My saga of getting an AR15 Ciener .22 LR kit to run

Discussion in 'Rifle Country' started by iamkris, Sep 28, 2008.

Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. iamkris

    iamkris Member

    Joined:
    Jan 6, 2003
    Messages:
    2,839
    Location:
    My own little slice of Purgatory
    I like the idea of running .22LR through an AR platform...cheap practice but more importantly to me, it is a good way to have a "cool" factor when I am introducing a youngster to shooting (usually start them off with a single shot Savage Cub and iron sights and then move them to a youth Henry lever action, but most kids become impatient with that pretty quickly).

    I've owned a CZ V22 dedicated upper but there were 2 problems: the bull barrel was too heavy for most kids to lift for very long and I could NEVER get the thing to run reliably. The out of battery discharge that blew the feed lips off of one of the magazines was the last straw.

    I'd love to get a dedicated upper but the $500+ makes it not a priority right now...maybe sometime. I did decide to get a Ciener conversion, even with the reputation of crappy service and iffy quality. From the reports I've seen, many people have perfect reliability in their unit but somewhere around 10-20% (my guess) have significant problems. I'm telling you what I had to do to get mine running...if you have similar symptoms, maybe this will help you.

    I got one of the few that Midway has in stock from time to time and at the dealer price. I installed it in a J&T M4-gery upper with a 16" 1:9 barrel on a DPMS lower with a RRA NM 2-stage trigger. Loaded up the recommended Remington 40 gr HVs, chambered a round and...nothing. The same thing happened with Remington 40 gr, Federal 36 gr bulk pack, Remington 36 gr bulk pack, and Aquila 40 gr. All of the problems below happened with all of the type of ammo I had. At this point, I was ready to throw the thing away, but a sense of pride, stubborness and a real desire to not let it beat me prevailed. So...on with the saga.

    Problem #1 - 75% failure to fire
    There were only light firing pin strikes on the rims. I swapped out the RRA hammer spring with the original hammer spring and finally got reliable firing. The trigger is heavier (moved from about 3-4 lbs to 5-6 lbs) but is still very crisp . Problem #1 solved.

    Problem #2 - 90% failure to extract
    Once I got the thing to fire, 9 out of 10 times the empty case wouldn't extract. On the Ciener kit in area #1 shown in the attached picture, there is a ramped cut in the metal surrounding the chamber that the extractor rides up into. When I would hand cycle shells with the unit out of the rifle, I noticed the ramp kept the extractor away from the rim until the extractor had ridden over the rim. In addition the extractor hook face wasn't square. I used needle files to both square up the extractor face and deepen the ramped cut. Take only a little metal off as you do not want get into the chamber area. Hand cycling and live fire now shows that the extractor is pulling the case out. Problem #2 solved...except now I found the next problem...

    jhfqxv.jpg

    Problem #3 - 50% failure to chamber and failure to fully extract
    Now that the unit was reliably firing and at least starting to get the shell out of the chamber, I found it wouldn't fully chamber or completely extract. There was no problem with the cartridge feeding out of the magazine but it would stop chambering about 1/2 way in. After manually pushing the bolt forward and firing the cartridge, it would start to extract then and then and the extractor would slip off the very small rim of the case. The first thing I did was take a .22 bronze brush, oil it and really scrub the chamber area (area #2 in the picture). I also lubed the guide rails and polished the bottom of the bolt in area #3. With that treatment, an unfired round would easily drop in the chamber and come out with a fingernail under the rim. With that, the unit feeds, fires and extracts about 99.5% of the time. But that led to...

    Problem #4 - 20% failure to eject
    In about 1 out of every 5 shots, the empty case would not eject and got hung up in the works. Often I had to take the upper and the unit out to get it cleared. I notice that the top of the magazine feed lips showed that they had been rubbing on the bolt (area #4 in the picture). Also the left feed lip is right next to ejector. I stoned the top of the feed lips and tried it...same results. I suspected the feed lip was interfering with ejection but didn't want to bend it because the mag fed reliably. I ordered 2 Black Dog Machine mags from Brownells and tried them (picture of the magazine shown below). 100% reliable!!! Everything works exactly like it should. Plus, these mags are 1) cheaper than Ciener's, 2) hold more, 3) have a bolt hold open feature, 4) look like a regular AR mag, and 5) are smoke colored so you can see how many rounds you have left. I threw the original magazine, #5 in the picture, in the reject bin...only to be used if i get amnesia. Problem #4 solved.

    mjbu6h.jpg

    So in the end, I probably shouldn't have put this much time into it, but I now have a 100% reliable unit with no additional expense...just some frustration and problem solving. It is reasonably accurate (3-4" at 50 yards with a red dot...probably better if I would mount a magnified optic). It runs the best with the bulk pack stuff, so that is a benefit.

    I think Ciener either needs to tighten up the design or tighten up the manufacturing/quality control...obviously some dud units are getting out. My advice to you? Buy a dedicated upper, wait for some of the other units coming out (like CMMG). If those are not possible, buy a Ciener...and cross your fingers.
     
    Last edited: Sep 28, 2008
  2. Cacique500

    Cacique500 Member

    Joined:
    Aug 4, 2003
    Messages:
    1,275
    Location:
    Georgia
    Wow...

    I have a Ciener kit for my S&W M&P15 and the only thing I did was replace the spring with a Lakeside spring. Did that before I even tried the kit for the first time based on other peoples problems. I put it in and went on my merry way. I've got 2500 rounds through it with not a single issue.

    Sorry you had to go through all that...
     
  3. Hoppy590

    Hoppy590 Member

    Joined:
    May 25, 2006
    Messages:
    4,277
    Location:
    MA :(
    hmmm Ciener seems to be the only major game in town and yet i rarely hear shinning reviews. ( most are either about rediculous long waits, or problems such as above)

    reconsidering my future purchase

    are these problems common in other .22 kits, kinda part of the game? or is it just ciener?
     
Thread Status:
Not open for further replies.
  1. This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
    By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.
    Dismiss Notice