Doctor's Inquiry Re Gun Ownership

Status
Not open for further replies.
I asked my Dr for a blood test for lead, just to know, since I shoot lead bullets and reload. Test was normal, and it led to a brief discussion; the Dr used to reload etc.
This is the second post I'm seeing here about getting one's blood checked for lead. Are there guidelines for when it's likely to be necessary etc? I do not plan to do reloading but I might shoot at indoor ranges sometimes, which I gathered from the other post could be more likely to result in lead problems compared to outdoor shooting.
 
"When this question was on a form I had to fill out for my first time seeing a doctor I took the bottle of white out I had and whited out the question on the sheet."

Haaaaaa, that is great! :)

Wonder how many people carry around a bottle of white-out, maybe not a bad idea for doctor visits...
Maybe the receptionist has White Out.
.
 
Last surgery I had turns out the doc and all the staff there are shooters,

My insurance agent, and very good friend, has taught me well, by his silence, to remain mute on all matters relating to firearms ownership.
 
Casual shooting contributes minimal lead to your body. If they were worried about your lead levels why don't they ask you if you smelt lead....say for fishing lures or jigs. Why don't they ask if your in industrial construction? Your probably exposed to more lead while installing Christmas lights( excluding you guys that cast and live at the range) than shooting.
 
"When this question was on a form I had to fill out for my first time seeing a doctor I took the bottle of white out I had and whited out the question on the sheet."

Haaaaaa, that is great! :)

Wonder how many people carry around a bottle of white-out, maybe not a bad idea for doctor visits...
<chuckle> I almost always have white out in my briefacse, folio or knapsack. Not only for impromptu paperwork, but for filling in the dots on sights when needed.
 
I've never been asked but my default would be not to answer either way. If I say no then it marks me as a house to invade since it's assumed I'm unarmed. If I say yes then it marks me as a house to rob when everyone is away to steal guns. I prefer being an unknown quantity. I know this is supposedly confidential information, and they might tell me it's perfectly safe to answer because of confidentiality. To that I would say, "Yeah, sure. Just like swiping a credit card is always completely secure":rolleyes:
 
I have seen this question evolve over the past several years. It used to be blatant, "Are there guns in the home?" Now it is much more appropriate. "Do you feel safe at home? Are there Any Conditions which make you feel unsafe or uncomfortable?"

But I have always answered, "Yes we have guns and everybody in the home has been trained to handle them appropriately."
 
The only one of my doctors that has any idea I own guns and shoot is my Eye Doctor. When we were discussing my getting the Cataract Surgery, she told me it can be done to optimize longer distance or short distance (reading), but not both, unless I opted for the high dollar type implant that is NOT covered by my HMO. I told her I needed "Clear vision from 25 to 100 yards". She chuckled and said she knew what I meant. Worked out very well.
 
WhiteOut, these days is a heroine overdose.
I have no problem lying to a huge corporate conglomerate. The answer on a cookie cutter form is "no".
To a human physician face-to-face? I'll suggest he/she might need surgery to replace their nose to it's own business.
 
My doctors are all avid duck hunters.
The pediatrician we use is an old, Jewish doctor that has been practicing for nearly 50 years. We compare pics of our new guns every time I see him.
I can find a new doctor just like I can replace Target for shopping.
I have guns and I see no need to lie about it. I pay State Farm extra on my homeowners to insure them so how exactly could I keep it a secret even if I wanted to. My name is on paperwork every time I buy a new gun. If a conglomerate doesn't want my business then I am good with that.
 
Health insurance has little or no similarity to homeowners or motor vehicle insurance. Where I get my health insurance is restricted to the limited offerings of my employer. If I could afford to shop around, I would. The insurance I do subscribe to limits the practitioners I see through the use of 'networks' In network, fine. Out of network, unaffordable.
And no, surrendering my 25 year career and pension to find a more reasonable health plan is not going to happen.
 
Insurance companies dictate some of the questions that doctors ask. These days, they ask if you feel safe in your home or feel depressed as part of an emergency room visit. One time yearly they ask me for a questionnaire to be filled out. No gun questions are on the questionnaire. I have never been asked about guns during the interrogation part of an emergency room visit. I see my family doctor and a couple of specialists regularly. Two of the three are gun owners.
 
I don't mind at all if my doctor knows that I have guns. He has seen at least one on my hip. What I don't want is for that information to be on any records accessible to just any "authorized" bureaucrat coming down the pike. If he ever asks, I will assume that he as been directed to "for the records," and the answer for the records will be "No."
 
When my doctor asked I became very uncomfortable with her and got a new one in the same company. The new one even started asking me all sorts of personal questions, and I thought it was just chit chat until I realized she was entering into their computer, I stopped answering and now I keep it very short with her.

I only really go in for the occasional checkup anyway. And I do NOT allow them to put my records in 'the cloud' which they require you to sign before they can put them on there.
 
Both my doctor and dentist ask me about my gun ownership every time I go. It is usually in the form of "So... did you buy anything cool over the last few months?"

Both of them shoot and one reloads so our discussions are very different than some of the ones here.
 
I refuse to answer general questions on medical forms that aren't directly applicable to treating medical conditions - and that's exactly what I tell them. Then I tell them I also don't feel obligated to talk with people calling me with telephone solicitations either - and that's about what their non-medical questions are equal to.
 
Years ago my wife injured herself while horseback riding, not an uncommon occurrence. Despite the fact I wasn't even in town when the accident occurred, that ER doc was hell-bent on domestic abuse. It all worked out in the end once he had to consider the facts rather than his wondering imagination. He tutored me well though, if questions are not directly related to the medical condition in question, silence is the answer.
 
I just got back from my Drs office and the pharmacy with a Charter Arms Undercover Southpaw .38 in a horizontal shoulder rig in the open. And there wasn''t even a raised eyebrow at either place.
 
"The American Medical Association (AMA)(2), American Academy of Pediatrics (AAP)(3), and American College of Physicians (ACP)(4) are urging doctors to probe their patients about guns in their homes. They profess concern for patient safety. But their ulterior motive is a political prejudice against guns and gun owners. And that places their interventions into the area of unethical physician conduct called boundary violations."

This quote is from an editorial:

Boundary Violations ---
Gun Politics in the Doctor's Office

Timothy Wheeler, MD

To repeat Dr. Wheeler's conclusions, these political, idealogically-driven questions are boundary violations which are explicitly defined as unethical in their context.

Makes no difference whether you are questioned by a clerk, nurse, PA or the MD. Such questions are violations, without cause, of the patient/doctor relationship and should be reported to the appropriate state medical association because the violation is ultimately the responsibility of the doctor.

Make it plain to your doctor that two things will happen:

1. Your violation will be reported;
2. Your services are no longer needed.

Doctor/patient relationships terminated by the patient, with prejudice, are no joking matter...and shouldn't be.
 
Well I can say I have never been asked by my Dr. either directly or through a questionnaire about gun ownership. Nor have I ever been asked by my insurance company. Having said that a couple of weeks ago I hurt my back at work and the workers comp contact person asked me an odd question. She asked if I had a hobbies. I said you need to know about my hobbies to which she replied yes do you fish, hunt, or target shoot for example. I found this to be none of her business but choose simply to answer that I use to fish when I lived up north but haven't since I moved here 5 years ago. I was a truthful answer if not a complete one.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top