RBid
Member
I've owned an XDm 3.8" 9mm (full grip) and currently own a G19 (Gen 4). I've fired the M&P 9, and have a fair amount of dry fire (with Snap Caps) with the Sig. If I had to pick a favorite, the trivial answer would be the M&P. Despite an unspectacular trigger, it is an extremely user friendly weapon. It's extremely flat shooting, feels great in the hand, runs well, and is better in live fire than dry. Honestly, I notice the trigger stuff in dry fire, but it works great in live fire.
Despite my enthusiasm for all of the other options, and despite being a Walther PPQ & P99 fanboy at heart, I recently transitioned to Glocks as my go-to. I don't prefer them over a PPQ or M&P. My choice was for one simple reason: resource availability. I was getting annoyed with searching online for mags and custom holsters for the PPQ, and the discussion around Federal or State level capacity restrictions made me think about availability in a more urgent way. Since I picked up my G23, I have already been able to add 5 standard, plus 22 and 31 rd mags for it, as well as an IWB and OWB holster. 2 of the mags were orders, the rest was all off the shelf. Because of frame commonality, my G19 uses the same holsters. In one month with the G23, I was able to acquire more resources for it than I found in a year with my PPQ, and I didn't go broke doing it (I will admit that I paid $100/mag for the 22 and 31 round mags, which I don't regret).
While I don't believe that Glocks are superior firearms to the other options listed here, I have become a believer that they are a better buy, for any person who performs well with them. They are very easy on owners.
No Koolaid here. I recognize that there are many options that equal Glocks, pistol-to-pistol. They really win big only in market support.
Despite my enthusiasm for all of the other options, and despite being a Walther PPQ & P99 fanboy at heart, I recently transitioned to Glocks as my go-to. I don't prefer them over a PPQ or M&P. My choice was for one simple reason: resource availability. I was getting annoyed with searching online for mags and custom holsters for the PPQ, and the discussion around Federal or State level capacity restrictions made me think about availability in a more urgent way. Since I picked up my G23, I have already been able to add 5 standard, plus 22 and 31 rd mags for it, as well as an IWB and OWB holster. 2 of the mags were orders, the rest was all off the shelf. Because of frame commonality, my G19 uses the same holsters. In one month with the G23, I was able to acquire more resources for it than I found in a year with my PPQ, and I didn't go broke doing it (I will admit that I paid $100/mag for the 22 and 31 round mags, which I don't regret).
While I don't believe that Glocks are superior firearms to the other options listed here, I have become a believer that they are a better buy, for any person who performs well with them. They are very easy on owners.
No Koolaid here. I recognize that there are many options that equal Glocks, pistol-to-pistol. They really win big only in market support.