Quantcast
  1. This site uses cookies. By continuing to use this site, you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Learn More.

M1 carbine for home defense?

Discussion in 'Rifle Country' started by megatronrules, Mar 24, 2003.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. megatronrules

    megatronrules Member

    Joined:
    Jan 5, 2003
    Messages:
    803
    Location:
    The sunshine state,Florida
    How would this gun do for home defense? I plan to use it loaded with the jacketed soft point ammo thats out there in .30 carbine. I've read this is a very effective gun/load combo for close up defense and i would incline to agree. I basicly figure that it packs a lot more of a punch then any of my handguns up close am I right? I also think it will be safe to use in a house with the soft point loads. My house is an older one here in florida and as a result has all cement walls unlike newer homes,so I don't feel over penatration to be an issue. So what do you guys think would you use the above mentioned gun/ammo combo for home defense?
     
  2. Marko Kloos

    Marko Kloos Moderator Emeritus

    Joined:
    Dec 20, 2002
    Messages:
    2,587
    Location:
    Enfield, NH
    I think the M1 Carbine is a fine little social rifle....lightweight, good sights, fast and nimble to handle, and very decent capacity. I would feel very well armed with an M1 for home defense, or any other social purpose requiring ballistic intervention at 100-200 yards.
     
  3. Will Fennell

    Will Fennell Member

    Joined:
    Dec 24, 2002
    Messages:
    748
    Location:
    Sharon, SC USA
    It will work, but don't fool yourself....

    I grew up with an M1 carbine as the family truck/house gun....it was the rifle that was always around, because it was HANDY. It went everywhere with dad and I. It was my first centerfire rifle that was mine....:cool:

    And while it was really fun to shoot[we always seemed to have a ammo can full o'ball handy] and to a 8 year old, it look really kewl, I quickly learned that I had to shoot animals several times to have much effect. I'm not talking bull elephants, I mean run of the mill stuff that needed killing around the country side. Feral dogs, 'coons, bobcats, etc. When you got to wild pigs, and I don't mean big boars, but just 30-60 lbs shoats, I would need to put sometimes 3-5[!] rounds into the chest cavity do slow them down much. When they got much over 100 lbs, we are still talking pigs folks, not big "wild boars" like most envision, I would have to shoot them to pieces to anchor them. Yup, I'm talking soft point/hollowpt hunting ammo, not ball.

    BTW, post-mortem investigation showed that the soft points didn't expand much, and didn't perform overall much better than ball.

    Dad only let me shoot 1 deer with it, and after that multi-shot fiasco [first shot was right through the heart lung area, and the rest peppered around the body as I tried to stop the wounded animal form escaping to die a slow death] and subsequest blood trailing session[ we found the young buck, but it took awhile]. Dad upgraded my hunting armament to a single shot 30/30 with a weaver 3x that killed things alot better.

    Now I'm not saying you need a single shot 30/30 for home defense, but don't fool yourself into thinking you have a semi-auto death ray! Look into the current crop of ammo, and see if anything has improved much......surely somebody has something better now than I had in the '70's[ ok, I'm feeling old now]. Make sure your rifle works well with your mags.....I found that the mil surp 15 rounders worked much better than most 30 rounders. I remember going through 3-4 aftermarket 5 round hunting mags to get one to work well. Looking at my old carbine, I think that if I were to set it up now for a HD rifle, I would open up the rear peep site a little....make it a little more of a "ghost ring" instead of the relatively small aperture. You can probally find a surplus site to experiment with. If your rifle is a milsurp, Olde but Goodie, check your stock.....mine was knocked over a few years ago, and took a fall. The stock broke cleanly in half behind the trigger guard. I replaced it with a wood surplus stock, but I think that if I were going to use this rifle more seriously, I would look into a synthetic stock from Choate or some such maker.

    M1 carbine is a really neat rifle, that is most of all, VERY HANDY. Its fun to shoot, lite weight, low recoil and easy to teach newbies to handle. Great for kids with the proper training. An old former WW2 sergeant told me that is why lieutenants liked them so much....and the sergeants kept their Thompsons;)
     
  4. benEzra

    benEzra Moderator Emeritus

    Joined:
    Dec 25, 2002
    Messages:
    8,536
    Location:
    Down East in NC
    The M1 is an excellent choice. JHP would be superior to softpoint or ball, though, IMO. I believe Winchester makes a Silvertip in .30 Carbine that would be a good option.
     
  5. 106rr

    106rr Member

    Joined:
    Dec 24, 2002
    Messages:
    529
    Location:
    CA
    No Silvertip -- but they do load a hollow soft point or something like that. It's a soft point with a little hollow cavity in the tip. Either the Rem SP or the Win HSP will work. They expand from .55 to .63 and penetrate 12 to 18 inches.
    Good Luck
     
  6. yzguy

    yzguy Member

    Joined:
    Dec 27, 2002
    Messages:
    589
    Location:
    Fl
    I love my dads Enforcer:
    [​IMG]
    (click to enlarge)

    if you get close enough to the BG you can catch him on fire with the ball of flame it puts out!! :)
     
  7. Matthew_Q

    Matthew_Q Member

    Joined:
    Feb 18, 2003
    Messages:
    295
    Location:
    Austin, TEXAS
    Megatron,

    Don't feel you've made a poor choice because of the above comments... The m-1 carbine is a great weapon for self defense. Packing more energy at 100 yards than a .357 Magnum at the muzzle is nothing to scoff at. But ammo choice counts bigtime!

    Ball tends to overpenetrate, and doesn't expand well. For home defense, I second the suggestions above. Find some softpoints or some soft hollow points. Those will play hell on predators of the two-legged kind.

    I have my carbine in a folding stock, under my bed, and have a 15 round mag loaded with softpoints in the nightstand... although my loaded 1911 and .357 Mag in the nightstand, too, would likely be reached for first!

    Congrats on the neat gun! I'm sure you'll love it's handiness and light weight.
     
  8. Tom C.

    Tom C. Member

    Joined:
    Jan 15, 2003
    Messages:
    734
    Location:
    Southern Maryland
    M-1 carbine as home defense weapon

    With decent hollowpoints, the carbine makes a very good home defense weapon, in my opinion. Others agree. Jim Cirillo, of NY stake-out squad fame, thought the carbine was the most effective long gun they used.
     
  9. beckrodgers

    beckrodgers Guest

    m1

    Bobby had a nice rebuilt import [he sold it for 3 times what he paid,to pay the chiropractor],he did not like it till he bought some reloads hps that blew big holes in a standard Mempho phone pole erected to shoot at,2&3 shot pops tore that pole up. 50&100 yds. The rifle always shot reliably ,he thought it was the ammo,those reloads did really well,hollow points.
     
  10. curt

    curt Member

    Joined:
    Jan 8, 2003
    Messages:
    378
    Location:
    NOVA
    beckroders are you talking M1 Garand or M1 carbine, its hard to imagine a carbine tearing up a phone pole at 100 yds. that would certainly be impressive performance from HPs. But what do i know i've only punched paper with mine.
     
  11. Scooter

    Scooter Member

    Joined:
    Mar 26, 2003
    Messages:
    5
    Location:
    Los Angeles
    As any long gun is easier to aim, especially under stress, that a handgun, something light and short yet sturdy like the M1 Carbine would be an excellent choice. And, if you run out of ammunition, you can always club them with it!:)
     
  12. Bart Noir

    Bart Noir Member

    Joined:
    Mar 20, 2003
    Messages:
    887
    Location:
    Mossy part of Washington
    Scooter says "you can always club them with it!" Well, if you have the later design forward handguard ring, you can fix bayonet and do more than club!

    Bart Noir
    A pistol packing piece of paramilitary paranoia.
     
  13. beckrodgers

    beckrodgers Guest

    Curt

    m1 Carbine. A man at a pawn shop in Olive Branch, Ms sold his personal reloads, had 3 ,50rd bxs, when we went back there has been difs between owners ,the man w/the hot loads had moved back to Pennsylvania, the shop has been closed for a while,yes it was impressive, surely some one here has seen something similar,we dont reload Yet. Thanks
     
  14. Sven

    Sven Senior Member

    Joined:
    Dec 20, 2002
    Messages:
    3,808
    Location:
    Los Gatos, CA
    Check out my thread here on THR about putting a red dot optic onto an M1 Carbine.

    Disclaimer: I'm currently deep into a carbine obsession from which I know I will eventually escape and move on to something else, but for now, man I _love_ those rifles.

    Lightweight, compact, fun to shoot. I'm planning on a detailed ammo roundup sometime in the next year. Maybe I'll buy some Ham and shoot it up.

    Here's another THR thread wherein we are discussing ammo for the carbine.
     
  15. Backwoods

    Backwoods Member

    Joined:
    Dec 24, 2002
    Messages:
    166
    Location:
    Ohio
    Well, I've got my old Underwood carbine hiding under the bed, 15 round mag loaded with softpoints and a Choate stock. I don't feel undergunned at all and yes, I do have a handgun handy too.

    I could substitute an AR, a 20" barrel Mossy 500, a 45 cal lever action, or several others, but why? The little M1 will likely do the job just fine, we could argue pros and cons of any weapon for hours, the use of any gun has tradeoffs.

    Don in Ohio
     
  16. Mannlicher

    Mannlicher Member

    Joined:
    Dec 24, 2002
    Messages:
    3,430
    Location:
    North Central Florida and Miami Florida
    I do not hesitate a moment, when I pick the .30 Carbine to put in the truck. I have taken a number of hogs, and feral dogs with it. I alternate ball and SP in my 15 round mags.
     
  17. JShirley

    JShirley Administrator Staff Member

    Joined:
    Dec 20, 2002
    Messages:
    20,841
    Location:
    Atlanta
    I really like the M1 carbine. In fact, I had an AR15 first, before I bought one. Then I sold my AR.

    One thing to remember- and this is good practice with all lower-powered "intermediate" cartridges like the .30 Carbine, 5.56x45mm and 7.62x39mm- is to use a "controlled pair" whenever possible.

    John

    One hole is good. Two holes are much gooder.
     
  18. Johnny Guest

    Johnny Guest Moderator Emeritus

    Joined:
    Dec 20, 2002
    Messages:
    3,721
    Location:
    North Texas
    When you come right down to it - - -

    Self defense may be the ONLY thing for which the M1 carbine is really suited. They ARE indeed very little handy little shoulder arms, and having a long gun of any kind sure beats NOT having one.

    We recently had a spate of carbine buying going on in my agency. Guys were talking about possible uses, and, much as I like the carbine, I always try to disabuse people of the misconceptions. The .30 USC round is NOT powerful enough to be a sporting deer cartridge. Neither the cartridge nor the arm lend themselves to significant improvement by handloading. The Carbine itself is NOT accurate enough to be a proper varmint arm.

    It is an anti-personnel combo, pure and simple. This was the design purpose--To make it possible to keep enemy soldiers away from secondary personnel more efficiently than a handgun. Worked fine for this. It really was not so good for attack, though some non-traditional troops made it work for the purpose. Let's face it--No human being wants to be shot with anything, and if hit, with anything, will usually stop what they're doing. Mission accomplished. It is possible to place hits (plural) more reliably with a carbine than with a handgun, but let's don't kid ourselves about the immediate result.

    As I say, I personally like the little carbine quite well. No offense is intended toward the weapon itself, nor toward those who use it. But it is neither a .30-06 nor a .22-250. :p

    Best,
    Johnny
     
  19. Blain

    Blain member

    Joined:
    Jan 17, 2003
    Messages:
    993
    The more I look at that new light barreled Bushie AR the more I like it. Though I wonder about the thiner barrel....just how much does it degrade preformance? In terms of accuracy and in terms of heat effects from semi-rapid fire? Sure is nice to have as light a weapon as possible in the AR!
     
  20. curt

    curt Member

    Joined:
    Jan 8, 2003
    Messages:
    378
    Location:
    NOVA
    blain,
    I don't there there is any practical decrese in accuracy with the thinner barrel. Remember you're talking about a 16inch chrome lined combat barrel that will probably still shoot 1-2MOA. In terms of combat accuracy it won't be a factor, in terms of benchrest maybe but that's not what you're talking about with a light 16in barrel. Its more important to have something light that you can keep mounted onehnded while opening doors or doing mag changes.

    Don't know about heat dissapation but i would suspect that might only be a factor during substained full auto fire.

    As soon as i can scrounge up the bucks i'm swapping my M4 profile barrel for a Bushie lightweight.
     
  21. Dr.Rob

    Dr.Rob Moderator Staff Member

    Joined:
    Dec 23, 2002
    Messages:
    14,478
    Location:
    Centennial, CO
    Good choice. Its not a deer rifle. Its not a 22. With HP's or soft points its very similar to a 357 in performance. Hi caps abound, and its not on any banned list. Historically interesting, light and easy to handle. What's not to like?

    Sure its not a 30-30 but niether is a 44 mag in a levergun.
     
  22. feedthehogs

    feedthehogs Member

    Joined:
    Jan 8, 2003
    Messages:
    1,801
    In a truly "home" defense situation due to the close quarters, low light the majority of the time, a great possibility of missing and sending a round thru a window or a wall, a shot gun loaded with bird shot makes the best "home" defense weapon.

    The stats show that the miss rate for handguns and long guns drawn in a point and shoot situation are above 75%. This includes well trained gun owners. Once adrenaline starts pumping, most training goes right out the window.

    Most people don't have the time to carefuly aim and shoot an intruder. Most people have the lights off in the house at night and end up shooting at shadows.

    Granted the sound of a gun discharging will send most intruders running, there are some that will shoot back though.

    To give your self and your family the best protection, a pattern of spray works the best.

    As always, only an opinion.

    The .30 carbine is a fun round for plinking. I have a Blackhawk in that caliber and its a blast to shoot.

    If its your only gun, it certainly is better than not being armed at all.

    Good luck.
     
  23. curt

    curt Member

    Joined:
    Jan 8, 2003
    Messages:
    378
    Location:
    NOVA
    Wow! a 75% miss rate for trained shooter? I'd be interested in a source for those stats.
     
  24. feedthehogs

    feedthehogs Member

    Joined:
    Jan 8, 2003
    Messages:
    1,801
    Get a copy of a book called "Too Close for Complacency".
    The author published a miss rate of 92% at 21 feet or less.

    The Canadian Mounties did a study and found a 88% miss rate.
    NYPD, no surprise, did a study and found a 85% miss rate.
    There are many other studies including ones from the FBI and other agencys you can find with a little looking.

    I site these studies because at the very least law enforcement has to keep current and qualify regularly. The public does not.
    But we all know how poorly most all police officers shoot.

    Being a firearms instructor for 25 years both in the private and professional sectors, the loose stats I have collected from other instructors at training seminars seem to back 75% and above.

    This is only because most all police department and private sector training is inadequate at best.

    Proper technique and lots of practice time training is essential.

    Look at any IDPA or competitive shooter and see the hours and many thousand rounds of ammo they practice.
    And this with no one shooting back.

    Most gun owners spend an hour 4x a year at the range to practice, if that.
    This includes CCW permit holders. Scary, Huh?

    When I do intensive training, including under stress live fire training, most do very poorly at best.

    This has a negative reaction to the shooter in that after getting good at hitting a target, once the stress part starts, they can't hit the target at all.
    I comment they just killed the innocent bystander standing to the side of the assailant.

    The only cure for this is time spent practicing.
    Which adds up to money, which most cops and people don't want to spend.

    Those that do, become part of the small percentage that hit their targets most everytime.

    Its also not like riding a bike. You do forget and reflexes slow down with age.
    Boy do I know that.

    The shotgun just gives you that edge if the right loads and barrel length are used.
    A draw back is it takes two hands to operate.
     
  25. Gerald McDonald

    Gerald McDonald Member

    Joined:
    Feb 12, 2003
    Messages:
    269
    Location:
    Texas
    I have had a couple of M1s, great shooters that were easy to handle but, if mine were the norm I would not want to shoot in a concrete room. The ones I had would ricochet worse than any round I have ever shot. If you missed it would probably hit them on one of the trips around the room if it didnt get you first.
    Gerald
     
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.

Share This Page