I bought one several months ago, and it may be the last firearm I would ever give up. I have a well used and loved Ithaca 37 DSPS that I wanted to semi retire. I was in the market for a buy once, cry once pump gun. I opted to get the heaviest and most robust one I could find as I seriously doubt I will ever buy another for the rest of my days, and I'm just 39. Or, if I do buy one, it will just be for fun
I liked that the 590a1 was about as tough as Mossberg makes them and has the same old school look as my Ithaca. The 37 handles like a finely balanced sabre. The 590a1 Retrograde wields like a battleaxe.
If I were a hunter, I would pick the 37 any day. Its just such a fine fitted gun that you dont see made like this much these days. However, I bought the Retrograde to be a home defense Post Up gun. I bought it to take to the cabin or toss in the trunk for long trips where unknown situations might happen. It's a heavy cuss, but it soaks up stout loads like they are nothing. 00 kicks about like 20g bird shot compared to the more robust felt recoil of the 37.
Spendy, but it's probably a pretty good deal if you factor in all the time and extra expense it would take to outfit a stock gun. Sometimes it's ok to spend a little extra for over built fluff. Truthfully, a Maverick 88 will most likely outlive me, but I get a lot more joy out of shooting, and even just dry firing, the Retrograde 590a1.