recoil: HK vs glock?

[badbadtz560]

I'm sure this must've been asked somewhere before.. but I can't seem to find a response with first-hand experience

Has anyone compared say.. a Glock vs HK w/ its recoil system?

Let's just say p2000/p2ksk/uspc/p30 vs g17/19

How's the repeat shot when comparing HK recoil system vs low bore axis of glock?

Now let's say it's for a .40 .. g22/23 vs the same guns in .40

Now let's say it's for a .45 ... same thing, but add hk45c in the picture...

any comments on the recoil comparison? I'm assuming they're around the same class size as a general comparison.. w/o gettin down to the nitty gritty dimension comparisons

 

[stevek]

My HK USP 45C seems a tad softer shooting than my Glock 30. But it also has a bigger grip and longer barrel/slide...

 

[HKIWB]

I didn't notice a major difference in recoil between my USP .40c and a G23. I don't care for Glock triggers, so any benefit from the lower bore axis is lost on me.

I compared my high-axis HK45 with the lower-axis M&P 45, a gun that I've heard described as a product-improved Glock. I noticed no difference in speed or accuracy of my double taps, but did notice that the M&P was less accurate during slow fire.