Will someone explain to me how shortening the grip makes it better for smaller hands? The diameter's the same, the trigger reach is the same...
Ah, but they're NOT! (Woulda thought you knew that already). The USP Compact series has a slimmer grip than the Full size, and a slightly shorter trigger reach as well.
That folks, is not the HK USP.
Boats obviously knows his 1911's, but his very own statement:
"If you do a decent inspection of the 1911 you are thinking of purchasing, (bring a snap cap or five to check feeding, ejection, how the extractor holds a round against the breechface), you will need no reliability work."
shows that you have to know more about the 1911 out of the gate than you do the USP. All you have to do with the USP is check to see if it fits your hand, and if you can live with the DA trigger. Period. End of story. No "detailed inspection" (of NIB pistol) no careful scrutiny of the angle of the shell to the breechface, etc... you just buy it!
Sure, everything breaks, and lemons happen, but if it does, you just stick it in a box and send it to HK and they fix it. And of course, you want to know all you can about your pistol, but you're not going to NEED to learn the tricks and tweaks just to make/keep it running.
I bought a USP45 many years ago with very little knowledge of them, other than HK's reputation. I have never had a malf of any kind with it. I learned about it over time, with experience, because I wanted to. I can completely detail strip my USP, but I never HAD to. (except to switch the safety to "left-handed")
Had I gone out and purchased a 1911 instead with the "newbie" experience level, who KNOWS what I would have gotten! I have seen guys at the range, sitting at the bench with their tools, working on their 1911's because they had a malfunction. I doubt there's a 1911 owner out there who doesn't carry tools with them on every range trip, "just in case".
The 1911 is a great pistol, and the most customizeable pistol in existence... But that doesn't make it the "easiest, simplest to maintain" pistol out there. It may be for you, but that's because you have a lot of experience doing so.
For routine maintenance, the USP is an easier pistol to deal with for someone who doesn't know either pistol.