I guess I'm committed now. These two revolvers represent my entry into the BP world. The Colt 1860 Army arrived earlier in the week; and the 1858 Remington New Army was delivered yesterday. Both were manufactured by Pietta; and ordered from Cabela's.
Not having fired either one, I don't have a favorite, yet. I am initially impressed with the fit, finish, and action of both, though. The bluing is similar on both; but the markings from the case hardening are more prevalent on the Remington. The checkered grips of the Remington feel good in the hand.
The wedge of the Colt did not exhibit any of the balkiness that some people have experienced with the Pietta guns. Two light taps with a rawhide hammer was all it took to remove it.
Not having fired either one, I don't have a favorite, yet. I am initially impressed with the fit, finish, and action of both, though. The bluing is similar on both; but the markings from the case hardening are more prevalent on the Remington. The checkered grips of the Remington feel good in the hand.
The wedge of the Colt did not exhibit any of the balkiness that some people have experienced with the Pietta guns. Two light taps with a rawhide hammer was all it took to remove it.