I love REVOLVERS-!

[Ed Bulldog]

There is something about a wheel gun
Practical - Simplicity - great for the professional and the civilian

I come to this site to learn.

QUESTIONS:
For the J FRAME FANs:
For the LCR FANS
For the TAURUS FANS
1) why did you chose your revolver-?
2) how to you EDC-?
3) what would you or not change change-?
4) your next revolver purchase-?

THIS IS SUPPOSE TO BE A POSITIVE THREAD:

For this Old Dawg
1) Because I was brought up a Snubby and it is a CQC tool - I could only afford a Taurus 605 357 Poly
2) it is my always firearm - cross draw OWB or IWB - when it was my BUG, pocket strong side.
3) change the trigger - not change the reliability factor
4) LCRx in either 38 or 22LR

How about you-?

Thank you

 

[skoro]

I've carried a S&W 642 for more than a dozen years. Goes in my right front pocket whenever I leave the house. Rests in a Mika pocket holster and has a CT laser sight. I keep it stoked with +P Speer Gold Dots, which have a fine reputation in police work. My carry is fine for my threat profile. Not a universal formula, though.

 

[Brutus54]

I have both revolvers and semi autos but the mechanics of how both single and double action revolvers work to me is a engineering masterpiece. They are a tiny handheld machine that are only getting better as tolerances and machining capabilities keep improving.

 

[chicharrones]

There is something about a wheel gun
Practical - Simplicity - great for the professional and the civilian

I come to this site to learn.

QUESTIONS:
For the J FRAME FANs:
For the LCR FANS
For the TAURUS FANS
1) why did you chose your revolver-?
2) how to you EDC-?
3) what would you or not change change-?
4) your next revolver purchase-?

THIS IS SUPPOSE TO BE A POSITIVE THREAD:

My first centerfire concealed carry gun was a Taurus 85UL (.38 +P) with Crimson Trace grip. I bought it before the Ruger LCP and it's kin conquered the pocket carry world. Sure, the Kel-Tecs led the pack, but they hadn't set the pocket carry world on fire like all of its copies have.

After many years of semi-auto pistol pocket carry, I did come back briefly to pocket revolvers with my Charter Arms Undercoverette in .32 magnum. And that led to the purchase of a Ruger LCR in .327 magnum for my wife.

As far as carry, all my pocket guns ride in a leather pocket holster of some sort or another. Edit to add, I chop the hammer spur off my pocket revolvers and make them DAO by removing the single action notch on the hammer.

If the recently released S&W .32 magnum j-frame revolver would have been available when I was shopping for the Undercoverette, I would have bought that instead with its great sights and slapped another small Crimson Trace laser grip on it (like this one). Personally, I don't have a use for the oversize Crimson Trace grips that make pocket carry harder to do.

 

[gconang]

I love revolvers as well. I used to just like 1911's, Glocks. But I stumbled into a S&W model 36 once and been hooked ever since.

 

[Tallball]

1) Why did you chose your revolver? I started with a Taurus Model 85 in the late 1980's. Currently I usually carry a S&W 642. Now that I'm older and more experienced, I prefer a hammerless revolver with an aluminum frame for CC.

2) How to you EDC? Usually OWB around 4:00. Depends a lot on weather and activity. I'll even wear a flat 9mm IWB if I have to.

3) What would you change about revolvers or carrying them? Nothing. Out of a bunch of options, my lightweight snubs are my preference for CC.

4) Your next revolver purchase? Probably another 22lr for practice/plinking. I shoot that caliber more than any other, and don't have a nice 3" DA model yet...

 

[westernrover]

There is something about a wheel gun
Practical - Simplicity - great for the professional and the civilian

I come to this site to learn.

QUESTIONS:
For the J FRAME FANs:
For the LCR FANS
For the TAURUS FANS
1) why did you chose your revolver-?

I chose my L-frame because I found I was far more effective with it than the J-frames I had been using. Why I chose a revolver is the first place was because of the many factors that make it an excellent side arm. The double-action trigger has a simple manual of arms. The unsafe conditions resulting from errors in operating other actions are avoided. The revolver is accurate. The revolver can fire effective cartridges. The revolver's grips can be adapted without compromise for the magazine. Steel revolvers are heavy to provide inertia against recoil making them easier to shoot. Revolvers don't shoot brass all over. Revolvers are extremely fast to reload with moon clips. Revolvers can have capacity comparable to automatics like the 1911. Revolvers can have excellent triggers. Revolvers will hold a red dot sight fixed to the non-reciprocating frame and barrel. Revolvers can fire bullets with meplats and ogive profiles that need not regard the feed ramp or feeding. Revolver cartridges can have large case capacities to accommodate slow and progressive powders. Revolvers in good order are less prone to malfunctions particularly those due to magazine or ammo problems. A second trigger press resolves most malfunctions. Revolvers are fine quality arms, not plastic. Revolvers are American.

2) how to you EDC-?

I remember to take it with me every time I leave the house.

3) what would you or not change change-?

My skills.

4) your next revolver purchase-?

More training. For the hardware, I sometimes think about a lighter revolver like a 3" KC or Viper. I've even considered another j-frame for ankle carry or shoulder holstering which could be good when seated in the car. I am able to practice drawing and firing my L-frame from the waist while in the car. It works but is not easy. It's also super loud fired in the car (be sure to double-up). Other times, I want an N-frame. The L-frame is the right balance, and I do not think I will change it.

 

[Anchorite]

There is something about a wheel gun
Practical - Simplicity - great for the professional and the civilian

I come to this site to learn.

QUESTIONS:
For the J FRAME FANs:
For the LCR FANS
For the TAURUS FANS
1) why did you chose your revolver-?
2) how to you EDC-?
3) what would you or not change change-?
4) your next revolver purchase-?

THIS IS SUPPOSE TO BE A POSITIVE THREAD:

For this Old Dawg
1) Because I was brought up a Snubby and it is a CQC tool - I could only afford a Taurus 605 357 Poly
2) it is my always firearm - cross draw OWB or IWB - when it was my BUG, pocket strong side.
3) change the trigger - not change the reliability factor
4) LCRx in either 38 or 22LR

How about you-?

Thank you

You left out the Colt fans. I won’t hold that against you, my friend. I carry this Agent about 90% of the time. Front pocket, strong side. Loaded with wadcutters. 20% more capacity than the J-frame / LCR and old school cool. What’s not to like ? I also have a few J frames (442, 49, 340PD), but the Colt gets the nod most often. I even have a few DS and a Cobra. I guess I like the smaller frames snubbies. Had and sold an LCR. I would get another LCR if the right deal came along.

 

[Rockrivr1]

I love revolvers as well. I used to just like 1911's, Glocks. But I stumbled into a S&W model 36 once and been hooked ever since.
View attachment 1250164

Same! I have a huge soft spot for revolvers, especially vintage S&Ws. I just picked up a beautiful M36 yesterday. Don’t think I’ll carry this but I could easily if I wanted too. I’m looking at a vintage M60 later this week as well

As to the OP I’ve pocket carried a 642 for a long while. Never felt under gunned with it.

 

[GEM]

Repeating myself - the J frame type gun is for pocket carry situations. I don't see them for belt carry offering much compared to a semi. I understand their limitations and the J frame life style argument that the risk probably will be handled for many by a single opponent gun. The more intense situation is not seen as happening (until it does) but that risk is discounted. I understand they are harder to shoot so have practiced and trained with them. There is no HATE just realism.

 

[Dave DeLaurant]

Both are good, accurate guns, except I'm no fan of the stupid "safety" lock holes.

The Airweight is a joy to carry, the 3" M60 is easier to shoot. Truthfully I'm about equally inept with either much beyond 7 yards.

Five shot capacity seems suited to me. It's a constant reminder not to blaze away under stress and to make each shot hit. Also a reminder that every round fired in public flies with a lawyer attached.

I once shattered my left forearm and lacked the hand strength to work the slide of my Glock for three months. That's when I began to appreciate the superiority of revolvers when restricted to one-handed manipulation.

 

[defjon]

I switched over after an injury and surgery.

 

[Old Dog]

3" Colt King Cobra. Best trigger on any production handgun I've purchased in the past thirty years or so. Carry in a George Bowers pancake strongside. Would prefer a luminous dot on front sight, but I can live with the gold bead (or brass, whatever). No more revolver purchases planned (well, maybe a Colt Viper). Or if I could ever find a minty 3" S&W Model 13 to replace my beater one...

Oh, wait -- this isn't a S&W J-frame (I have some), a Ruger LCR (tried on, didn't care for it) or a Taurus (have had some good ones) -- never mind.

 

[sgt127]

I carried various duty guns. 1911 and then a few Glocks. A 642 was my bug for over 25 years.

Same with off duty. It changed up. But, probably carried more than anything, a 3” model 65. A Ruger SP101.

Now, retired, I carry a Kimber K6xs more than anything.

 

[GEM]

BTW, if semis were banned - my belt gun would be my SW 632 327 Magnum. Six shots, manageble in quality 32 HR Mag. I can shoot the 327 but they are a beast. Boom and flash. I found for my little ol bod, I didn't like concealing a SW Model 19. The J frame 32 cal gun fits me fine. Yes, it has a lock but that never did anything bad in quite a few rounds.

 

[Pat Riot]

QUESTIONS:
For the J FRAME FANs:
For the LCR FANS
For the TAURUS FANS
1) why did you chose your revolver-?
2) how to you EDC-?
3) what would you or not change change-?
4) your next revolver purchase-?

I am a J frame fan. I haven’t owned an LCR or a Taurus.
I have an S&W 442 that I carry a lot. I have other Snubbies, but the 442 is one of my CCW guns.

1) why did you chose your revolver-? I chose the 442 because it would fit in my pocket and ride an ankle holster easily.

2) how do you EDC-? I pocket carry in a Sticky or an Uncle Mike’s pocket holster unless I have it in my jacket pocket. I also ankle carry it in a DeSantis Apache ankle holster.

3) what would you or not change change-? I am considering a new grip for it. The Uncle Mike’s factory boot grips are great, but my wrist isn’t crazy about it any more.

4) your next revolver purchase-? Not sure. I just recently traded for an S&W model 66-5. This will be a fishing, hunting, hiking carry gun.

I love revolvers. I like my semiautos, but my revolvers are my favorite handguns.

 

[Styx]

1) why did you chose your revolver-?
2) how to you EDC-?
3) what would you or not change change-?
4) your next revolver purchase-?

I'm more of an L-frames and N-frame fan than a J & K frame-sized fan for carry. That said, I still like and carry smaller revolvers. To answer your questions:


1) Why did you choose your revolver?
I chose a 2.5" S&W L-frame because I was a movie buff in the 80s and 90s. I recall seeing large-frame, short-barrel snubbies in a few movies and always thought they were bad-arse. I reckon that's partially why none of my revolvers have a barrel over 3". Practicality-wise, the weight allows me to more comfortably shoot. 38/.357 with less recoil while not being too heavy for EDC. The shorter barrel allows me to EDC 365 days a year, and I can also carry OWB concealed without having the barrel flashing.

I also almost always pocket carry a 357 LCR or Taurus model 85 as a BUG. I purchased the LCR 13 years ago at my LGS. I don't remember anything else about that day, what my mindset was, or why I chose the LCR, but I know I made a great choice. I chose the Taurus 85 because it was forged stainless and a little over $200 NIB shipped.


2) How do you EDC?
I have an IWB loop/snap and OWB pancake leather holster for my S&W L-frame 686+. I prefer OWB whenever I get the opportunity, but I will switch to IWB when my outfit calls for it for concealment purposes. I carry a split-six style speedloader pouch on my weak side.

I typically EDC the LCR or Taurus 85 in a jacket pocket or the pouch of a hoodie without a holster. I keep a speed strip in my pants change pocket.


3) What would you or would not change?
The only things I change are the sights and grips. My eyesight is bad, so I like a big front tritium day/night sight if applicable. I have boot grips on all of the revolvers I carry. I would NOT change any springs. I prefer to keep the stock springs for increased reliability and longevity.


4) What's your next revolver purchase?
A 2" Taurus 650 to replace my Taurus 85 because it has a concealed hammer and the ability to change the front sight. Other than that, probably a 2.5" Ruger GP100 7-rounder. Then a 2.5" Colt Python.

 

[WisBorn]

1) why did you chose your revolver-?
I started with a 642 with CT grips. Shortly after I added a 442, which is my favorite ccw.
I started with a revolver because of reliability and a safe carry option. A j frame because of S&Ws quality reputation.
I have carried and still carry several different semiautomatic pistols also. Different types of firearms for different types of attire and situations. I call my 442 my comfort carry. It works with most attires and situations along with ease to draw from a pocket.

2) how do you EDC-?
I prefer pocket carry.

3) what would you or not change change-?
I think trying different platforms and carry options is important. You need to find out what is right for you!

4) your next revolver purchase-?
I'm really thinking that my next revolver will be a classic. I would like to find a k frame like a S&W model 10. If I see a Taurus snubby 45 Colt, 44special I would pick it up.

 

[lee n. field]

There is something about a wheel gun
Practical - Simplicity - great for the professional and the civilian

I come to this site to learn.

QUESTIONS:
For the J FRAME FANs:
For the LCR FANS
For the TAURUS FANS
1) why did you chose your revolver-?

Taurus. "Affordability". Availability (Local gun monger occasionally has non-stupid prices on used stuff.) Currently mostly carrying one or another 856, for the extra round over a more typical 5 round snub. Continue to keep the LCRx .38 around because it's smaller and lighter, and the design is "cool" (as we used to say back in the day).

2) how to you EDC-?

AIWB in either a JM Custom Kydex AIWB, or a Dark Star Gear Apollo. Pocket carry sometimes, in Desantis Nemesis. I've got a Mika pocket holster that's nice, that's "around here somewhere". (I may order a new one.)

3) what would you or not change change-?

I almost always change out grips, for something I like better. Sometimes change front sight, if that's an option on the particular gun.

I have never felt need or desire to change out springs to lighten the trigger pull. Learn to run your gun.

4) your next revolver purchase-?

Ideal would be a 2.5-3" 6 shot .357 with adjustable sights. Local Gun Monger has a used GP100 that meets those specs, but is asking close to new price on it. And it's blued, not stainless.

May not be a next revolver purchase. I've got a low priority desire to pick up a .22 revolver, for shooting CB caps.

THIS IS SUPPOSE TO BE A POSITIVE THREAD:

For this Old Dawg
1) Because I was brought up a Snubby and it is a CQC tool - I could only afford a Taurus 605 357 Poly
2) it is my always firearm - cross draw OWB or IWB - when it was my BUG, pocket strong side.
3) change the trigger - not change the reliability factor
4) LCRx in either 38 or 22LR

How about you-?

Thank you

 

[.38 Special]

1) why did you chose your revolver-?
2) how to you EDC-?
3) what would you or not change change-?
4) your next revolver purchase-?

1) I carried a Model 19 in .357 for most of my life. I consider it a nearly perfect compromise between size, weight, and power - and I shoot it very well. Lately, I have been carrying a subcompact Glock in 10mm, and lately, I've become unsure why. I should probably switch back to the revolver.

I do have troubles with my lower back, and some days I really am not up for carrying much weight. The 340PD is my answer, on those occasions.

2) OWB, under a coat, jacket, or silk shirt. For many years I preferred IWB, under the assumption that it concealed better. OWB is far more comfortable, though, and "concealed is concealed". I occasionally get made fun of for carrying a snub OWB, but I know of no other way to be adequately armed in near-total comfort.

3) I probably would not have bothered with the Glock. My reasoning, at the time, was sound enough - accuracy and power for "mass shooting" scenarios against riflemen in body armor - but lately I have the luxury of not ever needing to expose myself to big crowds in large venues. There is very little that I cannot handle with a Model 19 that I would be able to handle with a Glock.

4) Nothing, probably. I have enough good revolvers. If Ruger introduces a five-shot Redhawk in some sort of .50 Special I will be there first thing in the morning. And if I ever stumble across a Detective Special at any kind of reasonable price here in California I will jump on it. Otherwise, well, I have enough good revolvers.

 

[StrawHat]

I prefer to carry a 45 ACP. This one,



In this holster,



It presents like this,



My favorite combination!

Kevin

 

[Ed Bulldog]

I prefer to carry a 45 ACP. This one,

View attachment 1250272

In this holster,

View attachment 1250273

It presents like this,

View attachment 1250274

My favorite combination!

Kevin

Beautiful

 

[adcoch1]

I just recently sold my Taurus that was j framed size. Probably going to regret it, but I haven't felt it yet. It was a good one. I love revolvers, and k frame s&w seems to be what I'm collecting, have 6 at the moment and am looking at two more.. well maybe 3 more if I can find the right 2"... I carry a 3" sp101 In a DeSantis OWB or one of the k frames in another OWB DeSantis. When hunting it's one of my ruger 44 mags, either my 7.5" redhawk in an old uncle Mike's worn weak side butt forward, or my sbh in a home modified cross draw setup. I have a 3" 22lr birdshead revolver on the way, and a bfr or ruger srh big bore is on the search list. Pretty much love all revolvers!

 

[tubeshooter]

I'm a big fan of revolvers.

I don't own them exclusively, and I'm secure enough to where I don't feel like I have to defend them against every detractor and naysayer.

I also recognize the upside (and downside) of the other side of the fence.


Don't plan on buying any more anytime soon (never say never). Like another said earlier - I already have plenty of good revolvers.

 

[Riomouse911]

I am another one who could probably swamp a canoe if I piled all my revolvers in it. From 22 to .45C, they have always been loads of fun.

I have owned three Taurus DA revolvers, a 6” satin nickel model 66 .357 I bought in the late 1980’s, a 94 .22 and a 941 .22 WMR. I never had an issue with any of them, though the trigger pulls on the two rimfires were a bit stout.

I will admit that I no longer ccw a revolver, I toted several over the decades with confidence but have moved exclusively to autos about seven-eight years ago. For those who carry their revolver(s) and work to shoot them well, I will never find fault in their choice to do so.

Stay safe.