"Well maby I'm just getting slower,or smarter as I age.I would have had more confidence in a short stick and my speed 20 years ago.As I get older,I have learned that I'm not nearly as good as I thought I was just a few years back.
I would agree you may be fairly effective against a folding knife,provided you see the knife before it is in you.Now days I always carry a Kahr P380 in a front pocket holster.I can put my hand in my pocket fairly fast and can keep it there on a long dark walk to the truck.
I can see part of your ease of carry arguement.My P380 gets carried more than my Glock 36 even though it isn't as effective.
I would just hate to see some of you guys put too much faith in a lesser weapon because of an over inflated confidence in training.I would certinly rather train with my weapon of choice than not, but most attacks are a surprise and don't allow for fancy maneuvers.Personally if I am knocked down and someone is on top of me trying to cut me or bash my head in,I would rather shoot them than try to hit them with a stick."
The Zimmerman case is a very good example of just why it may be a bad idea to shoot someone even if he's on top of you, if he's unarmed. It's called having other options than shooting. Would he be in trouble if he'd broken some bones in Martins hands or collar bone? Collar bones break amazingly easy, and takes that person out of action. When the fight goes to ground, it's time to get dirty.
I'll be honest, my main interest in non firearm weapons is that I live in Maryland. CCW is not option for me. But even if it were, I'd still want other options available to me for many reasons. Sure, a Kahr in the pocket is a nice thing, but in the end it may not be worth it if you make a mistake. The man in Florida is going to be broke for a couple of decades to come because he shot an unarmed man and there are questions. The contributions will not cover it all. Then, even if you squeak by in the criminal trial, there's the civil unlawful death suit, and still more legal fees for years to come. Law firms don't come cheap. So far, I was not in danger of a suit or charges the two times I used my stick on a low life who was not armed, but tried a strong atrm robbery. I went home each night after talking to the police and slept like a baby.
Then there's the travel issue.
Being retired, my better half and I are spending our kids inheritance by taking the trips we've always wanted to. Rome, Karen wanted to see the Cistene Chapel ceiling and I wanted to tour the collosium. Then it was fun riding around London in the two decker busses, and doing the tourist thing at the British Museum and bed and breakfast inns out in the country driving around the Cotswolds and seeing Stonehenge on the way back to London. It was Europe, but I was not unarmed. This next year we plan on going to Paris and then touring some countryside. Unfortunately one can't carry a gun on a European vacation. But a stick/cane can go anywhere. And if need be, a short stick can be fabricated from almost anything. When I was in the army, we had a course in improvised weapons. Some of the examples they gave us of a short stick was a lower rung kicked or stomped out of a wood chair, a towel rack pulled off a wall, a broom leaned against a wall and stomped on, mop bucket wringer handle unscrewed, a stout length of tree branch. For a strike weapon against sensitive targets, any end on hard object can be used. A tightly rolled up magazine, Sharpie marking pen, or my favorite, the AA mini mag flashlight.
If someone was on top of me, and that someone was an unarmed person, I'd really rather have my AA mini mag for some strikes to the collar bone, elbow, eye socket, ear/temple/mastoid gland, family jewels, kidney punches, than shoot him. I'd even rather have s small sharp knife to make a few strategic cuts. You don't have to outfight they guy, just be mean and underhanded enough to really hurt him. That means having something right there already in your hand when the bad stuff hits the fan. You can't walk around with a gun in your hand, but who's gonna say jack about a pen, carpenters pencil, or a mini mag, or a short stick?
Even if the impossible happened, and Maryland passed a CCW law, I'd still go with and practice with my non forearm weapons just to give me the non lethal options. It's a heck of a lot less headache to beat the ever loving dog stuff out of a punk trying to rob you than shoot him. And you'll go on with your life with no problems or lawyers fees.
Sometimes a gun is not the right solution to a problem. This is why cops carry a stick.
But your most important tool is the lump of gray stuff between your ears. Use your head to use options. Life will be easier.
Carl.