bottlerocket
Member
So I picked up some once fired brass from a friend and after checking it out last night, some of the shoulders have dents in them. Are these trash now or are they ok to fire and let re-expand in the headspace?
Dented shoulder?
- Thread starter bottlerocket
- Start date
- Status
bottlerocket
Member
Jasper1573
Member
- Joined
- Dec 28, 2010
- Messages
- 320
Concur...when I first started reloading, I was using too much sizing lube, and dented a lot of brass around the shoulder. Disappeared after the first shot. Then again, it depends on how "dented" the brass is...if it is severe, I would pitch it. The one in the picture is border line to me, but others may have better opinions.
bigedp51
member
Just out of curiosity are they Winchester cases fired in a shorter than normal barrel.
(Its a unburned ball powder question)
(I have a 16 1/2 inch Contender pistol with a butt stock added) 
(Its a unburned ball powder question)
(I have a 16 1/2 inch Contender pistol with a butt stock added) T Bran
Member
BOTTLEROCKET
Looking at your pic id say no problem itll iron itself out load and shoot then full legnth resize after that you probably wont be able to find that spot on the case again.
HAVE FUN
T
Looking at your pic id say no problem itll iron itself out load and shoot then full legnth resize after that you probably wont be able to find that spot on the case again.
HAVE FUN
T
bottlerocket
Member
Its actually all mixed brass, some Federal, some Remington and some Winchester. I'll press a few and se how they go.
oldreloader
Member
it looks like a lube dent to me. I'd load it and fire it.
bottlerocket
Member
Thanks for the additional advice guys! Gonna be loading it here shortly 
trapper500
member
My guess is lube dents not a problem when shot the dent will be gone . may aught go a bit easier on the lube
bottlerocket
Member
@trapper500
I usually take it easy on the lube. Cases were like this when I got em. I've never had a problem with hydraulic deformation.
I usually take it easy on the lube. Cases were like this when I got em. I've never had a problem with hydraulic deformation.
Oohrah
Member
Load it up and shoot it ! Likely if you picked this up at the range the dent could have come from the case hitting an object when it got extracted and ejected. The dent will be gone with the next firing.
Strongbad
Member
Have they been resized? Do they still have spent primers in them? That case to me looks like it has been fired, but nothing else. If the case had been fired the dent if it were caused by lube would have ironed itself out. If it happened WHEN the round was fired, it's mostlikely due to a low pressure load that failed to completely seal up the chamber.
amlevin
Member
Lube dents like this should be no problem. On the topic of too much lube, I have found that some dies don't seem to like much of any lube. I have a Redding die that dents almost every case even if using Unique and only put a minute amount on the base of the case. I also have a Lee die in the same caliber that won't dent cases even if I slather on the lube.
The Lee die has a relief hole in the shoulder area to let excess lube escape and the Redding die doesn't, it traps lube and accumulates it as more cases are run through it. Needless to say I now rarely use the Redding die.
The Lee die has a relief hole in the shoulder area to let excess lube escape and the Redding die doesn't, it traps lube and accumulates it as more cases are run through it. Needless to say I now rarely use the Redding die.
dagger dog
Member
My buddys ill fitting AR upper dented brass just like that. He gave me 100 rnds or so 'I'm still loading them.
Load 'em and shoot 'em !
Load 'em and shoot 'em !
Sport45
Member
Walkalong said:
I've read that before about low pressure causing dents and it's always made me wonder. Is there a time after the powder has ignited that there's more pressure outside the case than in it?
rcmodel
Member in memoriam
Not more pressure.
More like no pressure at all.
Large magnum cases, or over-bores like the 25-06 can blow powder out of the case mouth before full ignition occurs, and powder grains can migrate back against the shoulder before full burn & pressure can expand and seal the case in the chamber.
It is far more likely with very slow burning magnum powders, or reduced loads.
rc
More like no pressure at all.
Large magnum cases, or over-bores like the 25-06 can blow powder out of the case mouth before full ignition occurs, and powder grains can migrate back against the shoulder before full burn & pressure can expand and seal the case in the chamber.
It is far more likely with very slow burning magnum powders, or reduced loads.
rc
Huckelberry75
Member
As previously mentioned, that looks like a lube dent. When you go to reload them, just remember that a little case lube goes a long way.
- Status
