in there somewhere I'm sure, and I bet it rhymes with "12 bore 00 buck"... Still, if I only had a .410 in the arsenal I'd load it with 3" 00 buck and feel comfortable.

My 2 cents...

gp911
 
I don't know how to express my admiration and gratitude for this Shotgun section without sounding like a fawning sycophant. Every once in a while there's a moment when things come together just right to create something memorable. That's here and now. It's joy to observe and a privilege to participate.

To put that another way, Hotcha! Good stuff. Keep it coming. :)
 
I don't know how to express my admiration and gratitude for this Shotgun section without sounding like a fawning sycophant. Every once in a while there's a moment when things come together just right to create something memorable. That's here and now. It's joy to observe and a privilege to participate.

To put that another way, Hotcha! Good stuff. Keep it coming.

I am in complete agreement.

There are many bad things about the internet, but they are certainly offset by this forum. Outstanding info here.
 
Since it hasn't been mentioned, but I feel very relevant to extreme gun-n00bs like me...

12 gauge shotguns load up to 00 buckshot (or maybe 000 buckshot) which is generally the preferred Home Defense load. 20 gauge generally loads up to 3 buckshot (or rarely, 2 buckshot), with 3 being the preferred home defense load.

Some shotguns can load magnum shot, which is just a longer shell (so more shot). More kick, but if your gun has the option for it, a good idea for home defense. Guns which aren't clearly labeled magnum should NOT use that load even if it fits. Using it in this case may result in catastrophic damage to the gun and shooter.
 
Good stuff Dave, always a pleasure reading your stuff on all things of a shotgunnery nature.

One nit I'll pick though is this one:
going up to 15 in 3 1/2" magnums.

Believe it or not, they go up to 18 pellets in the 3 1/2's. I've done a fair bit of deer hunting with them, but have come to learn they don't do much more than kick harder.
 
Currently, for 12 ga 2-3/4" shells, I'm using either 9 pellets of #00 or 6 pellets of #000. It turns out that if you have to use standard wads because you can't afford to buy slug/buck-specific components (overpowder cards/wads without petals, teflon wraps, etc.), your best bet between #00 and #000 is the #000 because it'll fit better inside the shell using standard shotcup wads and not cause the shells (dimples in the plastic hull from the pellets bulging out) to hang on the way into the chamber, a no-no in a life-threathening situation. I'd go with the other recommendations in this thread based on your situation.

Anyway, the thing about using #00 versus #000 from a reloading standpoint is that you may want to drop your powder charge on #000 slightly, because 9 each of #00 is roughly 1-1/8 ounce, while 6 each of #000 is just under 7/8 ounce. If you don't change anything when going to #000 (assuming Hodgdon Universal or HS-6), you'll end up with a throaty, loud discharge, and it may negatively impact your grouping. I'd choose grouping over scaring the perp and other people.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top