Which M1 carbine are you speaking of?
I regard the commercial variants such as the Iver Johnson and Universal as little more than borderline junk. I experienced op-rod failure from a cheaply made cast iron op-rod in an Ivor Johnson crack and fail at the 500 round mark. I replaced it with a forged G.I. op-rod.
I have also owned some military M1 carbine guns in the past and their reliablity has not be good either.
None have been as reliable as the more economically priced SKS or AK series of weapons.
The flimsy magazines are easily damaged and are so flimsy that simply taking off the floor plate of the magazine to clean it will bend the cheap sheet metal floor plate and if you do not straghten it absolutely straight it will slip off under fire and cause a jam to the weapon.
30 round magazines in this gun are noted for being very unreliable and the commercial 30 round magazines are little more than junk. The military magazines are better but still are made of very thin flimsy sheet metal and even they are not 100 per cent reliable even in the more common and somewhat more reliable 15 round capacity.
In combat and hunting the M1 carbine has proven to be a dismal failure first class. Its weak and aenemic cartridge is eclipsed by even the intermediate battle rounds like the 7.62x39 or the small caliber .223.
Its weak operating spring must be immediately replaced with a heavy duty one or else partially riding the operating handle down will result in the bolt not fully going into battery. Ever notice a long time user of an M1 carbine constantly double hitting the op-rod after it runs forward to make sure the bolt closed all the way.
The MI carbines gas system needs a special tool to remove the piston for cleaning. If not kept clean this weapon soon malfunctions. Not a very good system compared to the very reliable and easy take down of the AK or SKS series of weapons.
Accuracy is very dismal with this weapon. Basket ball size groups being the norm on a good day at 100 yards.
The rear sight is staked and the stakes often come loose resulting in a loose rear sight. True, they can often be restaked but what a pain the the rear end to have to go through this.
The safety in the lever type is awkward to use under stress and the older push button safety resulted in people hitting the mag release button instead of the safety under stress resulting in ones losing his magazine in a bad moment and often under fire.
I really can not fathom why anyone would choose this weapon over the Ak or SKS series of weapons. The orginal M1 carbines are archaic collectors pieces that go for big bucks compared to the much more economically priced SKS or even AK series of weapons, and the commercial M1 carbines are little more than borderline junk.
I regard the commercial variants such as the Iver Johnson and Universal as little more than borderline junk. I experienced op-rod failure from a cheaply made cast iron op-rod in an Ivor Johnson crack and fail at the 500 round mark. I replaced it with a forged G.I. op-rod.
I have also owned some military M1 carbine guns in the past and their reliablity has not be good either.
None have been as reliable as the more economically priced SKS or AK series of weapons.
The flimsy magazines are easily damaged and are so flimsy that simply taking off the floor plate of the magazine to clean it will bend the cheap sheet metal floor plate and if you do not straghten it absolutely straight it will slip off under fire and cause a jam to the weapon.
30 round magazines in this gun are noted for being very unreliable and the commercial 30 round magazines are little more than junk. The military magazines are better but still are made of very thin flimsy sheet metal and even they are not 100 per cent reliable even in the more common and somewhat more reliable 15 round capacity.
In combat and hunting the M1 carbine has proven to be a dismal failure first class. Its weak and aenemic cartridge is eclipsed by even the intermediate battle rounds like the 7.62x39 or the small caliber .223.
Its weak operating spring must be immediately replaced with a heavy duty one or else partially riding the operating handle down will result in the bolt not fully going into battery. Ever notice a long time user of an M1 carbine constantly double hitting the op-rod after it runs forward to make sure the bolt closed all the way.
The MI carbines gas system needs a special tool to remove the piston for cleaning. If not kept clean this weapon soon malfunctions. Not a very good system compared to the very reliable and easy take down of the AK or SKS series of weapons.
Accuracy is very dismal with this weapon. Basket ball size groups being the norm on a good day at 100 yards.
The rear sight is staked and the stakes often come loose resulting in a loose rear sight. True, they can often be restaked but what a pain the the rear end to have to go through this.
The safety in the lever type is awkward to use under stress and the older push button safety resulted in people hitting the mag release button instead of the safety under stress resulting in ones losing his magazine in a bad moment and often under fire.
I really can not fathom why anyone would choose this weapon over the Ak or SKS series of weapons. The orginal M1 carbines are archaic collectors pieces that go for big bucks compared to the much more economically priced SKS or even AK series of weapons, and the commercial M1 carbines are little more than borderline junk.
Last edited:
