SAA - is there a more beautiful revolver?

Who hath summoned me? :p

The SAA is certainly in the running. Which is funny because William Mason designed it in a matter of months, in a rush after the army rejected the 1871-1872 Open Top. I would say the top three most beautiful revolvers are all neck and neck, depending on the eye of the beholder. For me, the SAA and 1860 are a photo finish.

For the SAA (and its derivatives) I would have historically said the 4¾" was the best of the bunch.

1739288148648.jpeg

The 7½" guns have really grown on me, like this USFA Nettleton.

1739288161569.jpeg

All of the "open top" Colt percussion guns and cartridge conversions are gorgeous sixguns. The Open Top cartridge model will always hold a special place in my heart.

1739288276994.jpeg

But nothing is sexier than the 1860.

1739288301502.jpeg

A close third has to be the Triple-Lock and to me the fixed sight guns are the most attractive, with four inchers taking top honors. Though I only have this 6½" 2nd model .44 Special.

1739288367513.jpeg

Not a revolver but to me #4 overall is the 1911.

1739288410466.jpeg

In revolvers, it must be one of the early S&W single actions. Here's my factory engraved Uberti Schofield from Taylor's.

1739288452683.jpeg

Though a case could be made for any of them. The #3 Russian is pretty spiffy, though not my favorite for running fast.

1739288514314.jpeg

1739288526059.jpeg

It's interesting that all the best looking handguns were designed 100years ago or more and all within a 60yr timeframe. Nothing since comes close. Anything that does was directly derived from one of these five.
 
It seems we are having a beauty contest with revolvers instead of women. I have to put the winner as the 1860 Army with It's smooth flowing lines that makes the 1851 Navy and the other precious ones look rather chunky. First runner up Is the 1873. DA revolvers are only in the running. A few of those make the finals but nowhere close to getting the crown. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder so It's up to you what is your personal favorite. Even if the Colt's win in the beauty department I much prefer shooting Rugers over the Colts because of their sights.
I also think the conversions are out of the running for beauty queen. It makes me think of taking a GMC truck and sticking a Ford grill on it.
 
Sterling: the grips are poplar, spalted from some horse fencing here on our farm. The cylinder line is the mark left by the New Model bolt, just the way it worked out in the notches. Best regards, Rod
 
Who hath summoned me? :p

The SAA is certainly in the running. Which is funny because William Mason designed it in a matter of months, in a rush after the army rejected the 1871-1872 Open Top. I would say the top three most beautiful revolvers are all neck and neck, depending on the eye of the beholder. For me, the SAA and 1860 are a photo finish.

For the SAA (and its derivatives) I would have historically said the 4¾" was the best of the bunch.

View attachment 1250514

The 7½" guns have really grown on me, like this USFA Nettleton.

View attachment 1250515

All of the "open top" Colt percussion guns and cartridge conversions are gorgeous sixguns. The Open Top cartridge model will always hold a special place in my heart.

View attachment 1250516

But nothing is sexier than the 1860.

View attachment 1250517

A close third has to be the Triple-Lock and to me the fixed sight guns are the most attractive, with four inchers taking top honors. Though I only have this 6½" 2nd model .44 Special.

View attachment 1250518

Not a revolver but to me #4 overall is the 1911.

View attachment 1250519

In revolvers, it must be one of the early S&W single actions. Here's my factory engraved Uberti Schofield from Taylor's.

View attachment 1250520

Though a case could be made for any of them. The #3 Russian is pretty spiffy, though not my favorite for running fast.

View attachment 1250521

View attachment 1250522

It's interesting that all the best looking handguns were designed 100years ago or more and all within a 60yr timeframe. Nothing since comes close. Anything that does was directly derived from one of these five.
Where is the LaMat!!!!
 
Even if the Colt's win in the beauty department I much prefer shooting Rugers over the Colts because of their sights.
Gotta agree, Doubleh, but a flat top Ruger has a look all its own. .357 NM Flat Top...I'll never forgive Ruger for putting the owner's manual on the barrel's side....other than that....It's a good shooting, well balanced six-shooter. Best regards, Rod

1739292299721.png
 
The Colt SAA is certainly one very beautiful revolver but my vote goes with the Colt Model 1860:
KwzLaSf.jpg

xbjGj5k.jpg
 
I think the Colt Model P is, if not the top very close, to the most aesthetically pleasing guns there is. A colt 1851 Navy is a fine looker too. I always have admired the Ruger Blackhawk as well.
 
I will also say that personally, the only other revolver that gives the SAA a run for its money aesthetically, is the Remington 1890.

ONSV10056__01.jpg


Not a fan of the aesthetics of any percussion revolvers, if I'm honest. I have a few modern revolvers that I also find very aesthetically pleasing, but for different reasons.
 
Don't have most of them but here goes:
Percussion- Colt 1862
Cartridge SA- Bisley, S&W 3 rd Model Russian
Cartridge DA- Models 1917, both Colt and S&W, newer- Python and S&W Model 1955 Target.
 
With the 7.5” barrel, I’d agree.

But the K-38 has to be the most handsome revolver. The revolver equivalent of a classic Hi-Power.
 
Back
Top