Looking to pick up a .357 revolver with a 4-5" barrel and I'm pretty sure I've narrowed it down to these 2. I conceal carry a 442 so I am familiar with the S&W controls and usually like to keep things uniform. The .357 will be used for home defense, open carry, target use. TRR8 can mount a light, holds one more round, and has a dark finish which I prefer (I don't really like stainless guns). On the other hand the 686+ is much less expensive. But I don't want to buy the 686+ and then wish I had shelled out more for the TRR8. Has anyone made a similar decision and which did you go with?