Brian:
How about this:
If you want to trust your life to a 9mm, be my guest.
If I want to trust mine to a 12 ga, please allow me to do so.
The man came here for opinions, and that's what he is getting.
2 things I always post when I talk about hiking, camping, fishing, canoeing, whatever your outdoor sport, are where I do that sport, from that you can derive that I have very few encounters with Bears or Cats and what I carry for that location. When I hike I go with the KISS principle. I want to enjoy my hike and to do so I carry the least possible.
Seriously the guy said "this is what I got and what are your opinions about these givens".
He has a 9mm and a 38. So I replied in kind to his message with information reguarding a 38 that I carry.
Then I mused that these type of threads often become "carry the biggest thing cause them bars is gonna git yew"
Dr Jones you told him immediately get another gun.... This is in reply to a statement
Please note, these 2 options are the only choices.
Your reply sounds very much like those who run around yelling "Get a Glock" on a 1911 thread.
I can see that dbracin lives in nc and a the possibility of him running into a bear rises with his proximity to the mountains of the western part of nc.
Is he going into wilderness where he might run into bear or mt lion???? I DUNNO...
So I replied to him what he wanted, info for a 442 or PM-9
OBTW My carry rotation includes a 357- S&W 13, a 38spec- S&W 60-4, 9mm-S&W 940, 45 - Sistema 1911, so I should not carry a 9mm I might run into bad guys????
Also many poachers and varmiters use a 22lr, so should they stop using the venerable 22lr and get a new gun???
Kaz_67 has some great info and not what I was talking about... when we respond, respond with what the guy asks for not what you think they need.
You might add what you use for your area but at least answer the original question.