3KillerBs
Member
DH loves his M&P so much that he's getting the compact too.
How? Marketing and a Match barrel? The M&P had the replaceable backstraps before the XD did, and now the late to the game XD has it and now it's light years more advanced? What does it do... hover and use self guiding bullets?The Springfield XD-M is light years more advanced than the M&P.
Posted by George Hill:
How? Marketing and a Match barrel? The M&P had the replaceable backstraps before the XD did, and now the late to the game XD has it and now it's light years more advanced? What does it do... hover and use self guiding bullets?
You can put a match barrel in the M&P.... That's not light years either. That's just a barrel made to closer specs.
However, three years later the XD is still outselling the M&P in the civilian market, despite Smith's considerably greater national and worldwide marketing "muscle".
1. Noticeably better trigger on the XDM. Shorter take-up and reset, lighter and less mushy. Best trigger of any polymer pistol I've ever fired.
Clear advantage XDM.
2. Noticeably superior match barrel that comes standard. Yes, you can put a match barrel in an M&P---but it's an OPTION that you will pay substantially extra for.
Clear advantage XDM.
3. Higher magazine capacity. I typically carry three magazines, which gives me three extra rounds with the XDM. Every little bit helps if and when a critical situation arises.
Advantage XDM.
4. Better slide serrations on the XDM, and has serrations near the front of the slide that the M&P lacks---which adds up to better gripping of the slide when hands are sweaty and slippery.
Advantage XDM.
5. Better grip texture on the XDM allows for better handling when hands are sweaty and slippery. I definitely can keep a little firmer grip on the XDM on a hot summer day.
Advantage XDM.
6. Magazine release button on the XDM is better located, better recessed and has better extension for easier reach than the one on the M&P. I can reach the XDM release without having to alter my firing hand grip---can't do that with the M&P.
Clear advantage XDM.
7. Better contruction and quality control on the XDM. Whereas early reports by owners and testers of the new XDM have indicated virtually no problems, when the M&P was released it was plagued with numerous substantive problems, some of which are still reported to be occurring by actual M&P owners.
Clear advantage XDM.
Posted by raz-O:
Ok, I'll bite. The XD-M is NOT ahead of anyone. It does however represent a solid refresh of a design that keeps it very current with some of the better design features of handguns.
where are you getting your numbers, I'd like to see the source. You also seem to have missed all the advertising SA is doing. In just a coupel of months it dwarfs everything I have seen for the M&P in two years.
XD triggers can be made light and smooth, but I have yet to experience a single one that wasn't mushy. The M&P triggers, box stock and worked on, all have a positive break you can feel. If you don't mind the mush, the XD trigger is probably better out of the box. If you don't like mush, it is not a clear advantage.
For the improved reset, you are paying for it. My M&P 40 with a trigger job, new sights, and a match barrel runs me about the same as the XD-M is going for at the moment. If they drop the price after the initial rush, then it is a different issue.
When talking price, the M&P 9pro is a better comparison. good or bad triggers come down to what you like/dislike most in a trigger, and which one addresses it better. Me, I can't stand mush and I like a positive feeling reset. The M&P does that better.
Not really, like I said above, you pay for that barrel. the XD-M costs more than a regular XD. You want an apples to apples comparison, the 9L or the 9pro are more appropriate, and they are producing some GOOD accuracy out of the box. I doubt the XD-M is doing much better. It's an OPTION you are paying for on an XD or an M&P. Both offer it from the factory. The two brands, however, differ on their opinions of where it is best to introduce that option.