How often should nipples be removed for cleaning?

How often should nipples be removed for cleaning?

  • Nipples should be removed for cleaning after every shooting session.

    Votes: 116 68.2%
  • Nipples only need to be removed for cleaning after every other shooting session.

    Votes: 8 4.7%
  • Nipples only need to be removed for cleaning after 3 – 6 shooting sessions.

    Votes: 7 4.1%
  • Nipples only need to be removed once or twice a year no matter how many times a gun is fired.

    Votes: 10 5.9%
  • If properly greased, nipples can wait 1 year or more before needing to be removed for cleaning.

    Votes: 11 6.5%
  • Nipples still work if rusted in place which proves that they don’t need to be removed at all.

    Votes: 4 2.4%
  • I’m not sure how often nipples need to be removed for cleaning.

    Votes: 14 8.2%

  • Total voters
    170
Status
Not open for further replies.
I think removing the cones for cleaning between stages might be too much, maybe every third stage...:evil:

The posse keeps complaining because I have them on their hands and knees looking for the ones I drop. They need to quit complaining, they are being taught culture and grace.

~Mako

And yes, I did mean stages and not matches...
 
Last edited:
I went with.... If properly greased, nipples can wait 1 year or more before needing to be removed for cleaning. The reason is, I used to clean them after every shooting session, then one day I stripped the cylinder threads thinking I screwed the nipple in straight, cost $50 for a new cylinder!!! I'm not going to re-tap and have weaker threads.... so yeah, I yearly clean them with special care of screwing them back in... However I do clean them after every shooting while the nipples are in the cylinders.
 
Chaz. You are correct.

I make sure the threads are properly handled (anti seize) when I do clean and cease to worry after that.

If others choose to clean between shots, fine! Your guns.
 
I have no idea how often they need to be removed; but I do it each time I clean the weapon. Mainly, I do it because I had a heck of a time initially removing the nipples from one of the guns I purchased. I promised myself that I would never let that happen to any of my guns again. Anti-seize is your friend.
 
...If others choose to clean between shots, fine! Your guns.

Noz,
Now that's an idea I hadn't considered... :evil:

I was in the process of setting up my 18Volt cone removal system with torque limiter and automatic nickel doped anti-seize dispenser. There has to be a market! I'll bet I can sell five before 2016. :rolleyes:

Seriously though, I used to worry about moisture in the threads because I submerged my cylinders when cleaning after matches. You know that I normally use two pairs of '60s as my main match guns and back-ups so I decided to run a test.

I started out alternating between sets at matches, cleaning one set with total dis-assembly and the other with just barrel and cylinder removal. The lightly cleaned guns had the frame groups cleaned with sprayed on moose milk. After a month I realized alternating was going minimize my data so I switched by taking one pistol from one set and one from the other, however I maintained the cleaning regimen I had started for each pistol.

This went on for a little over 3 more months until I accidentally dis-assembled the wrong pistol. I often clean while on my truck's tailgate or on a picnic table after a match while talking to friends. Stupid me...Thinking it was the normally stripped down pistol I was wondering how it had gotten so dirty in the trigger group from just 40 rounds when I realized I had stripped the wrong pistol. I hadn't washed the frame components yet so I decided to hold off on the cleaning until I got home and compare it to the one that had been shot in only two matches (probably 120 rounds). That pistol had been set aside without further cleaning beyond than the simple one I described earlier (I did liberally apply some heavy rust preventative to the exterior, cylinder and bore before bagging it).

The frame internally was filthy, it contained BP residue that had mixed with moose milk and then dried between cleanings and had a black film on most everything. There were even small fragments of copper cap material stuck to the remaining lubricating grease. The hammer/ hand/ bolt/ trigger still had traces of a very sticky molybdenum doped lubricant at the interfaces. This lubricant resists water and won't wash off easily without a soap or detergent so the action still worked without a noticeable difference from the one I stripped after every match.

The mate to it which had been used in two matches and then set aside for the balance of the time was also surprisingly dirty, it just had a lower level of grunge in the "innards."

After removing the cones from both pistols I inspected all of the threaded holes for any evidence of corrosion or water infiltration. I couldn't tell any difference between those two pistols or the other pair which were the ones I removed the cones before submersion.

So after all of that "blather" what is my conclusion? Just as you said, if you use a quality anti-seize compound on the threads you're not going to have a problem even if you submerge your cylinders on a regular basis to clean.

However I always use two brushes to rigorously scrub the exterior of the cones during my cleanings. One is a very stiff bristle brush to clean the sides and the cone "pocket" on the cylinder, the other is a small brass bristle brush I use to assure I have cleaned the cap seating surface down to the metal.

Later,
Mako
 
When I get around to cleaning the interior of my pistols I find, as you described, a lot of grunge. However since I clean between matches with a moosemilk made from from Ballistol, the grunge is a slick slimy mess. I infrequently find cap fragments. To remove the mess, I hold the gun under a cold water faucet until the visible grunge is gone, blow dry with an air compressor, spray with fresh Ballistol and button her up for another go around.
People grossly over think the care and cleaning required.
 
I guess the mechanically challenged should not remove the nipples too often! :banghead:

Haha :p .... I am some what mechanically challenged... Just a few months ago I stuck a screwdriver through my hand while replacing a double pole breaker. I'm pretty scarred up from self mutilation. lol Though that cylinder stripping was from being in a hurry, my bad.... It's not hard to strip the cylinder, those Pietta threads and some of the hardware is too soft to my liking.
 
i'm gonna throw in with the once a year gang IF the nips are lubed with anti -seize.

as stated by another poster ...crack 1/4 turn just to check on threads and tighten to snug.

i fired close to 100 shots and checked ...i pulled one nip, just a slight powder coat of soot on the face. threads were all still clean with anti-seize.
cleaned the cap side with a pipe cleaner after cleaning the cylinder, then set in the oven on 150' for eight minutes....go to go!

i feel pulling them out each and every time may produce thread wear & increases the chance of cross threading them upon retightening working with mild steel here....& bad eyes;) just my 2 cents.....

gizmodog
 
Mine aren't removable. I just wash them while I'm in the shower. ;)
 
I have heard it stated that C&B shooters develop a more intimate relationship with their revolvers then the suppository (cartridge) shooters, so I guess the nipple pulling thing must be part of it. Not for me. As I said before, after a shooting session sometimes all my guns get is a quick whore's bath. I don't have time to shave their legs too.:evil:
 
I do them after every shoot.

Maybe not a definite need to do but on the next shooting I never have any problems either.
 
Don't think anyone has posted with my particular 'cheat' for keeping the threads on the nipples clean - PTFE plumbers tape.

Remove the nipple, clean the threads, wrap some PTFE tape round the thread on the nipple and screw them back in. Repeat 6-12 monthly depending on use.

Works for me - YMMV.......
 
Wrapping the threads with Teflon tape works well? I would have thought that melting could be an issue.

So do you wrap the threads with tape and still use some anti-seize? r s Teflon tape all that is needed?
 
Don't think anyone has posted with my particular 'cheat' for keeping the threads on the nipples clean - PTFE plumbers tape.

Remove the nipple, clean the threads, wrap some PTFE tape round the thread on the nipple and screw them back in. Repeat 6-12 monthly depending on use.

Works for me - YMMV.......
Shoo the Moon,
Are you really, really sure there is enough clearance for teflon tape on straight threads? Tape works great with tapered pipe threads but there isn't enough clearance for it with a thread like a 12-28 Uberti or a Pietta 6 X 0.75mm.

If you remove the cone you will probably find there isn't any tape down in the threads.

Anti-seize works better and is inexpensive.

Regards,
Mako
 
i just take the hawken outa the stock,put back end in bucket hot soapy water,put patch over bristle brush,run it up and down till its clean,let dry and lil patch with oil on till next time.run patch through before loading
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top