Butter said:
There's a bit of anthromorphism going on there, if that's what I can call it, to ascribe to a lump of steel, wood and plastic all sorts of maniacal attributes that doesn't take into consideration the intent behind the use of any gun.
Excellent post, Butter. Plus "anthropomorphism" (sic) is one of my top five favorite words. You get big points in my book for that.
But I think that is exactly the point, and you hit it. People extrapolate their own fears and internal bad thoughts into the tool, and thus anthopomophisize it. We have lots of other ways of saying it more commonly - "guns don't kill people, people do" - but that's the same thing, just less clinically spoken. And then they extend that to project their internal fears into anyone who is an NRA member or supporter. "Hoplophobia" is a real mental disease as I've learned; and some medical professionals are starting to classify it as such.
Here's my one claim to fame: You have probably not seen this move, but it was by a famous director and actor: "Below" by Darren Aronofsky and starring Bruce Greenwood ( if you don't know his name, he's the guy who plaid Captain Pike in the new "Star Trek" movie - he's good). Darren was the guy who made "Pi" years ago and he also made the recent hit "The Wrestler" with Mickey Rourke.
His buddy who helped him write "Below" (one of their intermediate flops between the good films!) asked me to help him understand guns and how they worked so he could write it into the script accurately. Unfortunately, he asked me this after a dinner party in my apartment in NYC.
. I went to the bedroom and brought back a 1911 type pistol, walked him through the manual-of-arms a few times (Condition 1, 2, 3, why there's no "half cock" in acutal use, etc.) a few times while we sat on a couch. After about 20 minutes of this, an English person who was at the party and in the room noticed, and flipped out. She saw there was an unloaded, legally owned and licensed, gun being analyzed in a safe manner and pointed in a safe direction and she lost it. I mean "lost it."
Now, let me add two things:
1) the handling of the 1911 by Bruce Greenwood in the submarine movie "Below" are relatively authentic based on ME! (too bad it was a bad movie).
2) This "freak-out" woman is actually a prominent NY journalist, and she's neither American nor open minded to guns, and she's what sets the tenor and tone of our national media debate and dialogue on guns.
It may come as no shock, but despite being close friends for years, she's refused to return my friendly and non-confrontational emails for over 10 years. I'm so no longer shocked.